Battlefield 1

Author
Discussion

daddy cool

4,002 posts

230 months

Friday 27th January 2017
quotequote all
Whats the cheapest & best controller for flying on a PC? I heard you can use an XBOX controller, but a quick look suggests they are ~£40. No plans to be a hardcore pilot so would prefer to pay about half that for odd flights...

(Do xbox controllers have a USB connection, or do you need some kind of adapter for use with a PC?)

Lazadude

1,732 posts

162 months

Friday 27th January 2017
quotequote all
daddy cool said:
(Do xbox controllers have a USB connection, or do you need some kind of adapter for use with a PC?)
Xbox one is micro USB.

Xbox 360 you need to have the controller and the adapter to make it connect.

Rogue86

2,008 posts

146 months

Friday 27th January 2017
quotequote all
rockford22 said:
Problem in the campaign is that the flying controls are simplified (the rudder control is removed) meaning you can't yaw.
G
In MP the controls are as you would expect, although did take me a long time to set up.
Ah hadn't realised that, I played the campaign long before I went near the multiplayer aircraft!

While we're on the subject of flying though, I'm still really struggling with lag/connectivity issues. I know that there are lots of potential reasons for it, but the simple fact is that BF1 is the only game which seems to manifest it in this way. The game has been almost unplayable tonight.

https://youtu.be/z2GpKZP1dXc

https://youtu.be/MnGQoLWtLAY

https://youtu.be/oF5_rf5zKIE

https://youtu.be/ZwP8o9VEJP4

https://youtu.be/JUpITK6YOm4

Battlefront never did this. BF4 never did this. As above, Ive never loved and hated a game in such equal measure before. Was planning on buying premium this weekend but after 2hrs and 6 servers of this tonight I just cant see the point. These arent even "worst example" videos, just a sample of fairly generic gameplay from ten minutes in one particular server this evening. Put BF4 back in and no issues at all.


Edited by Rogue86 on Friday 27th January 23:27

kowalski655

14,656 posts

144 months

Saturday 28th January 2017
quotequote all
Lazadude said:
daddy cool said:
(Do xbox controllers have a USB connection, or do you need some kind of adapter for use with a PC?)
Xbox one is micro USB.

Xbox 360 you need to have the controller and the adapter to make it connect.
I got a cheap 3rd party wired XB1 controller from GAME,about 20/25 quid, perfectly useable for driving games so no reason it wouldn't work on BF1(I'm useless at flying so don't do the pilot thing at all)

rockford22

361 posts

133 months

Saturday 28th January 2017
quotequote all
Rogue86 said:
rockford22 said:
Problem in the campaign is that the flying controls are simplified (the rudder control is removed) meaning you can't yaw.
G
In MP the controls are as you would expect, although did take me a long time to set up.
Ah hadn't realised that, I played the campaign long before I went near the multiplayer aircraft!

While we're on the subject of flying though, I'm still really struggling with lag/connectivity issues. I know that there are lots of potential reasons for it, but the simple fact is that BF1 is the only game which seems to manifest it in this way. The game has been almost unplayable tonight.

https://youtu.be/z2GpKZP1dXc

https://youtu.be/MnGQoLWtLAY

https://youtu.be/oF5_rf5zKIE

https://youtu.be/ZwP8o9VEJP4

https://youtu.be/JUpITK6YOm4

Battlefront never did this. BF4 never did this. As above, Ive never loved and hated a game in such equal measure before. Was planning on buying premium this weekend but after 2hrs and 6 servers of this tonight I just cant see the point. These arent even "worst example" videos, just a sample of fairly generic gameplay from ten minutes in one particular server this evening. Put BF4 back in and no issues at all.


Edited by Rogue86 on Friday 27th January 23:27
Wow I can really see what you mean! Not sure if I have been incredibly lucky, but I can count on one hand instances like that and I'm rank 70 or so. The odd glitch yes but really very infrequent.

Rogue86

2,008 posts

146 months

Saturday 28th January 2017
quotequote all
rockford22 said:
Wow I can really see what you mean! Not sure if I have been incredibly lucky, but I can count on one hand instances like that and I'm rank 70 or so. The odd glitch yes but really very infrequent.
Yeah it's really annoying, been no better this afternoon either. I'm still getting plenty of kills in thr fighter (finished both games top with 79 and 82) but I'm having to avoid getting really stuck in defending positions because the slightest lag just puts me into the floor.

Ruskie

3,990 posts

201 months

Sunday 29th January 2017
quotequote all
Think I'm just going to have to admit defeat with this game. Don't people want to win games? Is it all about personal glory? I'm the first to admit I'm a bad loser and I'm horribly competitive to boot. That said if the playing field is level I can handle getting beat. It's the constant lag and unfair kills that are grinding me down. Also I'm sick of going for objectives and having people just sitting there all game doing nothing. Running the other way from checkpoints to get a position to snipe instead of just capturing the base. So hacked off with it because the game could be incredible.

J-D-Stagpump

145 posts

103 months

Sunday 29th January 2017
quotequote all
Ruskie said:
Think I'm just going to have to admit defeat with this game. Don't people want to win games? Is it all about personal glory? I'm the first to admit I'm a bad loser and I'm horribly competitive to boot. That said if the playing field is level I can handle getting beat. It's the constant lag and unfair kills that are grinding me down. Also I'm sick of going for objectives and having people just sitting there all game doing nothing. Running the other way from checkpoints to get a position to snipe instead of just capturing the base. So hacked off with it because the game could be incredible.
this

Polarbert

17,923 posts

232 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
I was hoping for good things but I honestly haven't played this since before Xmas. Since getting Rainbow Six Siege and Dead Rising 4 I just haven't thought about it really.

p1stonhead

25,576 posts

168 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
Ruskie said:
Think I'm just going to have to admit defeat with this game. Don't people want to win games? Is it all about personal glory? I'm the first to admit I'm a bad loser and I'm horribly competitive to boot. That said if the playing field is level I can handle getting beat. It's the constant lag and unfair kills that are grinding me down. Also I'm sick of going for objectives and having people just sitting there all game doing nothing. Running the other way from checkpoints to get a position to snipe instead of just capturing the base. So hacked off with it because the game could be incredible.
Sniping is really annoying on objective games.

I got so fed up last week than I spent an entire match throwing smoke grenades at snipers on my own team who were about 400m back from the action.

Petty but they deserved it hehe

CrutyRammers

13,735 posts

199 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
rockford22 said:
Rogue86 said:
rockford22 said:
Problem in the campaign is that the flying controls are simplified (the rudder control is removed) meaning you can't yaw.
G
In MP the controls are as you would expect, although did take me a long time to set up.
Ah hadn't realised that, I played the campaign long before I went near the multiplayer aircraft!

While we're on the subject of flying though, I'm still really struggling with lag/connectivity issues. I know that there are lots of potential reasons for it, but the simple fact is that BF1 is the only game which seems to manifest it in this way. The game has been almost unplayable tonight.

https://youtu.be/z2GpKZP1dXc

https://youtu.be/MnGQoLWtLAY

https://youtu.be/oF5_rf5zKIE

https://youtu.be/ZwP8o9VEJP4

https://youtu.be/JUpITK6YOm4

Battlefront never did this. BF4 never did this. As above, Ive never loved and hated a game in such equal measure before. Was planning on buying premium this weekend but after 2hrs and 6 servers of this tonight I just cant see the point. These arent even "worst example" videos, just a sample of fairly generic gameplay from ten minutes in one particular server this evening. Put BF4 back in and no issues at all.


Edited by Rogue86 on Friday 27th January 23:27
Wow I can really see what you mean! Not sure if I have been incredibly lucky, but I can count on one hand instances like that and I'm rank 70 or so. The odd glitch yes but really very infrequent.
Have you opened all the right ports on your router?
I rarely get any lag issues personally, as said above just the odd one now and again.

PeteB0

956 posts

247 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
Ruskie said:
Think I'm just going to have to admit defeat with this game. Don't people want to win games? Is it all about personal glory? I'm the first to admit I'm a bad loser and I'm horribly competitive to boot. That said if the playing field is level I can handle getting beat. It's the constant lag and unfair kills that are grinding me down. Also I'm sick of going for objectives and having people just sitting there all game doing nothing. Running the other way from checkpoints to get a position to snipe instead of just capturing the base. So hacked off with it because the game could be incredible.
I had a new one (for me) yesterday: playing operations and defending on Monte Grappa. Attackers have an airship and I jumped on one of the AAs to suppress the gun turrets. One of my squad mates (not anyone I knew) then decided he wanted to get on the AA instead, and took it upon himself to stand in my line of fire, so the blastback killed me ('Accident'). He then jumped on the gun himself. Tool.

Vantagemech

5,728 posts

216 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
PeteB0 said:
I had a new one (for me) yesterday: playing operations and defending on Monte Grappa. Attackers have an airship and I jumped on one of the AAs to suppress the gun turrets. One of my squad mates (not anyone I knew) then decided he wanted to get on the AA instead, and took it upon himself to stand in my line of fire, so the blastback killed me ('Accident'). He then jumped on the gun himself. Tool.
Yup, Ive had that as well, Monte Crappa, gun by the church a A. The only reason I persist with this is that the friends I have on chat still play.
I had one yesterday where I killed 2 players in the upstairs of a room on ballroom blitz, only to be killed by debis while the player next to me was untouched.



Vantagemech

5,728 posts

216 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
CrutyRammers said:
Have you opened all the right ports on your router?
I rarely get any lag issues personally, as said above just the odd one now and again.
What are these magical port settings? smile

Sway

26,325 posts

195 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
Vantagemech said:
CrutyRammers said:
Have you opened all the right ports on your router?
I rarely get any lag issues personally, as said above just the odd one now and again.
What are these magical port settings? smile
I wouldn't bother bud, you and Si suffer from the realism of the game - it clocks your location and gives you the ' twinset and pearls ' settings '

Vantagemech

5,728 posts

216 months

Monday 30th January 2017
quotequote all
Sway said:
I wouldn't bother bud, you and Si suffer from the realism of the game - it clocks your location and gives you the ' twinset and pearls ' settings '
Mate, youre the other side of Heavens waiting room, Eastbourne, so I guess theres less traffic as fewer OAPs use or understand 'tinternet your end of the coast... smile

andyr30

613 posts

187 months

Tuesday 31st January 2017
quotequote all
Not sure if I am doing something wrong when trying to melee, but I can be as close as is possible and when I melee I just hit them once...happened a few times where they have then turned around and just melee'd me straight away, quite frustrating!

Last night I snuck up behind someone, they had no idea I was there, hit melee and poked them once with my sawtooth blade thing, tried again and they turned around and killed me instantly >:-(

thetapeworm

11,243 posts

240 months

Tuesday 31st January 2017
quotequote all
andyr30 said:
Not sure if I am doing something wrong when trying to melee, but I can be as close as is possible and when I melee I just hit them once...happened a few times where they have then turned around and just melee'd me straight away, quite frustrating!

Last night I snuck up behind someone, they had no idea I was there, hit melee and poked them once with my sawtooth blade thing, tried again and they turned around and killed me instantly >:-(
The radius for the full-on attack varies from weapon to weapon but like you I've found it really random as to when it triggers, I end up with the same, a single tickle with the blunt side of the melee weapon then they turn around and circle me to the point where I have no idea where they are, then I get killed with one hit.

One of the awards is based on kills with the medic needle, I don't stand a chance with that unless I can get a 100m extension on it and poke from a Behemoth.

fullbeem

2,044 posts

202 months

Tuesday 31st January 2017
quotequote all
andyr30 said:
Not sure if I am doing something wrong when trying to melee, but I can be as close as is possible and when I melee I just hit them once...happened a few times where they have then turned around and just melee'd me straight away, quite frustrating!

Last night I snuck up behind someone, they had no idea I was there, hit melee and poked them once with my sawtooth blade thing, tried again and they turned around and killed me instantly >:-(
Certainly depends on the weapon used. The sawtooth and hatchet should be one hit kill or close to a one tap.

CrutyRammers

13,735 posts

199 months

Tuesday 31st January 2017
quotequote all
Vantagemech said:
CrutyRammers said:
Have you opened all the right ports on your router?
I rarely get any lag issues personally, as said above just the odd one now and again.
What are these magical port settings? smile
http://support.xbox.com/en-GB/xbox-one/networking/...

It's a bit of a faff if you've not played with your router before, but if you haven't done it, it can cause exactly the symptoms you describe.
How to do it depends on your router, but most have a help page online these days.