What's the best android sat nav app?

What's the best android sat nav app?

Author
Discussion

ecotec

Original Poster:

404 posts

128 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
I've been trying out various android sat nav apps as my current Garmin Sat Nav is getting on a bit (and it failed with routes a few times in France), the following are the ones I've tried and none of them seem as good as an actual sat nav...

HERE maps - offline maps but routes seem to be a little odd...
not very pretty display and keeps losing gps signal
Also will not show TomTom speed cam app on display

Waze - needs data - no good in rural east anglia! But i'm sure it's great in cities.

Google Maps - no current speed? or speed cam data.

TomTom - looks and works OK but costs £30 per year.

Any other great sat nav apps that I should try before I just give in and buy a Tom Tom sat nav?


Rick101

6,959 posts

149 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Co-pilot

ecotec

Original Poster:

404 posts

128 months

Sunday 4th September 2016
quotequote all
Rick101 said:
Co-pilot
Thanks, will download and try out, is it still being developed as no app update since Dec 15?

Rockatansky

1,697 posts

186 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
I use Sygic, works fine so far.

feef

5,206 posts

182 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Another Sygic user here. Gets my vote

dxg

8,121 posts

259 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
I find tomtom good. It picks up on traffic using its own system and that is its best feature, along with its suggestions of alternative routes as you're driving if they become quicker than the current one. Its camera warnings (although you have to pay more for those) are also very accurate.

Spare tyre

9,456 posts

129 months

Monday 5th September 2016
quotequote all
Don't forget waze caches stuff, mine works fine offline if you are going somewhere you have already been / plumbed in

I still keep my old 10 year old Tom Tom in glove box for if phone has a melt down


VladD

7,853 posts

264 months

Tuesday 6th September 2016
quotequote all
I use Sygic too.

Fore Left

1,411 posts

181 months

Wednesday 7th September 2016
quotequote all
Waze caches the map when it calculates the route so do your route planning while connected to wifi and don't close the app and it will be on the device for the duration.

Having used Waze for the first time a couple of weeks ago I think the community stuff is brilliant. It saved me a good 30 minutes on 2 hour trip last week.

One thing though, as it only gives verbal speed camera warnings if you're over the speed limit and assumes all variable speed limits on motorways are 70mph. Means you're only going to get visual alert if you're doing 69 mph in a 50 mph variable limit.

DamnKraut

456 posts

98 months

Wednesday 7th September 2016
quotequote all
If it needs to be for free and have offline maps I don't think there is a better alternative than HERE despite its shortcomings.
At least I haven't found one yet.

feef

5,206 posts

182 months

Thursday 8th September 2016
quotequote all
Sygic are offering a deal right now, I just got worldwide mapping and traffic for life for £29.99

Ste1987

1,798 posts

105 months

Thursday 8th September 2016
quotequote all
TomTom's £30 for 2 years isn't it? Unless it's changed since I got it

Ramona

173 posts

155 months

Thursday 8th September 2016
quotequote all
Having travelled the same 120 mile trip every week for a number of months, and having tried all the above, I found that by far the best routing came from Google Maps. I strongly suspect that it has the most up to date traffic data, so was the best at routing around any issues.

I use CamerAlert (from PocketGPSWorld) for a very up-to-date speed camera database; it is updated at least weekly and includes mobile sites. It can be used as an overlay with any navigation app.

I use Velociraptor to show the current speed limit, which it gets from Open Street Map and is generally accurate. It can also warn when you are a set amount over the limit (I have mine set to 10% + 2mph). It can show your current speed, although I prefer the display from SpeedOverlay to do this.

I use Automagic to start all of the above apps when my phone detects that it has connected to the Bluetooth in any of my cars, and to close them all down when I disconnect from the cars' Bluetooth.

Rick101

6,959 posts

149 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
Thought I give Sybic a try. Didn't even get as far as the Nav tbh.

Bit frustrating have to keep swiping away the pop ups saying to upgrade.
Putting destination in if you want to clear the last entry i.e street it seems to clear the whole lot an you have to start again.
Putting in my work address didn't work. Sets up for another street the same name other side of town even though it's clearly shown on the maps.

Pretty but not for me. Uninsalled. Back to copilot.

thetapeworm

11,191 posts

238 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
I'm probably biased as a beta tester and area manager but I find Waze covers most of the bases perfectly well for me.

If the data isn't there to meet your needs that can be an issue but the simple fix is to add it, either manually on the Waze editor app or by "paving" roads with the phone app if you travel them and they don't exist. It's likely a willing editor will then add these if they are missing.

When I first started to use it there were no roads, not even the ones in central Leeds, I paved them, added them manually, set directions, turn limitations etc until the infrastructure worked. Years later they actually bought some base maps so the majority of the road network is now covered and editors can enhance this and add to it. When I had issues with TomTom maps not including a major road in Leeds it took me over a year until it finally appeared, with Waze we can add roads as they are being built and then just enable them once they open.

Actual traffic data relies on other Waze users and I wish they would tap into the Google parent cache of Android / Google Maps data to help make this more useful but it only takes a couple of people or one active Waze user reporting issues to really make things work well.

On occasion I hire cars with Android head units and use Google Maps (Waze is due to work on them soon I believe) and while it's good it's just not quite as good as Waze.

This said there is room for improvement and the guidance is only as good as the maps / editors so some areas are better than others - it's evolving constantly and seems to be getting better and better in my opinion.

Oh and I'm keen to get more people on there so my experience is enhanced due to all the extra data wink

techguyone

3,137 posts

141 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
Waze is owned by Google you know.

OK I use Google maps as prime, Here as backup and this
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com....

Tomtom Speed Cameras (free) as an overlay. (Velociraptor isn't that great)

Google maps do offline too now btw, if you have the storage space.

All wrapped up in this. Carhome Ultra

https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=spin...


This means with my phone on its mount I can do anything journey related, make calls (bluetooth) map directions, current speed, speed cameras, hell even congestion via the tomtom overlay.

Android btw, Iphone lot need to look elsewhere.





Edited by techguyone on Friday 9th September 13:01

thetapeworm

11,191 posts

238 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
techguyone said:
Waze is owned by Google you know.
I do, that's why I said "Google parent" in my earlier post - they need to come up with a way of combining the best of both apps and allowing users to switch on / off the stuff they like to tailor it to their needs. Hardcore Google nav people might not want to collect "road goodies" or report road issues manually, likewise Waze users might not want the visuals of Google Nav.

rob0r

420 posts

169 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
I just use Google in the UK but I've just done 2900 miles in two weeks in France, Switzerland and Italy. I downloaded co-pilot for £22 and it was utterly brilliant and very configurable. I couldn't recommend it enough and can't see the need for a standalone satnav again.

techguyone

3,137 posts

141 months

Friday 9th September 2016
quotequote all
I tried the tomtom app version, but couldn't get on with it, especially as it was clearly designed for the device to be used portrait and I prefer landscape.

techguyone

3,137 posts

141 months

Sunday 11th September 2016
quotequote all
Just to illustrate how it looks