Advice on a 97 M3 Evo

Advice on a 97 M3 Evo

Author
Discussion

dan101smith

16,802 posts

212 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
Oh come on, you had a bad experience and now are claiming they're all going to explode.

It seems every instance of Vanos failure is documented on the forums, so I'd expect engine failures to be as well (that's tongue in cheek, by the way).

Like any car they have issues, but nowhere near the ridiculous levels you're claiming.

french

520 posts

201 months

Tuesday 13th May 2008
quotequote all
If a cars run on a shoestring budget then st happens, I'm not saying you did this boulder but possibly previous owners may have neglected it?

hey I not saying BM's dont have silly bloody annoying crappy faults such as plastic radiator necks , thermostat covers & those crappy dual heater spouts that break off when they decide to work but in this instance I think Dan's making a fair point thumbup

E36GUY

5,906 posts

219 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Frik said:
dan101smith said:
Nah that's simply not true.
Spot on.
yes The 3.2 engine is almost bullet-proof aside from rare (but over-hyped) VANOS issues. It's true that if you lose your gearbox that will be replaced becasue the 6 speed unit is sealed. Other than that there are no other documented regular problems.

With relibility issues you will always hear about the problems and rarely the "my car's absolutely fine" which paints an inaccurate picture. Out of the 000s of RHD models true failures are rare.

andye30m3

3,453 posts

255 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
E36GUY said:
Frik said:
dan101smith said:
Nah that's simply not true.
Spot on.
yes The 3.2 engine is almost bullet-proof aside from rare (but over-hyped) VANOS issues. It's true that if you lose your gearbox that will be replaced becasue the 6 speed unit is sealed. Other than that there are no other documented regular problems.

With relibility issues you will always hear about the problems and rarely the "my car's absolutely fine" which paints an inaccurate picture. Out of the 000s of RHD models true failures are rare.
I'm sorry but having had my M3 for 18 months and having had to replace 1 bottom end, there is an issue. Its not that common but not unheard off. When i posted about mine on E36coupe.com there was someone who was looking into the bottom end failures as it often seamed to occur within a couple of hundered miles of a service.

The Specialist who swapped my engine out suggested they'd seen a number of bottom end failures before.

AM-BM

261 posts

201 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
Boulder said:
Sell it and buy a 330CI.

Seriously sounds like you have a money pit there,im very wary of the evo engine after 100k miles.Wouldnt dare thrash one.

Speaking from experience.
Lol and have to ring it's neck all the time to get past all the reps TDI's!!!!!!!!

No thanks :-)

Boulder

167 posts

204 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all
AM-BM said:
Boulder said:
Sell it and buy a 330CI.

Seriously sounds like you have a money pit there,im very wary of the evo engine after 100k miles.Wouldnt dare thrash one.

Speaking from experience.
Lol and have to ring it's neck all the time to get past all the reps TDI's!!!!!!!!

No thanks :-)
If you can see through the soot!

M3John

5,974 posts

220 months

Wednesday 14th May 2008
quotequote all

Some interesting reading on here guys.


dan101smith said:
Might this also be time to consider swapping the steering rack out for the Z3 item?

Mine has started to let a little bit of oil go and a new rack is on the cards. I've herd something about a Z3 rack but could you shead some light on it for me please?

dan101smith said:
Mine is on 127k and going very well thanks! They're reliable engines, but like any car (and certainly any car with its performance) will need some care to keep it in top condition.

yes ^^ and mine has done 120k now - still going well and still pulling like a train.

RWDKurt

163 posts

247 months

Thursday 15th May 2008
quotequote all
My 115K miler M3 Evo has just made it to the Ring and back without using a drop of oil, unlike two of the three Honda Type R cars that were in our group. One is using oil like a 2 stroke, the other is on a low loader with a recently rebuilt (sub 100k) engine that's developed another fault.

My point: M3 engines can fail, as can any other. I wouldn't advise against a Type R Honda based on this experience, nor would I suggest that the M3 engine is bulletproof.

E36 M3s are, by and large, hugely good value for money and can be improved significantly without spending a fortune. I'd fix what needs fixing and use the car for a while before making up your mind about selling.

Kurt

matth76

83 posts

194 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
Boulder said:
Sell it and buy a 330CI.

Seriously sounds like you have a money pit there,im very wary of the evo engine after 100k miles.Wouldnt dare thrash one.

Speaking from experience.
100k miles is nothing. If it's well looked after and serviced regularly it should go on and on.