Fish and chip shop in Whitby

Fish and chip shop in Whitby

Author
Discussion

curlyks2

1,028 posts

145 months

Thursday 4th June 2015
quotequote all
Quite like The Fishermans Wife myself, which is up the Khyber Pass in Whitby.

ianrb

1,529 posts

139 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2015
quotequote all
My wife and I had a day out on the coast today, and visited the Magpie in Whitby for fish & chips. I must say that the fish was excellent and the chips were very good (although not quite as good as the fish). We got to their front door at about 20 to 12 and got a seat straight away, by mid-day it looked as if every seat was taken.

Not cheap though, cod and chips plus tea for 2 people came to £30, although that did include a tip.

We were going to do it properly and sit on the pier, but the weather was a bit too wet and windy for that.

_Leg_

2,798 posts

210 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2015
quotequote all
Trenchers. Was there Sunday as my eldest had been beach cleaning at RH Bay (he's aiming for a marine zoology degree/career). Tip top.

lee_fr200

5,475 posts

189 months

Tuesday 23rd June 2015
quotequote all
I'm in Whitby on Thursday installing in the star so will be having fish n chips

thetapeworm

11,192 posts

238 months

Tuesday 21st July 2015
quotequote all
We usually wander past the queue at the Magpie and go to the Quarter Deck, like a previous poster I'm a creature of habit, my wife made me try Hadley's once but I didn't really rate it.

Briza

119 posts

149 months

Wednesday 22nd July 2015
quotequote all
The Marine do an absolutley cracking fish and chips, sit in and cheaper than a lot of the takeaways, and you can have a pint, and live music most evenings.

TTOBES

609 posts

166 months

Tuesday 18th August 2015
quotequote all
Thought I would mention that based on this thread and another, older, thread with mixed reviews on eateries in Scarborough, I went to Trenchers yesterday for lunch.

At 1330 (Monday), we queued for no longer than ten minutes and had one medium and one small haddock with two cokes for £24. We both thought the fish was excellent; chips good too.

Recommended.

Daz68

3,346 posts

209 months

Thursday 27th August 2015
quotequote all
TTOBES said:
Thought I would mention that based on this thread and another, older, thread with mixed reviews on eateries in Scarborough, I went to Trenchers yesterday for lunch.

At 1330 (Monday), we queued for no longer than ten minutes and had one medium and one small haddock with two cokes for £24. We both thought the fish was excellent; chips good too.

Recommended.
Wow. That's alot of money for Fish and Chips?

james_tigerwoods

16,287 posts

196 months

Friday 4th September 2015
quotequote all
Quayside for me - With the added bonus that they do battered Haggis which is pretty damned good smile

FiF

43,960 posts

250 months

Friday 4th September 2015
quotequote all
I know this thread is primarily concerning fish and chips but, as pointed out nothing like out of the paper sitting in the open air, prefer Trenchers, last time we had Magpie they were rank from takeaway. However if you want a decent sit down meal cooked by a proper chef as opposed to a fryer please go to Bridge Street and just up from the swing bridge to...

http://www.greensofwhitby.com/

PH5121

1,963 posts

212 months

Friday 4th September 2015
quotequote all
We were in Whitby on Sunday and the fish and chips smelt great, me and the kids were keen to get some.

However my wife who claims she doesn't like fish and chips, strangely likes them from Thompsons who have a take away and cafe in Stamford Bridge and a take away and restaurant on the side of the A64 near Sand Hutton. So we had to wait an hour and a half after leaving Whitby until we could get some, but they were very very nice.

If eating in Whitby I like Trenchers haddock and chips, having been to the Magpie on a few occasions I was always 'unlucky' getting the fish that was all batter, or seemed to have been cut on a bacon slicer.

All that jazz

7,632 posts

145 months

Saturday 5th September 2015
quotequote all
TTOBES said:
Thought I would mention that based on this thread and another, older, thread with mixed reviews on eateries in Scarborough, I went to Trenchers yesterday for lunch.

At 1330 (Monday), we queued for no longer than ten minutes and had one medium and one small haddock with two cokes for TWENTY FOUR POUNDS.
yikes

What the juddering fk!!!!!!

Viperzs

966 posts

166 months

Saturday 5th September 2015
quotequote all
marshalla said:
Pretty much everyone else is going to recommend "The Magpie" (as featured on Rick Stein's TV programme a few years ago.)

I've never been in - having stood in a queue for an hour only to have them take a table of 4 from the queue behind us rather than take a smaller number of people from the head of the queue, I refuse to attempt to do business with them again.

My preference is Fusco's : http://www.whitbyfishandchips.com/
The Magpie is very over rated!

FiF

43,960 posts

250 months

Saturday 5th September 2015
quotequote all
Viperzs said:
marshalla said:
Pretty much everyone else is going to recommend "The Magpie" (as featured on Rick Stein's TV programme a few years ago. I've never been in - having stood in a queue for an hour only to have them take a table of 4 from the queue behind us rather than take a smaller number of people from the head of the queue, I refuse to attempt to do business with them again.

My preference is Fusco's : http://www.whitbyfishandchips.com/
The Magpie is very over rated!
Agreed although things are personal taste.

I would have been pissed at the experience of marshalla, but then I am aware of just how crammed you are in there. We were 3 on a table and how you're going to get a fourth on there was a bit of a mystery.

The food by far not the worst f&c ever, better than average by a long chalk, but definitely not the best. But the takeaway at street level, supposedly the same was terrible, definitely in the worst 20% ever experienced.

Problem is that extremely good f&c is as much about the experience and how hungry you are as the actual product. Best ever I've had were at Seamer near Scarborough. Going back under different circumstances nowhere near as good, barely average quality.

skip_1

3,459 posts

189 months

Saturday 5th September 2015
quotequote all
To be perfectly honest the fish and chips from our local shop taste just as good as any in Whitby that I have had.

TheBALDpuma

5,842 posts

167 months

Monday 7th September 2015
quotequote all
skip_1 said:
To be perfectly honest the fish and chips from our local shop taste just as good as any in Whitby that I have had.
This is it. I got to Murgetroyds in Yeadon (had one last night as it happens) and I've been to the the Magpie, and another in Whitby and I prefer Murgetroyds to both. 2 x chips, 1 x fish 1 x battered sausage and 2 x cokes was a £10, so not expensive either! And this fish is massive, as big as the special at the whetherby whaler down the road.