Please put the f****ing stick down!!

Please put the f****ing stick down!!

Author
Discussion

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
Yes I do, I see a very clear difference in the end result. One looks good, the other looks ridiculous. I can't imagine why anyone thinks a photo down a stick and their arm is an acceptable result for a photograph.
This is the 'photography' forum & I'd like to think those interested in photography would also find the end result low in photographic standards.

rottie102

3,997 posts

184 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
bernhund said:
Yes I do, I see a very clear difference in the end result. One looks good, the other looks ridiculous. I can't imagine why anyone thinks a photo down a stick and their arm is an acceptable result for a photograph.
This is the 'photography' forum & I'd like to think those interested in photography would also find the end result low in photographic standards.
I give up. smile why can't you accept that a) selfie sticks are not being used by serious photographers, but by tourists with compact cameras and b) that people can do whatever they want with their xameras is beyond me.

I'm off to stab myself with a selfie stick

Mr Will

13,719 posts

206 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
bernhund said:
Yes I do, I see a very clear difference in the end result. One looks good, the other looks ridiculous. I can't imagine why anyone thinks a photo down a stick and their arm is an acceptable result for a photograph.
This is the 'photography' forum & I'd like to think those interested in photography would also find the end result low in photographic standards.
^ This

I have no problem with the sticks per se, and I've seen them used for a lot of interesting purposes (unusual angles, challenging locations, etc). The real problem is when they are used in inappropriate situations, often to the inconvenience of others, just so that the photo can be made worse by including the photographer (in a stupid pose) between the camera and the subject.

I'd feel the same about someone setting up a tripod on Oxford street to take a selfie in front of Primark, but fortunately that seems to rare.

(maybe I'm just getting old...)

Mr Will

13,719 posts

206 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
rottie102 said:
I give up. smile why can't you accept that a) selfie sticks are not being used by serious photographers, but by tourists with compact cameras and b) that people can do whatever they want with their xameras is beyond me.
How do you feel about people filming concerts by holding an iPad aloft?

Don

28,377 posts

284 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
I'll bet David Noton could use a selfie-stick to great advantage.

Hmmmn.

LetterToDavidNoton said:
We know that using P mode will lead to an inevitable loss of self esteem as one's testicles will shrivel up and drop off but do you think that it is possible to actually create some art with a SELFIE-STICK!!???
If anyone is capable of it it must be you, surely?

P.S. I've heard they can now be used as a great excuse for carrying an offensive weapon in the boot of your car for "emergencies".

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
rottie102 said:
bernhund said:
Yes I do, I see a very clear difference in the end result. One looks good, the other looks ridiculous. I can't imagine why anyone thinks a photo down a stick and their arm is an acceptable result for a photograph.
This is the 'photography' forum & I'd like to think those interested in photography would also find the end result low in photographic standards.
I give up. smile why can't you accept that a) selfie sticks are not being used by serious photographers, but by tourists with compact cameras and b) that people can do whatever they want with their xameras is beyond me.

I'm off to stab myself with a selfie stick
Lol, I didn't want to get in an argument with anyone. It is simply my opinion & I thought it might prompt some interesting debate, that's all. I can't justify my hatred for the 'selfie down a stick'. People are entitled to do what they wish with them, and importantly, if the user is happy with the result that's ultimately all that matters.


rottie102

3,997 posts

184 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
Mr Will said:
How do you feel about people filming concerts by holding an iPad aloft?
I would fight them with all my might. Just like people obstructing my view with a selfie stick.
But OP doesn't rant against stupid people obstructing his view which I would support wholeheartedly. He moans about the general use of selfie sticks. Live and let live if it doesn't affect you in any way.

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
rottie102 said:
Mr Will said:
How do you feel about people filming concerts by holding an iPad aloft?
I would fight them with all my might. Just like people obstructing my view with a selfie stick.
But OP doesn't rant against stupid people obstructing his view which I would support wholeheartedly. He moans about the general use of selfie sticks. Live and let live if it doesn't affect you in any way.
I have made it quite clear from the off that using the stick in certain ways is fantastic. I've complemented images!. I've complained about the use of the iPad obstructing my view at a wedding too in the thread. All along I've talked about the 'selfie down stick' being my unjustified gripe.

72twink

963 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
Shall I start a new thread for my pet gripe then, Mr "oh you're only taking that picture with a compact or phone so I'll stand in front of you to take my own with my 2 week old entry level DSLR and squeaky clean nappy bag because I'm clearly a better photographer". Reminds me of the old Olympus ads with David Bailey and George Cole!

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
72twink said:
Shall I start a new thread for my pet gripe then, Mr "oh you're only taking that picture with a compact or phone so I'll stand in front of you to take my own with my 2 week old entry level DSLR and squeaky clean nappy bag because I'm clearly a better photographer". Reminds me of the old Olympus ads with David Bailey and George Cole!
confused

72twink

963 posts

242 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
Just as your gripe is selfie sticks mine is the person who always steps into frame as I'm about to take a carefully composed image and it's always an "all the gear and no idea" type. I guess I'm saying we all have a type who grinds us ......

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Thursday 8th January 2015
quotequote all
72twink said:
Just as your gripe is selfie sticks mine is the person who always steps into frame as I'm about to take a carefully composed image and it's always an "all the gear and no idea" type. I guess I'm saying we all have a type who grinds us ......
Lol. I'm there with you on that one too. I'm sure the actions of that kind of person must come out in all aspects of their life. I.e completely oblivious to the requirements of others because they're too blinded by their own importance.

Ari

19,347 posts

215 months

pilbeam_mp62

955 posts

201 months

Friday 9th January 2015
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
pilbeam_mp62 said:
Shutter open while the light-pen was drawing the face, in a pitch black room...... Then a single flash to capture the person.
Brilliant. I should have thought of that.

Wonder how many takes it took to get it right?!
I have all the negatives - there are half a dozen or so where the face went a bit wrong while he was drawing it - this is the best one that he then printed.

sgrimshaw

7,323 posts

250 months

Friday 9th January 2015
quotequote all
Unfortuneate yes, but no sympathy wink

http://www.dpreview.com/forums/post/54888486

Edited by sgrimshaw on Friday 9th January 21:31

Silver Smudger

3,299 posts

167 months

Saturday 10th January 2015
quotequote all
Mr Will said:
I prefer the term Narcissistick...
Did not get the credit it deserved - clap

Don

28,377 posts

284 months

Saturday 10th January 2015
quotequote all

Dave46

454 posts

139 months

Saturday 10th January 2015
quotequote all

Simpo Two

85,427 posts

265 months

bernhund

Original Poster:

3,767 posts

193 months

Tuesday 13th January 2015
quotequote all