The PH GOTY 2010 voting thread

The PH GOTY 2010 voting thread

Poll: The PH GOTY 2010 voting thread

Total Members Polled: 105

Battlefield: Bad Company 2: 22%
F1 2010: 14%
Gran Turismo 5: 41%
Mass Effect 2: 7%
Red Dead Redemption: 16%
Author
Discussion

Gun

Original Poster:

13,431 posts

219 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
Okay, here we go, it's time to get voting. Please vote for your choice of game of the year, voting will remain open until midnight on New Years Eve.

Edited by Gun on Sunday 26th December 18:12

newberry

473 posts

199 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
Fallout new vegas.

C2james

4,685 posts

166 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
newberry said:
Fallout new vegas.
I think it's a bit late mate.

Skii

1,630 posts

192 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
F1 2010 for me, easily the best F1 game I've played yet.

Altrezia

8,517 posts

212 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
This poll is madness. I don't understand how GT5 or F12010 are better than RDR or ME2. (And this is coming from a sim-racer who loves GT5!)


Egg Chaser

4,951 posts

168 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
Altrezia said:
This poll is madness. I don't understand how GT5 or F12010 are better than RDR or ME2. (And this is coming from a sim-racer who loves GT5!)
Remember, this is PH. wink

Norbury90

6,897 posts

207 months

Sunday 26th December 2010
quotequote all
Of those, I only own F1 and GT5. F1 is pooh. So, GT5 it is!

SteveC123

54 posts

187 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
I really don't get all the fuss over GT5?

I speak as someone who went out and bought a PS3 a couple of weeks ago mainly so I could play this, and well... I hate to say it, but it's not a patch on Forza 3?

Yes it's very pretty, (although I'm not so sure it's that much prettier than Forza in a lot of respects), and has a good spread of cars, but gameplay wise it's not in the same league... and that's what's most important surely?

Then there's the tuning section - all the cars to date I've had on there, the receipe is the same:

'Enter racing class... realise standard car isn't quite good enough... apply the same mods which cost the same whatever they're for... try same race again, win'.

BORING, and the handling model isn't all that either.

If anyone is desperate to try it out for themselves, I've no intentions of keeping the PS3!

(Conversely, I found Medal of Honor Tier 1 absolutely brilliant on it, if a little short in one player mode)

newberry

473 posts

199 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
C2james said:
newberry said:
Fallout new vegas.
I think it's a bit late mate.
Why, have I misunderstood ?

Original Poster

5,429 posts

177 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
newberry said:
C2james said:
newberry said:
Fallout new vegas.
I think it's a bit late mate.
Why, have I misunderstood ?
Unfortunately, yes. smile

We did a voting post not long ago where everyone said their top three, this Is the actual voting instead of nominations.

chris watton

22,477 posts

261 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
SteveC123 said:
I really don't get all the fuss over GT5?
In a way, I have to agree, and I have bought and played through every GT game. Having a poll about the best game when this has just been released will have quite a bit of bias in it, as right now, everyone is playing and drooling over GT5 - reminds me of Robbie Williams winning the 'Singer of the Millenium', beating Sinatra, Elvis etc, just because he was at the height of his (short lived) popularity!

GT5 is very good and I like it a lot - and I will no doubt spend many more hours playing it, but I have to say, I am disappointed with the graphics - Grid and Dirt 2 look better on the PC - and I haven't witnessed load times this long since the Spectrum ZX

newberry

473 posts

199 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
Oh right, never mind then.

Tsippy

15,077 posts

170 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
Altrezia said:
This poll is madness. I don't understand how GT5 or F12010 are better than RDR or ME2. (And this is coming from a sim-racer who loves GT5!)
Madness?............


THIS

IS

PISTONHEADS!!!



  • Kicks Altrezia into a well*


hehe

Animala

777 posts

163 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
YES!!! Mass Effect 2 at the bottom of the poll were it belongs!!! biggrin

Mattygooner

5,301 posts

205 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Errrr, Fallout New Vegas is better thanverything on the list, has it been left out for being just too good?

GT5 came out a month ago and is not even finished!


But B:BC2 is excellent, Vietnam included!

Bu Fallout is still better!

Edited by Mattygooner on Tuesday 28th December 17:13

Gun

Original Poster:

13,431 posts

219 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Mattygooner said:
Errrr, Fallout New Vegas is better thanverything on the list, has it been left out for being just too good?

GT5 came out a month ago and is not even finished!
Only got three nominations earlier in the month and was some way off making the top 5.

LandR

6,249 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Was Dragon Age Origins 2010 ? if so that.

If not then NBA2K11. It's just incredible for a sports game. IGN gave it 9.5


C2james

4,685 posts

166 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Animala said:
YES!!! Mass Effect 2 at the bottom of the poll were it belongs!!! biggrin
how dare you, leave at once!

Mattygooner

5,301 posts

205 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
LandR said:
Was Dragon Age Origins 2010 ? if so that.

If not then NBA2K11. It's just incredible for a sports game. IGN gave it 9.5
Very True, NBA was bloody brilliant.

Mastodon2

13,826 posts

166 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Fallout New Vegas has been the best this year, with Red Dead: Redemption in second. I think I'd be hard pressed to put GT5 in the top 20, and F12010 wouldn't even register!