NSL - 60 or 70mph

Author
Discussion

Swervin_Mervin

4,452 posts

238 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
speedking31 said:
VX Foxy said:
It's worrying that people with driving licenses don't know the answer to this.
So do you have to slow down to 60 here? It's not always clear cut.
Why is that not clear cut? It's a d/c, with a break for a right-turn lane. You think you'd have to drop 10mph for the 10-20m where the carriageway becomes one to accommodate the turn?

cologne2792

2,126 posts

126 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
When entering a local extended junction, with a physical grass verge separating the carriageways, a central refuge and single lanes in both direction the speed limit on my satnav jumps from 60 to 70 mph for the duration of the junction (a few hundred yards) then returns to 60 mph...

V8LM

5,174 posts

209 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
speedking31 said:
V8LM said:
Mr E said:
What's the speed limit on a single lane, one way NSL road (as there's no chance of oncoming traffic)?
60.
Motorway slip roads?
Within the start and end signs the carriageway is deemed to be a motorway - once past the start sign on the slip road you are on a motorway, once past the end sign on the slip you are not. Whether you are then deemed to be on a dual carriageway or one way carriageway is an interesting question. I suspect the latter, where a NSL limit would apply unless indicated differently.

speedking31

3,556 posts

136 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
Swervin_Mervin said:
speedking31 said:
VX Foxy said:
It's worrying that people with driving licenses don't know the answer to this.
So do you have to slow down to 60 here? It's not always clear cut.
Why is that not clear cut? It's a d/c, with a break for a right-turn lane. You think you'd have to drop 10mph for the 10-20m where the carriageway becomes one to accommodate the turn?
I don't think so, but
ziggy328 said:
... the test is if you can roll a ball from kerb to kerb then it's a single.
isn't strictly correct either then.

ziggy328

855 posts

214 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
speedking31 said:
Swervin_Mervin said:
speedking31 said:
VX Foxy said:
It's worrying that people with driving licenses don't know the answer to this.
So do you have to slow down to 60 here? It's not always clear cut.
Why is that not clear cut? It's a d/c, with a break for a right-turn lane. You think you'd have to drop 10mph for the 10-20m where the carriageway becomes one to accommodate the turn?
I don't think so, but
ziggy328 said:
... the test is if you can roll a ball from kerb to kerb then it's a single.
isn't strictly correct either then.
errr...it is. I didn't expect to have to actually say unless there is a break for a right turning in which case you could roll a ball through, but in that instance it is still a dual carriageway given the rest of the road has a central reservation....

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
60.

The clue is in the lack of road separation.

Sushifiend

5,182 posts

137 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
V8LM said:
jurbie said:
I think some of the confusion is caused by the definition of a physical divide. Does there have to be a bit of armco or is a strip of grass acceptable?

I would assume a strip of grass is a physical divide but I've met plenty who claim it isn't which I would imagine makes driving on roads where the armco suddenly stops only to reappear several 100 yards later an interesting experience.

https://goo.gl/maps/8iubDK6xQeC2
Central reservation is a physical divide.
This. There just have to be two separate strips of tarmac. It doesn't matter is they are divided by an armco barrier or grass or a strip of soil planted with carrots.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
Sushifiend said:
This. There just have to be two separate strips of tarmac. It doesn't matter is they are divided by an armco barrier or grass or a strip of soil planted with carrots.
Not sure I fancy picking the carrots.

BertBert

19,039 posts

211 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
VX Foxy said:
It's worrying that people with driving licenses don't know the answer to this.
It's kind of interesting when you read the highway code as the dual carriageway definition is under the multi-lane carriageway section implying that you need multi-lanes to have one.

Also I can't find an official reference to rolling a ball across.

According to a quote elsewhere it could be a flat gap between the carriageways ("land")...

The LEGAL definition as laid down in the Interpretations of meanings for Traffic Signs and General directions regulations 2002
""central reservation" means -
(a) any land between the carriageways of a road comprising two carriageways; or
(b) any permanent work (other than a traffic island) in the carriageway of a road,

which separates the carriageway or, as the case may be, the part of the carriageway which is to be used by traffic moving in one direction from the carriageway or part of the carriageway which is to be used (whether at all times or at particular times only) by traffic moving in the other direction; "
and

""dual carriageway road" means a road which comprises a central reservation and "all-purpose dual carriageway road" means a dual carriageway road which is not a motorway; "
Number of lanes to a carriagway has no bearing on the classification of the carriageway. There are plenty of examples of multi laned, single carriageways around the country, and several examples of single laned, dual carriageways too.

ziggy328

855 posts

214 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
BertBert said:
Also I can't find an official reference to rolling a ball across.
You won't I don't think I used it as an example to answer the question. It does however hold true. A carriageway is defined as a separate road not a lane as you say. The roads therefore need to be separated by something more substantial than road markings. Generally speaking therefore the thing causing the separation would generally stop a ball from reaching the other side. Including carrots!

BertBert

19,039 posts

211 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
They only need to be separated by a space - "land". The question is what is the definition of land!
Bert

VX Foxy

3,962 posts

243 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
speedking31 said:
o do you have to slow down to 60 here? It's not always clear cut.
Derrr...

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
VX Foxy said:
speedking31 said:
o do you have to slow down to 60 here? It's not always clear cut.
Derrr...
Exaclty - it's ALWAYS clear cut!

TwigtheWonderkid

43,367 posts

150 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
ziggy328 said:
You won't I don't think I used it as an example to answer the question. It does however hold true. A carriageway is defined as a separate road not a lane as you say. The roads therefore need to be separated by something more substantial than road markings. Generally speaking therefore the thing causing the separation would generally stop a ball from reaching the other side. Including carrots!
Temporary traffic cones would stop a ball rolling across the carriageway but my understanding is that that isn't enough to make it a dual carriageway. A strip of grass or land or any form of proper barrier certainly is though.

catman

2,490 posts

175 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
The OPs colleagues have fallen into the usual trap of thinking that a dual carriageway is determined by the number of lanes. It isn't.

Tim

ModernAndy

2,094 posts

135 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
ziggy328 said:
You won't I don't think I used it as an example to answer the question. It does however hold true. A carriageway is defined as a separate road not a lane as you say. The roads therefore need to be separated by something more substantial than road markings. Generally speaking therefore the thing causing the separation would generally stop a ball from reaching the other side. Including carrots!
Temporary traffic cones would stop a ball rolling across the carriageway but my understanding is that that isn't enough to make it a dual carriageway. A strip of grass or land or any form of proper barrier certainly is though.
Also, there would be no barrier between the actual tarmac, it's just something placed on top of the tarmac rather than barriers put into concrete between the carriage ways. I'm sure there's exceptions like those tall poles you get in certain places that seem to be placed directly into the tarmac.

ModernAndy

2,094 posts

135 months

Monday 16th November 2015
quotequote all
TwigtheWonderkid said:
ziggy328 said:
You won't I don't think I used it as an example to answer the question. It does however hold true. A carriageway is defined as a separate road not a lane as you say. The roads therefore need to be separated by something more substantial than road markings. Generally speaking therefore the thing causing the separation would generally stop a ball from reaching the other side. Including carrots!
Temporary traffic cones would stop a ball rolling across the carriageway but my understanding is that that isn't enough to make it a dual carriageway. A strip of grass or land or any form of proper barrier certainly is though.
Also, there would be no barrier between the actual tarmac, it's just something placed on top of the tarmac rather than barriers put into concrete between the carriage ways. I'm sure there's exceptions like those tall poles you get in certain places that seem to be placed directly into the tarmac.

Sushifiend

5,182 posts

137 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
I would say that 90% of drivers out there have no idea whether they are on a single or dual carriageway, nor do they care because they don't realise that different speed limits apply. As for that road sign consisting of a white disc with a black diagonal line through it - I'd say most have no clue what it means, let alone an understanding of this concept called "National Speed Limit".

They need to know:
- the difference between a single and dual carriageway
- that there is such a thing as a national speed limit
- that the national speed limit varies depending on the type of road AND the type of vehicle they are driving
- when the national speed limit applies
- what the actual limit is

There are far too many variables for the majority of people who drive only to get from A to B without any interest or enjoyment in the act of driving itself. You could say that people must know these things in order to pass their driving test, but in my experience this is one area where I think the vast majority are clueless. I'd bet any traffic cop would back me up on that assertion.

JonV8V

7,227 posts

124 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
While we're on the subject, the speed limit on a dual carriage with street lights is 30 unless signed differently. I know some people who think it's always 70 unless signed (they forget regular street lights are in effect a sign except on motorways)

Johnnytheboy

24,498 posts

186 months

Tuesday 17th November 2015
quotequote all
Sushifiend said:
I would say that 90% of drivers out there have no idea whether they are on a single or dual carriageway, nor do they care because they don't realise that different speed limits apply. As for that road sign consisting of a white disc with a black diagonal line through it - I'd say most have no clue what it means, let alone an understanding of this concept called "National Speed Limit".

They need to know:
- the difference between a single and dual carriageway
- that there is such a thing as a national speed limit
- that the national speed limit varies depending on the type of road AND the type of vehicle they are driving
- when the national speed limit applies
- what the actual limit is

There are far too many variables for the majority of people who drive only to get from A to B without any interest or enjoyment in the act of driving itself. You could say that people must know these things in order to pass their driving test, but in my experience this is one area where I think the vast majority are clueless. I'd bet any traffic cop would back me up on that assertion.
My speed awareness course brought this home - most people seemed to have no idea what speed limits applied where and to what vehicles.