Major fault- Dealer saying write off

Major fault- Dealer saying write off

Author
Discussion

Byker28i

59,852 posts

217 months

Tuesday 2nd January
quotequote all
defblade said:
If you buy a Meaco, just make sure you keep all the packaging. They are apparently funny about warranty claims if you don't (tho ours is fine after a year or so, so far... touch wood).
They charge you a tenner to get all the correct packaging to send it back under warranty, then replace the whole unit with a new one claiming it was damaged in their care.... I asked for my £10 back
winkbiggrin

Brilliant dehumidifiers and great customer service

blueg33

35,901 posts

224 months

Wednesday 3rd January
quotequote all
mercedeslimos said:
irc said:
arguti said:
This is good advice - a decent desiccant dehumidifier will pull out at least 5-8 litres out overnight. Well worth the £200 or so investment - you can then use it for drying laundry overnight indoors !

Please note: You wife will initially laugh at you and then thank you later!
As above. Good advice. Note - has to be the dessicant type as they work a low temps I bought this one for shed and attic use in Oct. Works well.

https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/aw/d/B077T6TL3V/
Second this. Bought one in December to replace a compressor-type one, pulls 5l/day minimum as it often fills faster than you can get to it to empty it. I need to stick it into my TT which is damp now :/
I have been running that type continuously in my garage for 3 years. No issues at all.

johnboy1975

8,402 posts

108 months

Wednesday 3rd January
quotequote all
freedman said:
georgeyboy12345 said:
I’d be looking to get shot of this car if I were in that position. Part ex it for something else.

Have you done a VCheck on this car? Are there any salvage records on it?
Car is clean from that POV, nothing recorded

He is planning to change it as soon as he can
Isn't there significant grounds for "you've sold me a lemon" - namely the rear light casing full of water?

I'd be "annoyed" if I brought this off the OP privately and later discovered the cars history. Such is life I suppose?

NRG1976

974 posts

10 months

Wednesday 3rd January
quotequote all
johnboy1975 said:
freedman said:
georgeyboy12345 said:
I’d be looking to get shot of this car if I were in that position. Part ex it for something else.

Have you done a VCheck on this car? Are there any salvage records on it?
Car is clean from that POV, nothing recorded

He is planning to change it as soon as he can
Isn't there significant grounds for "you've sold me a lemon" - namely the rear light casing full of water?

I'd be "annoyed" if I brought this off the OP privately and later discovered the cars history. Such is life I suppose?
I don’t think I would ever sell a “problem” car to anyone other than a trade-in to a major dealer network. I suspect (hope) the OP would be similar in that regard.

fourstardan

4,280 posts

144 months

Wednesday 3rd January
quotequote all
freedman said:
Ok, latest update, and closure, in the main

Dealer rang yesterday, said they had dried the car out, and replaced the NSR door seal, and an electrical connector under the seat (OFM?)

The car was starting and driving with no faults recorded. However they jet washed the car multiple times, and could not confirm where the water ingress had been from, but it was not coming from the door seal (now, at least) said they would leave it overnight and check it again this morning to make sure all ok, and we could then pick it up.

We collected the car this morning, and at present all seems well, it runs and drives without issue. They also fixed the issue with the NSR wheel arch liner, which now sits correctly against the wing. Looks like a fixing was missing.

Negatives, whilst they did not charge for labour they charged for the parts (about (£130.00 inc vat) and whilst that’s a rather better position than a week ago, I dont believe he should have had to pay, even if the dealer offered it as good will, especially with the nonsense spouted by they service advisor about contacting the insurers and a potential write off.

Rear floor passenger side is still pretty wet, so I got some out with a wet vac thing, hopefully it will dry out and the cause has been resolved even if they couldn’t pinpoint it. Dealer said the colour and smell of the water suggested it had been present for an extended period, potentially back to before purchase.

He has written to Volvo customer services with the complaint

Would like to thank all of those who posted information and suggestions, and those that PMd me with further assistance, all very much appreciated

I will update if and when he gets a response from Volvo
What a shambles, making you pay even a penny.

I've had similar issues fixing a kia with a Local dealership, I ended up getting a 30% offer from Kia UK which again was a psstake but in the end the local dealer seemed to admit it was a warranty issue, all very strange but my advice is don't pay a penny and hold your guns.



freedman

Original Poster:

5,416 posts

207 months

Thursday 4th January
quotequote all
NRG1976 said:
I don’t think I would ever sell a “problem” car to anyone other than a trade-in to a major dealer network. I suspect (hope) the OP would be similar in that regard.
Indeed, it will be px'd somewhere, not sold privately

119

6,289 posts

36 months

Thursday 4th January
quotequote all
freedman said:
NRG1976 said:
I don’t think I would ever sell a “problem” car to anyone other than a trade-in to a major dealer network. I suspect (hope) the OP would be similar in that regard.
Indeed, it will be px'd somewhere, not sold privately
Which is why you now have someone else's problem.

havoc

30,069 posts

235 months

Thursday 4th January
quotequote all
119 said:
Which is why you now have someone else's problem.
But what's the answer then?

I would (maybe naively) have expected that buying from a dealer would give both comeback and warranty to fix this sort of st at the trade's expense (or ideally the warranty insurer's), as they have far deeper pockets than your typical punter.

freedman

Original Poster:

5,416 posts

207 months

Friday 16th February
quotequote all
To update further on this

Car had dried out and was fine for a few weeks, then one day after some hard overnight rain, the same problem returned, with the rear footwell being soaked.

He dried it out himself this time, and it has not returned

In the mean time, the finance company sent an engineer to inspect the car properly.

Report concludes that whilst it was not possible to determine exactly where the water was coming from, it is clear that the fault was existing at the time of purchase

The finance company have offered some compensation and booked the car into the dealers to inspect it again to try and resolve. They say if this fails then the car can be rejected

I’m thinking it should go back immediately as the engineer has reported it was an existing fault (even though no one appears to know what the actual fault is!!

Dealer said they’ll have a look but they can’t do more than they did before, so I doubt the problem will be fixed anyway

E-bmw

9,221 posts

152 months

Friday 16th February
quotequote all
My understanding is that you have to give them the chance to repair, which it sounds like you have done, but feel free to check with them again.

NRG1976

974 posts

10 months

Friday 16th February
quotequote all
I bet a local Indy could find the issue quickly, most stuff like this are known faults.

johnboy1975

8,402 posts

108 months

Friday 16th February
quotequote all
NRG1976 said:
I bet a local Indy could find the issue quickly, most stuff like this are known faults.
Google seems to be pointing at sunroof seals

https://www.google.com/search?q=v90+water+ingress&...

But this car had water in the rear lights (implying driving through water? Unsure how else this could have been caused)

GasEngineer

939 posts

62 months

Saturday 17th February
quotequote all
johnboy1975 said:
Google seems to be pointing at sunroof seals

https://www.google.com/search?q=v90+water+ingress&...

But this car had water in the rear lights (implying driving through water? Unsure how else this could have been caused)
freedman said:
fourstardan said:
Just a thought, have you got a sunroof OP? On VWs the drains get bunged. The original owner might have had this happen.
No sunroof

johnboy1975

8,402 posts

108 months

Saturday 17th February
quotequote all
GasEngineer said:
johnboy1975 said:
Google seems to be pointing at sunroof seals

https://www.google.com/search?q=v90+water+ingress&...

But this car had water in the rear lights (implying driving through water? Unsure how else this could have been caused)
freedman said:
fourstardan said:
Just a thought, have you got a sunroof OP? On VWs the drains get bunged. The original owner might have had this happen.
No sunroof
Fair enough...I assumed it had come up at some point.

Something isn't right though (obviously) and - if the "approved used" tag means anything, they should be bending over backwards to sort it IMO. The latest episode definitely points to a (reoccurring) leak rather than a one off driving through a flood though prior to ownership - as I'd initially thought. (I've read the whole thread, but it's been a while smile )

Can't they run a hose on the car or something to simulate rain? "Must be" the rear windows (??)

lord trumpton

7,397 posts

126 months

Sunday 18th February
quotequote all
This sounds lie such a pita

Is it not possible to just get rid?

QBee

20,984 posts

144 months

Sunday 18th February
quotequote all
I had a similar sort of problem to this with an Audi A8. The battery and a number of ECUs are in the offside corner of the boot, and I found that the ECUs, whihc are under the battery, were sitting in several inches of water. I could never work out where the water was getting in, but did discover it was a common fault with D3 A8s.

It might be worth asking non-franchise Volvo garages, or on the Volvo forums, if anyone has come across this problem.

Good luck solving it, if you do decide to keep the car.

freedman

Original Poster:

5,416 posts

207 months

Sunday 18th February
quotequote all
lord trumpton said:
This sounds lie such a pita

Is it not possible to just get rid?
Finance is an issue, but also the way out if he cat get the, to agree the car should be rejected

freedman

Original Poster:

5,416 posts

207 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
Latest update

Volvo had the car back for almost two weeks

Unable to replicate the fault, so currently have no idea how or why water has been getting in

As far as I was aware this should now be grounds to confirm rejection

Finance co are saying they want to send another engineer…

No idea why, apart from to waste time

They are also saying that after rejection they would refund the finance payments, less 35p a mile which would leave him giving the car back, and then needing to give them some cash on top, as it’s done about 12k since purchase

Have to say that doesn’t sound right to me, but who knows?

OutInTheShed

7,604 posts

26 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
How does anyone agree what's a fair 'per mile' deduction?

You're giving back a car which is older in years as well as miles.
You could try looking at the prices of cars related to mileage, you could play games with WBAC.
Rightly or wrongly all the 'market value' indicators are strongly influenced by mileage.

As well as the reduced value, you've also 'used up' some interval between services?
Has the car had services or tyres etc paid for by the buyer?

What's the current HMRC mileage rate for using a private car? 45p still? That obviously includes fuel, but various people have moaned it's too low for a very long time.

If you buy a car with a small deposit, then I imagine it's very easy to be in 'negative equity ' with it, particularly early in a contract when the payments could be lower than the depreciation.

freedman

Original Poster:

5,416 posts

207 months

Monday 18th March
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
How does anyone agree what's a fair 'per mile' deduction?

You're giving back a car which is older in years as well as miles.
You could try looking at the prices of cars related to mileage, you could play games with WBAC.
Rightly or wrongly all the 'market value' indicators are strongly influenced by mileage.

As well as the reduced value, you've also 'used up' some interval between services?
Has the car had services or tyres etc paid for by the buyer?

What's the current HMRC mileage rate for using a private car? 45p still? That obviously includes fuel, but various people have moaned it's too low for a very long time.

If you buy a car with a small deposit, then I imagine it's very easy to be in 'negative equity ' with it, particularly early in a contract when the payments could be lower than the depreciation.
Car has recently been serviced, by Volvo. Service was part of their deal when buying the car