US Top Gun started by British Fleet Air Arm

US Top Gun started by British Fleet Air Arm

Author
Discussion

Ayahuasca

Original Poster:

27,427 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all

erolb

506 posts

188 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Excellent post. Extremely interesting.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Like most areas of military doctrine. We invent it and then someone with more cash and resources runs with it.

SF, Subs training, Commando training, the afore mentioned Top Gun, Flight testing, etc.

Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
When did the British invent Flight Testing?

Hooli

32,278 posts

201 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
When did the British invent Flight Testing?
Just after we invented the first British aeroplane smile

Mr_B

10,480 posts

244 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
The Top Gun wiki page is interesting. Maybe needing an edit ?

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
When did the British invent Flight Testing?
Let me qualify what I mean by 'invent' - develop the internationally recognised good practice based on structured, rigorous, and where applicable, scientific methods biggrin


Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Hooli said:
Eric Mc said:
When did the British invent Flight Testing?
Just after we invented the first British aeroplane smile
That would be five years after the Americans then.

It's a moot point really. Every time an early pioneer took a contraption up into the air he was "testing" the machine. In that regard, they all invented test flying up to a point. You COULD probably argue that the first proper test pilot was George Cayley's footman - who was a passenger in Cayley's man carrying glider in the 1850s.

I would suggest that the first dedicated Test Flying institution was the US National Advisory Committee on Aeronautics (NACA) which was established as far back as 1915 (4 years before the British Royal Aircraft Establishment - the RAE). NACA still exists in its better known modern form, NASA.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Hooli said:
Eric Mc said:
When did the British invent Flight Testing?
Just after we invented the first British aeroplane smile
That would be five years after the Americans then.

It's a moot point really. Every time an early pioneer took a contraption up into the air he was "testing" the machine. In that regard, they all invented test flying up to a point. You COULD probably argue that the first proper test pilot was George Cayley's footman - who was a passenger in Cayley's man carrying glider in the 1850s.

I would suggest that the first dedicated Test Flying institution was the US National Advisory Committee on Aeronautics (NACA) which was established as far back as 1915 (4 years before the British Royal Aircraft Establishment - the RAE). NACA still exists in its better known modern form, NASA.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/George_Cayley

Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Indeed, the first test pilots were French, Pilatre deRozier and the Marquis d'Arlande - who made the first untethered free flight in any sort of flying machine in 1783.

Ginetta G15 Girl

3,220 posts

185 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
I would suggest that the first dedicated Test Flying institution was the US National Advisory Committee on Aeronautics (NACA) which was established as far back as 1915 (4 years before the British Royal Aircraft Establishment - the RAE). NACA still exists in its better known modern form, NASA.
The RAE came into being in 1918 not 1919.

I would argue that the birth of The Royal Aircraft Factory in 1912 (which was re christened the RAE so as to avoid confusion with the birth of the RAF on 1 April 1918), and which having been re branded from the Royal Balloon Factory (born in 1904) comprehensively trumps NACA!

biggrin

Ayahuasca

Original Poster:

27,427 posts

280 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Would have been good if the Top Gun film had incorporated Miramar's British origins.

e.g.

"I feel the need. The need for a nice cup of tea and a sit down."




Ginetta G15 Girl

3,220 posts

185 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Ayahuasca said:
e.g.

"I feel the need. The need for a nice cup of tea and a sit down."
I can't speak for the FAA but I would assume that its pilots are similar to RAF pilots in that the majority drink coffee.

Tea is very much an Army thing.

Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Ginetta G15 Girl said:
Eric Mc said:
I would suggest that the first dedicated Test Flying institution was the US National Advisory Committee on Aeronautics (NACA) which was established as far back as 1915 (4 years before the British Royal Aircraft Establishment - the RAE). NACA still exists in its better known modern form, NASA.
The RAE came into being in 1918 not 1919.

I would argue that the birth of The Royal Aircraft Factory in 1912 (which was re christened the RAE so as to avoid confusion with the birth of the RAF on 1 April 1918), and which having been re branded from the Royal Balloon Factory (born in 1904) comprehensively trumps NACA!

biggrin
It was a factory rather than a dedicated test establishment. Obviously, all early flying had a large element of testing associated with it due to the nature of early aviation. But it's main job was to produce balloons, airships and aircraft for the RFC.

The NACA produced nothing. It's job was to provide academnic input and testing for the benefit of all US aircraft manufacturers. Something the RAE was also tasked to do when it was set up a few years later. My view is that the NACA was the role model for the RAE.

Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Ginetta G15 Girl said:
Ayahuasca said:
e.g.

"I feel the need. The need for a nice cup of tea and a sit down."
I can't speak for the FAA but I would assume that its pilots are similar to RAF pilots in that the majority drink coffee.

Tea is very much an Army thing.
I bet the FAA drank tea - laced with rum.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Indeed, the first test pilots were French, Pilatre deRozier and the Marquis d'Arlande - who made the first untethered free flight in any sort of flying machine in 1783.
Yes, but being the first ever pilot does not flight testing make.

There is a world of difference between flying a plane and commenting on how it flys, to the use of rigorous scientific method to assess flight characteristics, the invention of which can be attributed to Cayley.

Where the US did beat us though WRT scientific flight testing was in the area of cockpit ergonomics - it was an America Alphonse Chapanis, who invented the wheel shape coding for landing gear levers.

Anyway, lets move on, we could argue this all day. My original point is generally correct, so let's ignore the flight testing bit.

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Ayahuasca said:
Would have been good if the Top Gun film had incorporated Miramar's British origins.

e.g.

"I feel the need. The need for a nice cup of tea and a sit down."
The British influences are clear IMO. Goose is clearly sporting a DEFSTAN 00-198 Moustache MkIIb.


Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
Spoilsport smile

Other FAA inventions used today by the US Navy include the mirror landing system and the angled flight deck.

Eric Mc

122,183 posts

266 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
This is what a PROPER naval aviator looks like -



A great picture of a Fleet Air Arm pilot and his F6F Hellcat during WW2

rhinochopig

17,932 posts

199 months

Thursday 17th November 2011
quotequote all
nono

DEFSTAN 00-198 Facial Hair Standards for Airy Fairy Personnel clearly states that the ONLY permissible facial topiary is the:

  • MKIIa winter / extreme weather moustache - for use in theatres below 7 degrees C or where wind speeds exceed 40kts;
  • the MKIIb lightweight desert / hot climate moustache;
  • and the MKIIc general purpose moustache.
Under no circumstances shall the MKIVa special forces beard be worn by any fleet air personnel, unless where required to do so for RN Concert Party duties.