The PH build off

Poll: The PH build off

Total Members Polled: 40

The same 1:72 scale Revell aircraft: 80%
Any 1:72 scale Revell aircraft: 20%
Author
Discussion

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Zaxxon said:
Maybe forget the competition for the first couple of goes.
As there will be a big difference in skills. DR_gn that ME109 that you linked to is stunning and shows a very high attention to detail and skill.

Perhaps we should keep it simple so the person who is voted for as having done the best effort (not necesarrily best model) can choose the next subject.
It's your shout smile

dr_gn

16,168 posts

185 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Zaxxon said:
Perhaps we should keep it simple so the person who is voted for as having done the best effort (not necesarrily best model) can choose the next subject.
Or, how about combining both your ideas and have a competition for the "best effort" on a set model - considering experience, materials used and painting method? Seems to me to be an excellent compromise. That way anyone could use any amount of aftermarket stuff or airbrushing and it would still be a level playing field.

I would be up for that arrangement.

Zaxxon

4,057 posts

161 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Cool ok we'll go for that as DR_GN posted above.

This model?

http://www.revell.com/germany/aircraft/80-4374.htm...

Easy model to start with

Models to be completed by March 1st 2010

Is everyone up for that?

dr_gn

16,168 posts

185 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Zaxxon said:
Cool ok we'll go for that as DR_GN posted above.

This model?

http://www.revell.com/germany/aircraft/80-4374.htm...

Easy model to start with

Models to be completed by March 1st 2010

Is everyone up for that?
Although it was one of my nominations, I reckon now we've gone this far, we should put everyone's nominations to the vote.

Yertis

18,060 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Well I'm cool with the Russian thing. Looks easy enough.

biggrin

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Bugger - I'd have to buy that.

I have a KP one in my stash but that wouldn't be in line with the "Revell" requirement.

Cerberus90

1,553 posts

214 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
I recently built the Revell Me 109G, IMO, not the greatest kit. The wheels didn't work very well for me.


The Hurricane however is an excellent model, the Tempest is also pretty nice, although my invasion stripes aren't very straight when you look at it closely, biggrin


Maybe it'd be good to try and get a model that no one, or at least, very few people have built?

Yertis

18,060 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Cerberus90 said:
my invasion stripes aren't very straight when you look at it closely, biggrin
So quite authentic. For D-Day They were applied in great haste, sometimes using brooms.

(Having just looked this up I see Typhoons and some Tempests had them painted on at the factory so they were probably quite neat.)

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Is the Revell Tempest a repop of the Heller Tempest? If it is, the Airfix kit could also be used as that is definitely a repop of the Heller Tempest.

It's amazing how often one manufacturer's product ends up in other manufacturers' boxes.

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Interesting news in IPMS Germany website is that Revell will be issuing a "new tool" 1/72 Halifax in 2011. This would be great if true. A couple of years ago they released the old Matchbox Halifax which, whilst welcome, has serious shape issues with its cocpit canopy.

Not suggesting it for the build off - but I was having a go at Revell a few posts ago for not producing that many British WW2 subjects. Maybe they are now looking at this area for new releases - I bet their new Lancaster has sold well.

SlipStream77

2,153 posts

192 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
dr_gn said:
I reckon now we've gone this far, we should put everyone's nominations to the vote.
+1

Edited by SlipStream77 on Friday 7th January 14:29

Cerberus90

1,553 posts

214 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Interesting news in IPMS Germany website is that Revell will be issuing a "new tool" 1/72 Halifax in 2011. This would be great if true. A couple of years ago they released the old Matchbox Halifax which, whilst welcome, has serious shape issues with its cocpit canopy.

Not suggesting it for the build off - but I was having a go at Revell a few posts ago for not producing that many British WW2 subjects. Maybe they are now looking at this area for new releases - I bet their new Lancaster has sold well.
My Revell Halifax was quite a nice build. biggrin




So I shouldn't buy La-5 yet?

Edited by Cerberus90 on Friday 7th January 15:03

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Cerberus90 said:
Eric Mc said:
Interesting news in IPMS Germany website is that Revell will be issuing a "new tool" 1/72 Halifax in 2011. This would be great if true. A couple of years ago they released the old Matchbox Halifax which, whilst welcome, has serious shape issues with its cocpit canopy.

Not suggesting it for the build off - but I was having a go at Revell a few posts ago for not producing that many British WW2 subjects. Maybe they are now looking at this area for new releases - I bet their new Lancaster has sold well.
My Revell Halifax was quite a nice build. biggrin



Edited by Cerberus90 on Friday 7th January 15:03
It makes up into a nice model - but the windscreen is completely wrong - unfortunately.

Ironically, Airfix's Halifax, which is a much older mould and VERY hard to turn into a decent model, got the windscreen shape correct.

Edited by Eric Mc on Friday 7th January 15:09

Yertis

18,060 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Cerberus90 said:
Are we all going to bid on that one?

Yertis

18,060 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Am I unique in finding myself overwhelmed by the urge to rush out to the local model shop to look for an La-5, now I have 'legitimate' excuse?

Pathetic isn't it, really.

dr_gn

16,168 posts

185 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Yertis said:
Am I unique in finding myself overwhelmed by the urge to rush out to the local model shop to look for an La-5, now I have 'legitimate' excuse?

Pathetic isn't it, really.
I quite fancy the Walrus now paperbag

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
I'd put the Walrus at the top of my list now too.

Cerberus90

1,553 posts

214 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Yertis said:
Cerberus90 said:
Are we all going to bid on that one?
Hope not as there's only 3.


Only problem with this La 5 is, to me it doesn't seem readily available.

e-models don't have it, and there's not many on ebay.

Yertis

18,060 posts

267 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Please let it not be the Walrus, none of my family or friends will believe I've assembled it correctly.

Eric Mc

122,050 posts

266 months

Friday 7th January 2011
quotequote all
Yertis said:
Please let it not be the Walrus, none of my family or friends will believe I've assembled it correctly.
That'll be a plus point.