One for the Legal bods - scummy company

One for the Legal bods - scummy company

Author
Discussion

KFC

3,687 posts

130 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
I don't see how you can realistically get "justice" without causing irreparable harm to her career. I would forget it and move on.

Doodlebug87

Original Poster:

188 posts

113 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
Surely the harm has already been done when a prospective new employer asks the s for a reference?

User33678888

1,142 posts

137 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
Companies cannot legally give bad references any more. She may be entitled to a bit of compensation. You won't know how much most of that is until you know how long she is between jobs.
You/she needs to do the following things:
1) Sign on. Not for the JSA but all the other stuff like housing helps when you don't have an income. She's paid in so should feel no guilt taking something back out of the pot.
2) Get a new job. ASAP
3) Once new job is started and secure, then worry about the legal aspects of this. Nobody in their right mind would go back, so getting something new going has to be the priority. Any payout will not be huge - she really really needs a new job.

edc

9,235 posts

251 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
What sort of justice do you want? Some sort of reprimand for the company that will come from another body and change the decision making process? That's not going to happen. Some monetary award to you? As I've already written, that's not going to be big enough to be really worth the effort. You should for the time being lodge an appeal if you so wish then quickly move on to the job search. Your only real hope of getting anything like significant monies is by making a discrimination claim stick and by all accounts from what you describe and the success rate of those cases that seems highly unlikely.

edc

9,235 posts

251 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
swerni said:
edc said:
What sort of justice do you want? Some sort of reprimand for the company that will come from another body and change the decision making process? That's not going to happen. Some monetary award to you? As I've already written, that's not going to be big enough to be really worth the effort. You should for the time being lodge an appeal if you so wish then quickly move on to the job search. Your only real hope of getting anything like significant monies is by making a discrimination claim stick and by all accounts from what you describe and the success rate of those cases that seems highly unlikely.
i'd go back and look for a compromise.
Good reference and payment for any holiday owed, outstanding commission and notice period to leave quietly.

They would be mad to say no
As an HR person, I would be making all the correct payments anyway. I would assess the risk of a claim and if on the face of it like this case it looks unlikely then I would not propose a compromise agreement.

As an employee you need to understand that a compromise agreement curtails your rights to make claims. Take this document to your legal representative and with only contractual payments covered they would likely advise you that you are mad to sign away your rights for nothing in return. The compromise agreement is a binding document and it cannot fabricate the reason for leaving.

barryrs

4,389 posts

223 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
I think she "could" bring a claim against the company for unfair dismissal on the basis that she was dismissed before she could take action to enforce a statutory right.

"There are certain types of dismissals that are automatically unfair. This means that the employee does not have to have worked for 2 years in order to make a claim."

"The statutory right being that your employer should protect you from being bullied at work."



KFC

3,687 posts

130 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
User33678888 said:
Companies cannot legally give bad references any more.
Drivel like this is a great example of why you shouldn't take legal advice for free from an unrelated car forum.


A lot of solicitors will give you a free consultation; I suggest you go take one of them up on it.

User33678888

1,142 posts

137 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
KFC said:
User33678888 said:
Companies cannot legally give bad references any more.
Drivel like this is a great example of why you shouldn't take legal advice for free from an unrelated car forum.


A lot of solicitors will give you a free consultation; I suggest you go take one of them up on it.
Just passing on what I'd been told by an HR bod a few years ago.
Two of you have said pretty much what you have so I'm probably wrong. The rest of my post - re getting a new job asap still applies, ta.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

233 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
OP it would seem that on balance the very best thing your wife could do is go to work for a direct competitor and make it her aim in life to capture ever single 10p to £10bn account the old company has.

There may be grounds for a claim, there may not be, but the last thing I think either of you need is to have this continue to hang around your necks.

There are a few people in this life that I have a special dislike for. It has given me great pleasure over the years to have found on the odd occasion that it is within my power, or sphere of influence, to, completely within professional and legal boundaries, ensure that they have a really fking bad day from time to time. It's nothing so dark as something I look for, more that cards have been marked and when opportunity knocks I'm not the sort to walk away.

elanfan

5,520 posts

227 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
Doodlebug87 said:
We already have written statements from employee's provided by the company - there are at least a few which describe the guy as flying off the rail at my wife unprovoked and scaring everybody, resulting in my wife breaking down outside the meeting room. Being that she has been there less than two years, options are a little more limited by all accounts but there must be a way to get some justice, and if there is I will find it
My brain isn't working properly tonight and I can't think of the phrase I'm looking for (help?). Anyway isn't it considered assault or something similar if you are left I fear and ........ by someone else's actions. Report to Police if so and get him arrested??.?

KFC

3,687 posts

130 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
elanfan said:
My brain isn't working properly tonight and I can't think of the phrase I'm looking for (help?). Anyway isn't it considered assault or something similar if you are left I fear and ........ by someone else's actions. Report to Police if so and get him arrested??.?
Sales meeting gets a bit shouty..... weeks later the 'victim' goes to police and has someone dragged off to the police station.

Take a wild guess at what this does for the employability of the person who got the police involved?

edc

9,235 posts

251 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
elanfan said:
My brain isn't working properly tonight and I can't think of the phrase I'm looking for (help?). Anyway isn't it considered assault or something similar if you are left I fear and ........ by someone else's actions. Report to Police if so and get him arrested??.?
Honestly, get real. If every person was reported for shouting at somebody then we would all be in prison. Every other parent would be on Childline and social services watch list and every pub would have customers arrested every night.

anonymous-user

54 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
i would speak to ACAS, you go to tribunal, i.e get job back, compensation etc.

she gets another job and follow thru with claim, people get sacked everyday for unfair reasons, which you can't change. move on life is too short for politics.

edc

9,235 posts

251 months

Wednesday 8th July 2015
quotequote all
Unfair dismissal is a legal term and is not the same as being dismissed for what one might perceive as unfair reasons. Likewise discrimination has a legal meaning. Just because one may feel that they are a victim of discrimination does not mean they actually are in the legal sense.

elanfan

5,520 posts

227 months

Thursday 9th July 2015
quotequote all
edc said:
elanfan said:
My brain isn't working properly tonight and I can't think of the phrase I'm looking for (help?). Anyway isn't it considered assault or something similar if you are left I fear and ........ by someone else's actions. Report to Police if so and get him arrested??.?
Honestly, get real. If every person was reported for shouting at somebody then we would all be in prison. Every other parent would be on Childline and social services watch list and every pub would have customers arrested every night.
Fairy muff I did say my brain wasn't working properly. Would love to see the guy get his just desserts tho'

Pegscratch

1,872 posts

108 months

Thursday 9th July 2015
quotequote all
User33678888 said:
Just passing on what I'd been told by an HR bod a few years ago.
Two of you have said pretty much what you have so I'm probably wrong. The rest of my post - re getting a new job asap still applies, ta.
My advice is to ignore the HR bod who gave you this advice when it comes to HR advice. If you're good friends with them, you might want to gently suggest a change of career for them.

Grumfutock

5,274 posts

165 months

Thursday 9th July 2015
quotequote all
Just place a turd in the air con vent on the way out!