Young driver insurance cost

Young driver insurance cost

Author
Discussion

John D9395

Original Poster:

377 posts

208 months

Friday 24th June 2016
quotequote all
Hi

Looking to buy a car, probably 07 / 08 for my daughter who will hopefully pass her test sometime in the near future.

Started looking at Toyota Aygo, but gave realised that insurance on Mini's is similar.

That said, on line insurance seems to be significantly cheaper on a 1.6 copper, than a 1.4 mini one.

To me, this doesn't seem right given the extra engine size and performance.

Can anyone confirm this is correct and not a 'direct line's glitch, I don't want to buy something that we on after find is too expensive to insure.

Thanks


Boogs

407 posts

143 months

Friday 24th June 2016
quotequote all
It's just a numbers game. New drivers expect a One to be cheaper so they all buy them. The one then gets a poor rep for accidents and price goes up, in the meantime the coopers are not having accidents and stay down.

Same thing with keeping a car on drive can be cheaper than in garage.

Run it through a comparison site and see what comes up. That way you know you are not reliant upon 1 insurer.

Mini insurance does seem to be quite good, My 19yo son has an MCS and it was only £200 a year more than a 1.2 corsa that he had before. 184bhp versus about 70!

John D9395

Original Poster:

377 posts

208 months

Sunday 3rd July 2016
quotequote all

Well the deed is done, an 08 Mini Copper has been purchased.

Really pleased with it, daughter even more pleased, she should be, I never had a car like that to learn in when I was 17!

mph1977

12,467 posts

168 months

Sunday 3rd July 2016
quotequote all
Boogs said:
It's just a numbers game. New drivers expect a One to be cheaper so they all buy them. The one then gets a poor rep for accidents and price goes up, in the meantime the coopers are not having accidents and stay down.

Same thing with keeping a car on drive can be cheaper than in garage.

Run it through a comparison site and see what comes up. That way you know you are not reliant upon 1 insurer.

Mini insurance does seem to be quite good, My 19yo son has an MCS and it was only £200 a year more than a 1.2 corsa that he had before. 184bhp versus about 70!
it's all about claims experience ... arguably the car is one of the least relevant factors in car insurance

comapred to driver / age / experience / history and the locality the vehicle is kept and driven in ...

younger / less expereinced rivers have more crashes and tend to have more spectacualr crashes as well ( plus the car full of students is rather more expensive in terms of the potential personal injury claims than a singleton or couple a few years older)