BMW E61 M5 Touring

BMW E61 M5 Touring

Author
Discussion

davewhitt

136 posts

142 months

Monday 29th September 2014
quotequote all
don't forget the last few with the updated idrive

fwordm3

17 posts

128 months

Monday 29th September 2014
quotequote all
A great read and thanks for sharing...

longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Tuesday 30th September 2014
quotequote all
RC1 said:
Good to know thanks

So when does a post facelift come in at under 15k or am I dreaming and will I need to take a chance with a rs6 instead?!
I assume you're talking about the C5 RS6 then?

After everything I've read about the E61 M5, I reckon it would be far cheaper to run than a C5.

AW10

4,432 posts

249 months

Tuesday 30th September 2014
quotequote all
RC1 said:
How are these beasts in the snow with snow tyres on? My e39 with its almighty 2.5l 6 cylinder is shod with nokians each winter and is perfectly driveable but it's not quite the beast the m5 is
Very controllable and sure footed on snows and amazingly skittish on the summer Michelins when it's below zero!

ecain63

10,588 posts

175 months

Tuesday 30th September 2014
quotequote all
longfellow said:
RC1 said:
Good to know thanks

So when does a post facelift come in at under 15k or am I dreaming and will I need to take a chance with a rs6 instead?!
I assume you're talking about the C5 RS6 then?

After everything I've read about the E61 M5, I reckon it would be far cheaper to run than a C5.
Ive owned both. A sorted M5 is heavier on the wallet than the sorted RS6. A dog M5 is also heavier on the wallet.

C5 RS6's are brittle beasts. The M5 is just expensive!



longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Wednesday 1st October 2014
quotequote all
ecain63 said:
longfellow said:
RC1 said:
Good to know thanks

So when does a post facelift come in at under 15k or am I dreaming and will I need to take a chance with a rs6 instead?!
I assume you're talking about the C5 RS6 then?

After everything I've read about the E61 M5, I reckon it would be far cheaper to run than a C5.
Ive owned both. A sorted M5 is heavier on the wallet than the sorted RS6. A dog M5 is also heavier on the wallet.

C5 RS6's are brittle beasts. The M5 is just expensive!


That's a fair point actually. I suppose in terms of maintenance and fuel, the M5 is more expensive but then the RS6 is as you say, "brittle" and can end up costing you a fortune.

DUring my last 5 months of ownership, the Plus has had the IC's refurbed, new N75, new rear view mirror and a new gearbox valve body harness.
It now needs a new steering rack and EGT sensor which is probably going to set me back a couple of grand. It would be closer to £3k if I couldn't get the parts cheap.

Eddie, did you have any issues during your M5 ownership such as iDrive failure etc?

RC1

4,097 posts

219 months

Wednesday 1st October 2014
quotequote all
I think from a total cost of ownership I might be better off with the c5 rs6 that's sorted... say I keep it for 3 years and assuming I get one that's had the big bills sorted already, then I reckon my running costs will be lower than the depreciation hit on the m5 in addition to any potential bills...

I can get into a sorted rs now for about 10k with rad, brakes, cambelt, water pump etc, tyres, coolers and drc stuff already done but I cant get change from 18k for a pre lci m5

I know the rs might be a little agricultural in comparison to the m5 but I cant resist the allure of that v8...

does that look about right??

Carlton Banks

3,640 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st October 2014
quotequote all
Im torn between a c63 and an e61 M5 as my next car.

Wish you hadn't posted this thread!

metsta

425 posts

223 months

Wednesday 1st October 2014
quotequote all
Yes painted carbon black



longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
metsta said:
Yes painted carbon black


Metsta, is yours currently for sale in the classifieds?

longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
RC1 said:
I think from a total cost of ownership I might be better off with the c5 rs6 that's sorted... say I keep it for 3 years and assuming I get one that's had the big bills sorted already, then I reckon my running costs will be lower than the depreciation hit on the m5 in addition to any potential bills...

I can get into a sorted rs now for about 10k with rad, brakes, cambelt, water pump etc, tyres, coolers and drc stuff already done but I cant get change from 18k for a pre lci m5

I know the rs might be a little agricultural in comparison to the m5 but I cant resist the allure of that v8...

does that look about right??
Well that's what I thought a sorted car was and I've been stung with a new rack and will be replacing a dodgy EGT sensor and if I was to use MRC (RS specialist), I would be looking at a bill of more than £3k, then if my gearbox decides enough is enough, then that's another £3.5/4K.
The alternator is also a common failure but can be done as a DIY and the ABS pump has also been know to let go.

These are things that have plagued most C5 owners, just check out RS246 for evidence etc.

I don't want to put you off but these monsters can literally haemorrhage money but when they're running well, they can be awesome.
I absolutely love the sound of the V8 and the way it pulls is addictive but I really miss the E60's quality interior.

If you're thinking of a saloon, you can pick up a pre-lci for around 15-16k without stupid miles but if you're talking about a touring which are all LCI FYI wink then yes, you won't find one for less than 18 g's.

batmanreturns

Original Poster:

536 posts

269 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
I had a C5 RS6 as well, the first service i had it in for cost me £3k in just basic stuff and then a few thousand miles later the gearbox was on it's way out. All those Audi's RS6's from that era were badly built on the mechanical side of things and it's a constant case of changing parts out and listening out for the next problem. The inteiro is very dated now as well.

The E60/E61 on the other hand is a great drive, much more upto date and both of mine have cost nothing more than general service items. Mine just had the 'big' one at 60k which cost £750 at a main dealer.

You'd have way more fun in the BMW and less cost.

RC1

4,097 posts

219 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
yep the more I look into it its almost impossible to find one car that's had all the bits tended to which does present me with a potentially crippling liability that makes a 10k car easily a 3k car because of what I need to do to fix it...

im still looking though and am wondering whether the 550i touring might be the compromise because the m5 touring will def be out of reach at 18k

longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
The 550i Tourings are like three legged rocking horse sh!t.

There was one for sale at the beginning of the year that I was tempted by and it had every conceivable extra bar a heated steering wheel. It looked lovely. But I decided to step into the world of RS6 madness instead.




Lefty

16,149 posts

202 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
I really like the v10 m5 and was looking for an e61 m5 but really struggled to find one with nice spec and colour scheme, ended up with a c6 rs6 which is much, much faster but less "fun" and sounds much less exciting. Gearbox is much nicer though...

Edited by Lefty on Thursday 2nd October 16:20

RC1

4,097 posts

219 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
if I can pootle around in the e39 until next may then maybe a private sale m5 will be within grasp at 15k?

after many an hour spent on rs246 and learning more about peoples real life experiences with the c5 rs6 I don't think my balls are big enough to take it on just yet

longfellow

551 posts

143 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
RC1 said:
if I can pootle around in the e39 until next may then maybe a private sale m5 will be within grasp at 15k?

after many an hour spent on rs246 and learning more about peoples real life experiences with the c5 rs6 I don't think my balls are big enough to take it on just yet
I wish I was a wise man!!!!

RC1

4,097 posts

219 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
are you looking to get out of your c5 rs6 into the e61 m5 then??

hamish382

3 posts

114 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
I have been lurking about on here for a while now, but thought I would finally sign up since I have one of these. In a year and a half of ownership it has proved to be awesome fun with only a few downsides;
Failed ionic spark detection module - fixed under warranty, although I would hate to think of the cost
Fuel usage - 18mpg usually, less than 200 miles out of a tank once
Tyres, they seem to vanish quickly!
Gearbox is a bit of a nuisance in slow traffic.

On the up sides, it always puts a smile on my face, is very comfy when required, very nice to drive on the local back roads and is actually pretty good in snow too with winter tyres.








Lefty

16,149 posts

202 months

Thursday 2nd October 2014
quotequote all
hamish382 said:
I have been lurking about on here for a while now, but thought I would finally sign up since I have one of these. In a year and a half of ownership it has proved to be awesome fun with only a few downsides;
Failed ionic spark detection module - fixed under warranty, although I would hate to think of the cost
Fuel usage - 18mpg usually, less than 200 miles out of a tank once
Tyres, they seem to vanish quickly!
Gearbox is a bit of a nuisance in slow traffic.

On the up sides, it always puts a smile on my face, is very comfy when required, very nice to drive on the local back roads and is actually pretty good in snow too with winter tyres.







Fantastic colour, black leather?