Eating raw meat- Bad for you?

Author
Discussion

MentalSarcasm

Original Poster:

6,083 posts

212 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
I'm working on essay on the cult of Dionysus. There's a theory that part of the ritual involved eating raw meat, probably goat.

This ritual would probably have taken place once a year, possibly once every 2 years. I'm just wondering if eating raw meat would make one ill? Or would it be okay if it was only once a year or so and only a little bit was eaten?

mitzy1968

13,857 posts

198 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Any one had Goat Curry? In london ?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

250 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
what do you think hams are?

besides I love a blu steak

308mate

13,757 posts

223 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Not sure but one of my Aussie mates eats all his red meat "blue", which as far as I can see is pretty much raw.

Anyway, he doesnt seem to have any ill effects.

otolith

56,177 posts

205 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Have you never eaten raw beef? Tartare or carpaccio or even just a bit of steak or roast beef properly cooked?

evoesque

1,034 posts

207 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
I once had Steak Tartare for dinner the day before I was due to fly back from my trip abroad. It was ing rancid and yes, I was rough as hell for a few days after.

Edited by evoesque on Tuesday 12th February 16:41

Silent1

19,761 posts

236 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
what do you think hams are?

besides I love a blu steak
Cooked meat left to go cold.

MentalSarcasm

Original Poster:

6,083 posts

212 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
otolith said:
Have you never eaten raw beef? Tartare or carpaccio or even just a bit of steak or roast beef properly cooked?
I've eaten steak and roast beef when they're still a bit pink inside. Guess I never really thought of that as raw since it's A) warm and B) the outside is cooked.

Anyway, thanks for the replies boys and girls, no ill effects from eating raw goats it is!

Now how difficult would be for a few women to tear apart a live goat?

Mahatma Bag

27,427 posts

280 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Lions eat raw meat. It is bad for you if you are the meat.

HTH

Rod Rammage

2,557 posts

201 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
I used to eat it all the time when I was a kid.

And look at me now.

<Wipes drool from chin. Pushes eye back into socket>



<Hefts ENORMOUS penis around into more comfortable position>

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

218 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
The problem with raw meat is bacteria. Keep it in the right conditions and eat straight away (maybe not with white meats!!) and I'm not to worried. Leave it out for quite a while at room temperature and I'd be getting very worried.

I won't eat a steak if it's gone anywhere past very rare and haven't been ill from one yet.


SiH

1,824 posts

248 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
MentalSarcasm said:
I'm working on essay on the cult of Dionysus. There's a theory that part of the ritual involved eating raw meat, probably goat.

This ritual would probably have taken place once a year, possibly once every 2 years. I'm just wondering if eating raw meat would make one ill? Or would it be okay if it was only once a year or so and only a little bit was eaten?
What do you think prehistoric man had been doing for years and years! Didn't seem to do them much harm.

MentalSarcasm

Original Poster:

6,083 posts

212 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
SiH said:
MentalSarcasm said:
I'm working on essay on the cult of Dionysus. There's a theory that part of the ritual involved eating raw meat, probably goat.

This ritual would probably have taken place once a year, possibly once every 2 years. I'm just wondering if eating raw meat would make one ill? Or would it be okay if it was only once a year or so and only a little bit was eaten?
What do you think prehistoric man had been doing for years and years! Didn't seem to do them much harm.
Ah, but I'm wondering if digestion would have changed by then, Greeks didn't eat much meat, the meat they did get was cooked as it had been part of the sacrifice to the Gods.

Rocco Stigfredi

1,801 posts

211 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
my oh has been known to eat raw beef, with no obvious ill effects, but apparently she's done it since she was little... not as in massive steaks, but nickiing a lump as it's being prepared...

she is, however, mad as a box of frogs on nitrous oxide...

scorp

8,783 posts

230 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
They eat plenty of raw meats in Japan (as one example) the list of which includes chicken and horse aswell as sashimi, so presumably it isn't all that bad for you. Apparently you have to be real careful preparing it though.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

250 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Silent1 said:
sleep envy said:
what do you think hams are?

besides I love a blu steak
Cooked meat left to go cold.
not all of them

CY88

2,808 posts

231 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
Carpaccio cloud9

What's not to like?

davido140

9,614 posts

227 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
my understanding was..

Beef, not really a problem,

Pork, not great, but unlikely to make you ill

poultry, taking a bit of a risk here, filthy animals.

not sure where goat would fall,


MentalSarcasm

Original Poster:

6,083 posts

212 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Sadly I don't have time to buy a goat and then run around the department trying to find a few undergrads willing to rip it apart.

That said it may have been bigger than a goat, could have been a deer.

JohnSW20

886 posts

238 months

Tuesday 12th February 2008
quotequote all
When I worked as a chef, we would quite often slice up a bit of fillet steak and eat it raw, with no harm done. One chef would squeeze the meat out of a sausage and eat that raw; this was step too far for me. Always eat steak blue or very rare.

John