Is it just me that doesn't WANT built in sat nav?

Is it just me that doesn't WANT built in sat nav?

Author
Discussion

kennydies

198 posts

118 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
I only ever use google maps. Ideally I want the inbuilt sat nav to be Android based and is self updating.

Until that point I will always use my phone...

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
Magic919 said:
You can probably order your Boxster without satnav.
KevinCamaroSS said:
It might make a difference when selling the car?
Sure. So reduce the sale price. Nav is a £1k option. How much will it reduce the sale price by? A grand or more? Just tick the box and never use it. Less than a grand? Then you're quids in for not ticking it.

swisstoni

16,950 posts

279 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
Just need the screen to be able to mirror the phone display. Should be easy to implement.

kambites

67,544 posts

221 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Just need the screen to be able to mirror the phone display. Should be easy to implement.
You can certainly do it with a cheap off-the-shelf Chinese android head unit.

culpz

4,882 posts

112 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
This is my biggest bug while deciding on what car to get next. Since having it on my Scirocco and now my A4, i think i'd have to have inbuilt sat-nav. The sad thing is that i don't really do that many unknown trips to justify it but i just like to have it there ready, working within the car, if and when i need it.

cjs racing.

2,466 posts

129 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
I'm not a fan of built in sat navs.

My car doesn't have a built in system, and the Yeti my wife collected last months was ordered without it too.

We far prefer stand alone Garmins.

CraigyMc

16,387 posts

236 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
Phones and things like tomtom/garmin have limited size GPS receivers because they are small devices. Cars can have huge aerials.

Car systems can (and on my car, do) measure wheel speed so the car knows where it is when I'm driving in a tunnel, even if I stop.

If those two things could be used with a smartphone app like google maps, I'd be a happy bunny - for example, if the wheel speed was available via bluetooth, and if the car's GPS antenna was available to the phone.

Nobody allows casting with something like miracast of a phone screen onto an in-car display.

Unfortunately nobody bothers with that sort of integration.

Stickyfinger

8,429 posts

105 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
Roger Irrelevant said:
I don't get the '5 year old satnav is hopelessly out of date' thing - mine is from 2004 (so practically the dark ages), and granted I don't need to use it that much but when I do I put the postcode in, it gives me directions, I get there. What am I missing?
£15 on EBay and an update from TomTom....as you say, it gives directions/lanes, shouts at me for exceeding the speed limit and screams CAMERA when it should.

rampageturke

2,622 posts

162 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
CraigyMc said:
Phones and things like tomtom/garmin have limited size GPS receivers because they are small devices. Cars can have huge aerials.

Car systems can (and on my car, do) measure wheel speed so the car knows where it is when I'm driving in a tunnel, even if I stop.

If those two things could be used with a smartphone app like google maps, I'd be a happy bunny - for example, if the wheel speed was available via bluetooth, and if the car's GPS antenna was available to the phone.

Nobody allows casting with something like miracast of a phone screen onto an in-car display.

Unfortunately nobody bothers with that sort of integration.
I know it will be a nice feature to have, but is tunnel position really that important? Worried about missing your turnoff?

Dave Hedgehog

14,546 posts

204 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
kennydies said:
I only ever use google maps. Ideally I want the inbuilt sat nav to be Android based and is self updating.

Until that point I will always use my phone...
and that's the crux of the matter, car manufacturers are just so slow at modernising and updating tech / code

recently they have changed the layout of lewisham roundabout a several times because of the development there, the next day Waze had the new roads / changes loaded automatically

spookly

4,018 posts

95 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
I think they should put an industry standard HD touchscreen in there with a standard micro hdmi + USB connector in the glovebox.

Then you could use it to add whatever aftermarket audio/nav device you wanted to... or add an android auto/car play interface.... whatever you like. I bet the aftermarket would step in and make many fantastic products that put the OEM stuff to shame.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

126 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
spookly said:
I think they should put an industry standard HD touchscreen in there with a standard micro hdmi + USB connector in the glovebox.
Mmm. Whose product gets to become that standard?

xRIEx

8,180 posts

148 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
spookly said:
I think they should put an industry standard HD touchscreen in there with a standard micro hdmi + USB connector in the glovebox.
Mmm. Whose product gets to become that standard?
A product isn't a standard, it's nothing more than a set of defnitions; any manufacturer can then make a product that fits those definitions.

It's been done before with ICE: DIN and double-DIN slots. PCs and components have operated on standards for, what? 30 years? Almost every TV has been able to communicate with every DVD player (and vice versa; and VHS recorder, digibox, etc. etc.) via SCART, component, coax, HDMI (or whatever at the time) for decades without being restricted to a particular manufacturer. TV broadcasts could be received and interpreted by TVs from every manufacturer.

stupidbutkeen

1,010 posts

155 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
I just dont like to use any sat nav. don't have one in my car but I know most of the roads within N.Ireland anyways.
When I do go on road trips I take the motorbike and a proper map and enjoy the getting lost bit of the trip.


spookly

4,018 posts

95 months

Thursday 10th November 2016
quotequote all
TooMany2cvs said:
spookly said:
I think they should put an industry standard HD touchscreen in there with a standard micro hdmi + USB connector in the glovebox.
Mmm. Whose product gets to become that standard?
There are already standard universal screens with a common USB interface for touch input and hdmi for video signal....hence why I referenced them.... duh.

Have a look on ebay you'll find loads of touchscreens which you can use with almost any OS or system, most support native touch drivers, and of course USB.

I've used one of these universal touchscreens with a raspberry Pi, Linux, microcontrollers and Windows.... in fact I bet I could build a better sat nav unit with a Raspberry Pi and a few online traffic data sources than many manufacturers manage.


CraigyMc

16,387 posts

236 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
rampageturke said:
CraigyMc said:
Phones and things like tomtom/garmin have limited size GPS receivers because they are small devices. Cars can have huge aerials.

Car systems can (and on my car, do) measure wheel speed so the car knows where it is when I'm driving in a tunnel, even if I stop.

If those two things could be used with a smartphone app like google maps, I'd be a happy bunny - for example, if the wheel speed was available via bluetooth, and if the car's GPS antenna was available to the phone.

Nobody allows casting with something like miracast of a phone screen onto an in-car display.

Unfortunately nobody bothers with that sort of integration.
I know it will be a nice feature to have, but is tunnel position really that important? Worried about missing your turnoff?
Yes, it is. It copes well with situations where the GPS loses lock, like when you're in a city with tall buildings. The car does a decent job of knowing where it is based on previous location hisory (GPS) combined with compass heading and wheel speed. It's far more precise than guessing based on last heading and last speed known from the GPS.

Swampy1982

3,305 posts

111 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
my A4 has Android Auto for the screen, as well as playing your music etc.

My experience has been generally great, voice activated directions, always updated maps, no issue with losing GPS (can download route prior to journey) with the added bonus that I can use my work phone so zero data cost.


HappyMidget

6,788 posts

115 months

Friday 11th November 2016
quotequote all
rampageturke said:
I know it will be a nice feature to have, but is tunnel position really that important? Worried about missing your turnoff?
In Switzerland it is biggrin

Halmyre

11,183 posts

139 months

Monday 14th November 2016
quotequote all
I hate the SatNav on my wife's MX5. The screen is far too low, way out of my line of sight. A chameleon or Marty Feldman might be able to use it and keep an eye on the road at the same time, but I can't. If going anywhere long distance, I'll take my Garmin along.

Chainsaw Rebuild

2,004 posts

102 months

Monday 14th November 2016
quotequote all
Unless the built in system is Waze/has Waze style traffic updates its always going to be second best.