Decent mechanic near Camberley

Decent mechanic near Camberley

Author
Discussion

davek_964

Original Poster:

8,796 posts

174 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
I've had a fairly ridiculous quote for replacing a door mirror on one of my cars. I accept that the electrical connector is behind the door panel, and I accept a few other bits need to be taken off once the panel is removed. I don't accept that it is therefore 2 hours labour at a total cost of £190 + VAT (plus the cost of the part).

Obviously I can - and probably will - do it myself. But for the times I can't be bothered, I think I've reached the point where I would rather use a skilled mechanic for generic jobs and just leave the annual service / stamp in the book to the £100 an hour specialists.

So - who do you use near Camberley, and what hourly rate do they charge?

(I'm sure it's been asked before but I couldn't find anything recent with a search).

edc

9,231 posts

250 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
If it's not a car or job they've worked on regularly before then they will check the Autodata book time then apply their hourly rate. Best bet is find a local marque specialist for that sort of thing.

davek_964

Original Poster:

8,796 posts

174 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
edc said:
If it's not a car or job they've worked on regularly before then they will check the Autodata book time then apply their hourly rate. Best bet is find a local marque specialist for that sort of thing.
A marque specialist is who I usually use. But I simply don't believe that having to take a door card off means a job takes 2 hours.
Even if it did, I'm pretty sure there are decent mechanics who are capable and charge £50 an hour not £100?

edc

9,231 posts

250 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
Unfortunately I don't think there's that many charging cheap rates these days round here. I used a few years ago the garage behind the petrol station in Frimley Green to change the brakes on my Boxster a few years ago. I supplied all the parts and they just did the labour. I can't remember the hourly rate but it seemed cheap enough at the time for a simple mechanical job.

Vixpy1

42,620 posts

263 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
Dan at Surrey Scooby Specialsts round the corner from your sepcialist is good at taking on wierd and wonderful jobs.

davek_964

Original Poster:

8,796 posts

174 months

Friday 17th February 2017
quotequote all
Cheers, might look them up.

Maybe I need to stop being lazy and start fixing more stuff myself.

e600

1,315 posts

151 months

Sunday 26th February 2017
quotequote all
JC Autos NorthCamp, behind motorcycle city.

Mr Tidy

22,065 posts

126 months

Sunday 26th February 2017
quotequote all
OP you don't say what the car is, but from other posts I think you may have a BMW?

If so I would recommend TWG Automotive in Frimley - my 2 always go there! Will, the proprietor, is ex-Sytner.

Rate is £75 per hour (inc. VAT), but the beauty of using someone who knows the cars inside out is they will do the job quicker than a non-specialist!


davek_964

Original Poster:

8,796 posts

174 months

Monday 27th February 2017
quotequote all
Mr Tidy said:
OP you don't say what the car is, but from other posts I think you may have a BMW?

If so I would recommend TWG Automotive in Frimley - my 2 always go there! Will, the proprietor, is ex-Sytner.

Rate is £75 per hour (inc. VAT), but the beauty of using someone who knows the cars inside out is they will do the job quicker than a non-specialist!

Nope - I'm browsing BMWs and may shop for a Z4 but the specific car in question is an AM Vantage. I already have specialists I use for servicing, but was trying to avoid their (what seem to me) inflated prices for generic work.

Thanks for the suggestions - but I think I have now concluded I simply need to start doing more to my cars myself. The quote that started this thread was to replace a wing mirror because it wasn't always folding out properly (although I've since dismantled it and lubricated it, which seems to have solved it for now). I was told it was a 2 hour job because it was "quite involved and includes removal of the door card" - and two different specialists told me that, with almost identical justification.

Since then, I decided to see just how hard it was to remove the door card. It took me under 10 mins - in fact, it was the simplest door card I've ever removed. Removing the mirror from the mounting arm is ~1 minute (two screws). Removing the arm - which you need to do if you are going to replace the mirror to be able to get the wiring through - does involve a bit more than just removal of the door card - but not 50 mins more, plus another 50 mins to re-assemble.

So my conclusion is, on some jobs even respected specialists are taking the p**s - and if I can do it myself, I will (and in this case I definitely can if / when it needs doing).

Thanks for the tip on the BMW specialist though, that may come in handy in future....