Apache Crash in Afghanistan - "Return to target" maneuver

Apache Crash in Afghanistan - "Return to target" maneuver

Author
Discussion

Simpo Two

85,552 posts

266 months

Wednesday 21st March 2012
quotequote all
He almost got away with the 'landing' though...

Fat Albert

1,392 posts

182 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
This is a fairly standard maneuvre in a amilitary helicopter, you just need to be a little more precise about the entry & exit though!

the first time I experienced one of these was when a student Pilot mucked up a 'quick-stop' and the instructor took over, did a wing-over and then brought us in for a down-wind quick-stop.

At the time I was standing out on the step as it was my job to talk the pilot in from the 50' hover when the quick-stop completes....I was quite surprised to find myself effectively lying horizontal about 150' in the air with 6 tonne of Wessex pivoting above and around me!

The Down-wind Quick-stop was quite a cheeky maneuvre in a Wessex too, especially from the outside!

Puggit

48,481 posts

249 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Odie said:
Puggit said:
Trying to land a helicopter like a 'plane, what was he thinking?!
the return to target maneuver isnt trying to land, its like doing a J turn in a car
No kidding hehe

daz3210

5,000 posts

241 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fat Albert said:
At the time I was standing out on the step as it was my job to talk the pilot in from the 50' hover when the quick-stop completes....I was quite surprised to find myself effectively lying horizontal about 150' in the air with 6 tonne of Wessex pivoting above and around me!
Bet that resulted in a bum clenching moment for you then!

Oakey

27,593 posts

217 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Good to know they fly in real life like most of us do in BF3 hehe

mrmr96

13,736 posts

205 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
"Holy fk!". Indeed.

Fabric

3,819 posts

193 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
eek Bloody hell! Unbelievable nobody was hurt. Could failure to compensate for density altitude, given it's atop a cold mountain range, have played a factor in him being unable to recover his dive?

davepoth

29,395 posts

200 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fabric said:
eek Bloody hell! Unbelievable nobody was hurt. Could failure to compensate for density altitude, given it's atop a cold mountain range, have played a factor in him being unable to recover his dive?
Yes, but flying like a prat appears to be the main cause.

Fabric

3,819 posts

193 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Yes, but flying like a prat appears to be the main cause.
Very true. At least the troops got a memorable air show though!

y2blade

56,129 posts

216 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Oakey said:
Good to know they fly in real life like most of us do in BF3 hehe
rofl


y2blade

56,129 posts

216 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fat Albert said:
This is a fairly standard maneuvre in a amilitary helicopter, you just need to be a little more precise about the entry & exit though!

the first time I experienced one of these was when a student Pilot mucked up a 'quick-stop' and the instructor took over, did a wing-over and then brought us in for a down-wind quick-stop.

At the time I was standing out on the step as it was my job to talk the pilot in from the 50' hover when the quick-stop completes....I was quite surprised to find myself effectively lying horizontal about 150' in the air with 6 tonne of Wessex pivoting above and around me!

The Down-wind Quick-stop was quite a cheeky maneuvre in a Wessex too, especially from the outside!
bow

mrmr96

13,736 posts

205 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Yes, but flying like a prat appears to be the main cause.
rofl

Sonic

4,007 posts

208 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Jesus, quite how nobody died in that accident, both pilots and people on the ground, is pure luck.

LukeBird

17,170 posts

210 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Bloody hell! eek

Fat Albert

1,392 posts

182 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
daz3210 said:
Fat Albert said:
At the time I was standing out on the step as it was my job to talk the pilot in from the 50' hover when the quick-stop completes....I was quite surprised to find myself effectively lying horizontal about 150' in the air with 6 tonne of Wessex pivoting above and around me!
Bet that resulted in a bum clenching moment for you then!
My hand had to be prized from the grab-handle afterwards! (you can see them in the top corners of the door in the pic below)It scared the bejeezus out of me...but once I knew what was coming I loved it. Doing the Left-Hand ones was just as fun as you went over the top of the aircraft!

We would enter the maneuvre at 50' and 90 kts, the students were restricted to 45 degrees nose up and 45 degrees bank, the instructors were allowed to go to 60/60, which is the closest you can get to inverted in a flapping hinge heli.

I think in the apache's case they had a low entry height, didn't climb far emough and, as someone said, didn't take into account their thrust margin for a high denisty altitude



scubadude

2,618 posts

198 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
I like the way the cameraman and his buddy run AWAY from the accident- I can only hope they where going to get an ambulance/fire extinguisher although knowing a few grunts wouldn't be surprised if they where running to their laptop to upload to YouTube first! :-)

Amazing that he didn't flaten anyone on the ground, seemed to be alot of people milling about.

y2blade

56,129 posts

216 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fat Albert said:
daz3210 said:
Fat Albert said:
At the time I was standing out on the step as it was my job to talk the pilot in from the 50' hover when the quick-stop completes....I was quite surprised to find myself effectively lying horizontal about 150' in the air with 6 tonne of Wessex pivoting above and around me!
Bet that resulted in a bum clenching moment for you then!
My hand had to be prized from the grab-handle afterwards! (you can see them in the top corners of the door in the pic below)It scared the bejeezus out of me...but once I knew what was coming I loved it. Doing the Left-Hand ones was just as fun as you went over the top of the aircraft!

We would enter the maneuvre at 50' and 90 kts, the students were restricted to 45 degrees nose up and 45 degrees bank, the instructors were allowed to go to 60/60, which is the closest you can get to inverted in a flapping hinge heli.

I think in the apache's case they had a low entry height, didn't climb far emough and, as someone said, didn't take into account their thrust margin for a high denisty altitude

Bloooooodyhell...fantastic!!!! biggrin

Simpo Two

85,552 posts

266 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fat Albert said:
didn't take into account their thrust margin for a high denisty altitude
Surely low density, ie try 'up' and nothing happens?

PaulG40

2,381 posts

226 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Proper brown trouser moment! Neglected to consider his vertical speed on his VSI perhaps? Or probably a just a simple 'Oh F*&k' moment!

daz3210

5,000 posts

241 months

Thursday 22nd March 2012
quotequote all
Fat Albert said:
My hand had to be prized from the grab-handle afterwards! (you can see them in the top corners of the door in the pic below)It scared the bejeezus out of me...but once I knew what was coming I loved it. Doing the Left-Hand ones was just as fun as you went over the top of the aircraft!

We would enter the maneuvre at 50' and 90 kts, the students were restricted to 45 degrees nose up and 45 degrees bank, the instructors were allowed to go to 60/60, which is the closest you can get to inverted in a flapping hinge heli.

I think in the apache's case they had a low entry height, didn't climb far emough and, as someone said, didn't take into account their thrust margin for a high denisty altitude

What was the actual effect of teh turns then? Did the g forces throw you into or out of the aircraft?