Changing from 9-5 Aero to...........9-5 diesel ?

Changing from 9-5 Aero to...........9-5 diesel ?

Author
Discussion

addsvrs

Original Poster:

582 posts

216 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
So something i have been putting off thinking about for awhile.
I have a 9-5 Aero estate, absolutely love it, my mobile office, fast enough, well specced etc etc but....

I am self employed buying and selling on Ebay. When i bought this car Aug 2013, my main 2 suppliers were local, my mileage was low, compared to the other cars i looked at (5 series tourer / E class) this seemed a bargain. And it has been, probably the best car i have ever owned. Now for the 'small' problem.
My 2 local suppliers have become unreliable / putting prices up etc so i have been finding myself going further afield to find stock and while i can get low 30's on a run I am starting to think a diesel will suit my situation better.

So what to replace it with. Well it has to be another 9-5 estate but a diesel ( i think a lower powered petrol will be even more depressing) so my questions are basically around which diesel engine is best ? I like the look of the 3.0 one but cant believe mpg will be much better, the 2.2 one, is that a Vauxhall ?

Any other suggestions more than welcome, btw I cant drive any slower lol, LPG is a option, load space similar to the 9-5 is essential.

Thanks

otolith

56,090 posts

204 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
I fancied the 3.0 diesel, did some research, ran away in terror.

addsvrs

Original Poster:

582 posts

216 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
That bad ! oh dear

otolith

56,090 posts

204 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
Dropped cylinder liners, as I recall.

MrC986

3,492 posts

191 months

Tuesday 14th April 2015
quotequote all
I bought my '53 plate 9-5 2.2 Tid Vector estate 2 yrs ago having researched the whole 3.0 Tid saga and also having been convinced that at that time I should go for a chain driven engine rather than a cambelt version ala the 1.9 Tid. I needed a good value diesel estate in which to do a 115 mile a day round trip to work & back. Now 45k miles on (with 150k showing), other than a periodic cleaning of the EGR (a common fault apparently when doing a lot of short journeys - SWMBO had it for 1 yr) & a few small wear & tear suspension bits plus servicing, the car has run well and does upto 750 miles on a tank at decent motorway speeds with 2 up and a small amount of luggage. The car has more than accomplished itself in its stay with me & although I'd not had a Saab before, my 2 yrs of ownership has led me to a 9-3,150 bhp Tid sportwagon being the replacement as of today.

The 2.2 isn't especially quiet a low speeds although has reasonable torque and was enough for me to haul a twin axle car trailer with a GTV V6 back from Somerset at a good rate & still did an indicated 28 mpg. I couldn't have owned a better diesel estate for the money - Is that sufficient words of support for the 2.2 Tid?

addsvrs

Original Poster:

582 posts

216 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
Thanks for taking the time to post that, very helpful. I listed my car last night, going to test drive a 2.2 tomorrow so we will see how that goes. Is Vector the top spec for diesels ?

MrC986

3,492 posts

191 months

Wednesday 15th April 2015
quotequote all
YHM....as for the question on the family pecking order, I think you might be right on the Vector being the most spec''d standard car. Some have full leather and heated/electric seats were options too, just like the Aero model.