Which car to buy and tuck away? Audi TT Mk1 or Boxster Mk1

Which car to buy and tuck away? Audi TT Mk1 or Boxster Mk1

Author
Discussion

Hooli

32,278 posts

201 months

Thursday 22nd October 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Or certainly a Jag XJS a lovely car timeless and far too often overlooked.
This. Already on the up & much much nicer than boring German stuff.

Pat H

8,056 posts

257 months

Thursday 22nd October 2015
quotequote all
You can't piss, fart or whistle without tripping up over a TT or a Boxter.

You want something properly rare.

What about a Phase 3 GTV 3.2? There were fewer than 60 registered in the UK.

Even the common or garden Phase 1 and Phase 2 GTV V6 is a pretty uncommon beast.

Here's one which I should never have sold.....






















Furyblade_Lee

4,108 posts

225 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Furyblade_Lee said:
I would not be buying either for making money in 5 years,

I have had a Boxster S, would not touch amother, check my profile....

BUT I love the original TT, would have to buy one in silver, 225, black leather, no rear spoiler and the best I could afford. Just like the pure motor show concept car. An original one of those should go up in value, but not for at least 10 years I reckon, way too many left.
Interesting read on the profile.

Why did you skin the discs (wheeler dealer style) over replacing with new items?

Was it the 350BhP version you had?
I didnt skim the discs out of choice. The dealer who I brokered the sale with insisted on it to sell it. Because it had little use in the last 3 months of my ownwership ( bored my tits off so it just sat there ) they corroded up in a disgraceful way. At that point I just wanted rid. Would skimmimg the discs caused a problem for the new owner then????

Furyblade_Lee

4,108 posts

225 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
How about 2x RX-8 for £1k ish each fix any broken engine issues then flog on for multiples of your cost.
Ha ha I compete in a shared RX8 PZ ( Prodrive one ) in a southern sprit and hillclimb championship with a mate, you are never going to make money on an RX8!!! I ADORE our one, its pretty much unbeatable in the production 2-litre class, only an Integra Type R comes close and that is worth at least 3X as much. But we have pretty much taken 1/3 the life out of a freshly rebuilt engine in just 1 season on competition between 2 of us and a few trackdays on top. The PZ in particular is a certified solid gold classic, and deservedly so, but that engine is a consumable component at £2k a pop rebuild so again I'd give it 10 years before they will make any money.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Furyblade_Lee said:
I didnt skim the discs out of choice. The dealer who I brokered the sale with insisted on it to sell it. Because it had little use in the last 3 months of my ownwership ( bored my tits off so it just sat there ) they corroded up in a disgraceful way. At that point I just wanted rid. Would skimmimg the discs caused a problem for the new owner then????
Why didn't you just drive it for ten miles and use the brake a lot. Actually they would be clesned up massively quicker than that a few hard stops and or trailing brake would do it. Vastly cheaper same result.

Hackney

6,853 posts

209 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Why would you "tuck away" any car that cost only a few grand?
If it was a properly rare car, yes but a mass produced model.....?

If you want to drive either, but it and drive it.
If you want to invest £5k surely there's better ways than a second hand golf in a posh frock.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Hackney said:
Why would you "tuck away" any car that cost only a few grand?
If it was a properly rare car, yes but a mass produced model.....?

If you want to drive either, but it and drive it.
If you want to invest £5k surely there's better ways than a second hand golf in a posh frock.
How about E34 M5 /E39 M5 IF you can find one at that price point? Amazing cars the former last of the hand built cars so seriously desirable the latter arguably the best ever M5 period so again strong returns.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

199 months

Friday 23rd October 2015
quotequote all
Or e46 M3 that is right at the bottom of the price band. Will they go lower? They don't seem to be moving very much if anything some are getting stronger.

Oi_Oi_Savaloy

2,313 posts

261 months

Saturday 24th October 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Hackney said:
Why would you "tuck away" any car that cost only a few grand?
If it was a properly rare car, yes but a mass produced model.....?

If you want to drive either, but it and drive it.
If you want to invest £5k surely there's better ways than a second hand golf in a posh frock.
How about E34 M5 /E39 M5 IF you can find one at that price point? Amazing cars the former last of the hand built cars so seriously desirable the latter arguably the best ever M5 period so again strong returns.
I think the e34 m5 is a definite grower but they can be eye watering to keep oem. Suspension (from memory is particularly expensive.) but yes; agree with you.

On the e39 for me it's rust rather than mechanicals.

4rephill

5,041 posts

179 months

Saturday 24th October 2015
quotequote all
Oi_Oi_Savaloy said:
Welshbeef said:
Hackney said:
Why would you "tuck away" any car that cost only a few grand?
If it was a properly rare car, yes but a mass produced model.....?

If you want to drive either, but it and drive it.
If you want to invest £5k surely there's better ways than a second hand golf in a posh frock.
How about E34 M5 /E39 M5 IF you can find one at that price point? Amazing cars the former last of the hand built cars so seriously desirable the latter arguably the best ever M5 period so again strong returns.
I think the e34 m5 is a definite grower but they can be eye watering to keep oem. Suspension (from memory is particularly expensive.) but yes; agree with you.

On the e39 for me it's rust rather than mechanicals.
An E34/E39 M5 for £5K? - Pretty sure that ship has sailed already!

Furyblade_Lee

4,108 posts

225 months

Sunday 25th October 2015
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Furyblade_Lee said:
I didnt skim the discs out of choice. The dealer who I brokered the sale with insisted on it to sell it. Because it had little use in the last 3 months of my ownwership ( bored my tits off so it just sat there ) they corroded up in a disgraceful way. At that point I just wanted rid. Would skimmimg the discs caused a problem for the new owner then????
Why didn't you just drive it for ten miles and use the brake a lot. Actually they would be clesned up massively quicker than that a few hard stops and or trailing brake would do it. Vastly cheaper same result.
Doh! Didn't think of that, could have saved myself £300