Cooper S Query

Cooper S Query

Author
Discussion

aaruck

Original Poster:

829 posts

239 months

Tuesday 5th May 2015
quotequote all
Hi, we're wondering about getting a Cooper S for my wife (subject to seeing if the boot is big enough for the pushchair etc). I'm just wondering if they have any common faults that I should consider? I notice from 2007 that the engine gets a bit more power and more mpg so we'd probably try to stretch to one around that time. Thanks for any help.

rigga

8,730 posts

201 months

Wednesday 6th May 2015
quotequote all
Won't get a pushchair in the boot without lowering the rear seats unless its a very compact version.
2007 on cooper s has lots of possible issue's, drinks oil for fun, possible can chain problems and high pressure fuel pump issue's amongst others, great to drive though.

Edited by rigga on Wednesday 6th May 07:27

Maracus

4,235 posts

168 months

Wednesday 6th May 2015
quotequote all
Could you look at a late Gen 1 Suoercharger, or a late Gen 2 N18 184BHP model?

FUBMW

39 posts

139 months

Wednesday 6th May 2015
quotequote all
As an R56 MCS owner...

You won't fit a pram into the boot of an R56. The weekly shop seems to be as much as it can take. Anything more and the rear seats need to come down. Speaking of rear seats, you are unlikely to get anyone into the back seats at all the space is that sparse.

I've had mine for 2 years, 30000 miles. In that time, it has cost me £600 in servicing, £380 in a cracked alloy and $400 on tyres. My timing chain and tensioner have never been changed, HPFP has never had an issue either and both look to be holding up fairly well.

The interior can be squeaky on some cars, but mine hasn't been too bad. The best change I ever made was to move to non-runflat tyres. It transformed the car. On the whole it is a brilliant car, and the moments when I have a laugh with the car outweigh the moments I get frustrated at its ergonomic shortcomings...especially when the exhaust pops when I change gear smile

Any questions gimme a shout!

Maracus

4,235 posts

168 months

Wednesday 6th May 2015
quotequote all
When my 5'2 wife drives, all 4 of us can get in our R56 with no broken bones biggrin

As said, the boot is good for shopping and a couple of rucksacks. I've managed to fit 4 x 17 wheels and tyres in with the seats down.

mike9009

7,005 posts

243 months

Thursday 7th May 2015
quotequote all
We have a Clubman S (2007 model) - with the turbo rather than supercharger.

It can fit a pram in the back - Mamas and papas buggy we have fits okay in the boot. We have also had a 2004 MINI Cooper S and fitting a pram in the boot is an impossibility.

We have a two year old and six year old. For longer journeys we have a roof box. With one child we used to fit a pram behind the passenger seat to give more space in the boot.

Problems with the car have been few and far between for us (I have had the car four years now). Tyres can be expensive. We had the thermostat housing crack and needing replacement (£205 fully fitted from BMW). It likes a drink of oil so needs regular checking (TADTS)

They can suffer from timing chain failure (expensive!!) but I 'think' this is linked to the oil consumption and not checking regularly enough - others disagree on this point. They start to sound like a diesel when it starts to happen. When I first had mine it had the death rattle and had a new tensioner put on. Now 30k miles later it is still fine....

neil_w

79 posts

198 months

Saturday 9th May 2015
quotequote all
We used to have a 2004 Cooper S and could get a BabyJogger City Mini buggy in the boot with room for a couple of shopping bags, had to remove the parcel shelf though. Not tried it in the newer 2007 onwards mini but I thought the boot was meant to be marginally bigger on them.

L3090

73 posts

139 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
If you're looking at an R56, try and get an LCI.

They're from circa October 2010 onwards.

Pre LCI models are notorious for coking of the engine and also the timing chains needing to be replaced.

Search it up on MINI forums, they'll be plenty of info.

The later engines were much more improved.

AAD44H

410 posts

159 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
R56 Death Rattle, type this in to google and it may help you change your mind!

Maracus

4,235 posts

168 months

Sunday 10th May 2015
quotequote all
LCI is the way ahead. Look for the N18 184BHP model.

The death rattle was fixed on the N18, I believe with a redesign of the tensioner. As mentioned above, ensuring the oil level is checked regularly is paramount.

Our N18/LCI is on 41k and is running perfectly.