New petition to getthe Government to raise motorway speed li

New petition to getthe Government to raise motorway speed li

Author
Discussion

vonhosen

40,233 posts

217 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
vonhosen said:
Environmental reasons (noise/emissions).
No matter how I drive my car it won't have a thirst like most big cars, nor will it ever have the kind of particulate emissions a diesel chucks out. It's my fuel and I'll burn it as I see fit in my Euro 5 compliant car.
Not without risk of sanction/penalty as far as your speed choice is concerned though.

Terminator X

15,077 posts

204 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
surveyor_101 said:
Traveling at 80mpg burns 15-20% more fuel in my experience. Studies say more like 20-25%.
Who cares, small beer for the PH Millionaires.

TX.

Willy Nilly

12,511 posts

167 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Willy Nilly said:
vonhosen said:
Environmental reasons (noise/emissions).
No matter how I drive my car it won't have a thirst like most big cars, nor will it ever have the kind of particulate emissions a diesel chucks out. It's my fuel and I'll burn it as I see fit in my Euro 5 compliant car.
Not without risk of sanction/penalty as far as your speed choice is concerned though.
Will you please make up your mind what the speed limit is for.

One minute it's road safety. Then it's emissions, but low emission cars aren't exempt. Then it's to cut noise, so a decibel limit really, but there are no decibel monitors by the side of the road. Surely an electric car has zero local emissions and is very quite and should thus be exempt from limits in place for noise and emissions reasons. Then it's traffic control, that funnily enough even applies off peak and in the dead of night.

My car is small in most company, it's serviced on time every time, it's also considerably quieter than a new diesel I used recently and largely used off peak. So what sanctions do you think this little car deserves against it?

Ans, before you answer. A lot of my club mates are getting their cars broken into while we go for a run.The local constabulary and doing half of fk all about it, but seemingly will move heaven and earth to enforce and prosecute even the most trivial seeding offence, regardless of the conditions on the road that the time, and this is before we factor in the break ins on farms in the local area, which they are also totally useless at dealing with, putting the onus, just like the car break ins on the victims, rather than the criminals.

vonhosen

40,233 posts

217 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Willy Nilly said:
vonhosen said:
Willy Nilly said:
vonhosen said:
Environmental reasons (noise/emissions).
No matter how I drive my car it won't have a thirst like most big cars, nor will it ever have the kind of particulate emissions a diesel chucks out. It's my fuel and I'll burn it as I see fit in my Euro 5 compliant car.
Not without risk of sanction/penalty as far as your speed choice is concerned though.
Will you please make up your mind what the speed limit is for.
I've consistently said that it exists for many reasons, not one reason.


surveyor_101

5,069 posts

179 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
MrBarry123 said:
Yes, but the chances of getting tugged for 85mph are pretty low.

I'm guessing some of the people who want the limit raised to 90mph do so on the basis that it'll free them to do 100mph+ without being tugged, however this simply won't happen given the inevitable increase in enforcement.

And anyway, no-one NEEDS to travel at more than 70mph as a) the UK simply isn't that big and b) the vast majority of people's journeys wouldn't benefit in a meaningful way.

ETA: To clarify, I'd love the motorways to have a higher limit however I just don't think the amendment would be worth the hassle.
Can't see it working.

Following distance and lane discipline is do bad in this country not sure it's a good idea. Enough accidents on my stretch of the m5 with nsl. They were floating the idea of 50 limit the other day!

Also a third of cars I see are 2ton 4x4s disco, rr, rrs etc being driven like the are sports cars at 100. Clearly a great car for high speed motorway work, heavy, high centre gravity, not built to take corners at speed. Can't think of a better car to do 3 figure motorway runs.

raspy

1,469 posts

94 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
If the government is willing to train every driver on how to drive on motorways properly (regardless of speed) then 90mph might not be a bad idea to explore.

surveyor_101

5,069 posts

179 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
Who cares, small beer for the PH Millionaires.

TX.
I know rules are for the guidance of the rich and poor to obey.

However the einviroment is a big U.K. And EU think and noise and pollution trump getting there a few minutes earlier.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 16th March 2017
quotequote all
surveyor_101 said:
Terminator X said:
Who cares, small beer for the PH Millionaires.

TX.
I know rules are for the guidance of the rich and poor to obey.

However the einviroment is a big U.K. And EU think and noise and pollution trump getting there a few minutes earlier.
What? Don't you ever read what you type before you post?

Flibble

6,475 posts

181 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
Cooperman said:
Flibble said:
Drag increases remarkably quickly at high speed as it's proportional to the cube of speed.
Drag increases as the square of the speed. Double the speed = four times the drag.
Sorry, to clarify, drag force increases with the square of speed as you rightly say, however drag energy (which affects fuel consumption) increases with the cube of speed. Hence fuel consumption rises very quickly indeed above 70 mph.

Willy Nilly said:
One minute it's road safety. Then it's emissions, but low emission cars aren't exempt. Then it's to cut noise, so a decibel limit really, but there are no decibel monitors by the side of the road. Surely an electric car has zero local emissions and is very quite and should thus be exempt from limits in place for noise and emissions reasons. Then it's traffic control, that funnily enough even applies off peak and in the dead of night.
Most noise at speed for road cars is tyre noise (bonkers exhausts excepted), so electric cars would not be exempt.

GloriaGTI

509 posts

87 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
General Fluff said:
Turkeys voting for Christmas. Any increase in the limit would no doubt come with an increase in enforcement. You can already drive at 85 with no risk of getting tugged.
Also tugged at 82 last year and put on SA Course, Hants Police.

Monkeylegend

26,386 posts

231 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
Complete waste of time. As we get progressively more smart motorways, applied real time speed restrictions will mean most of the time the limit will be lower than 70 let alone 80.

I see it seems to have stalled at just under 21k signatures.

PH XKR

1,761 posts

102 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
PoleDriver said:
So they can feel better if they only make it 80MPH... Win-Win! smile
Had an epic drive to dover this morning, 160 miles of free flowing motorways. Strangely no congestion.

I set cruise to 60 and relaxed, those going faster would overtake then I would catch up again as they had to slow down usually concertining as they out braked each other.

No need to raise the limit at all

vonhosen

40,233 posts

217 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
PH XKR said:
PoleDriver said:
So they can feel better if they only make it 80MPH... Win-Win! smile
Had an epic drive to dover this morning, 160 miles of free flowing motorways. Strangely no congestion.

I set cruise to 60 and relaxed, those going faster would overtake then I would catch up again as they had to slow down usually concertining as they out braked each other.

No need to raise the limit at all
Yep, leave a big gap in front & just relax. Average speed not high speed.

surveyor_101

5,069 posts

179 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
PH XKR said:
Had an epic drive to dover this morning, 160 miles of free flowing motorways. Strangely no congestion.

I set cruise to 60 and relaxed, those going faster would overtake then I would catch up again as they had to slow down usually concertining as they out braked each other.

No need to raise the limit at all
I tend to agree, I get 50-60 mpg at 65mph in golf gtd and half of those who pass me I catch up when we leave the motorway. Often little point in speeding.

Some days I come of the motorway for a b road blast but daily commute and works trips I dont see the need to speed all over the place.

I recently drove a trackered marked works vehicle on 500 miles round trip and hardly went over 65. It was so much more relaxing than trying to go as fast as traffic allows.


Edited by surveyor_101 on Friday 17th March 13:13

del mar

2,838 posts

199 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all

Whilst I like the idea of raising the speed limit, we "the motoring public" don't deserve it.

The standard of driving on motorways is generally poor, we don't really deserve any enhancements. When we can demonstrate that we know how to drive then maybe, but that is a long way off.

PH XKR

1,761 posts

102 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
Having said what I said, raising it could work if only allow people to get home legally at 80 when safe and clear enough to do so

bad company

18,576 posts

266 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
PH XKR said:
Had an epic drive to dover this morning, 160 miles of free flowing motorways. Strangely no congestion.

I set cruise to 60 and relaxed, those going faster would overtake then I would catch up again as they had to slow down usually concertining as they out braked each other.

No need to raise the limit at all
What on earth was 'epic' about that? Sounds boring to me.

surveyor_101

5,069 posts

179 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
bad company said:
What on earth was 'epic' about that? Sounds boring to me.
Any idiot can stamp on the throttle on the motorway and do 80mph plus accelerating and braking and wasting fuel.

To drive economically with smooth planning and flowing and to achieve maximum efficiency actually takes some skill, it can be quite interesting to see whats the highest mpg you can get.

cmaguire

3,589 posts

109 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
surveyor_101 said:
Any idiot can stamp on the throttle on the motorway and do 80mph plus accelerating and braking and wasting fuel.

To drive economically with smooth planning and flowing and to achieve maximum efficiency actually takes some skill, it can be quite interesting to see whats the highest mpg you can get.
To you perhaps, to me that sounds so dull I'd probably fall asleep and if not I'd perhaps ram a flyover upright head-on in an attempt to end it all.
Driving or riding quickly and competently requires way more skill than that, although the default standpoint of the authorities and those that support them insists that any claim to competence ceases as soon as one of their pedestrian limits is exceeded.

bad company

18,576 posts

266 months

Friday 17th March 2017
quotequote all
surveyor_101 said:
To drive economically with smooth planning and flowing and to achieve maximum efficiency actually takes some skill, it can be quite interesting to see whats the highest mpg you can get.
Sorry but- sleep