Cheddar - what's actually decent?

Cheddar - what's actually decent?

Author
Discussion

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,292 posts

214 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
I used to think this was orangey-yellow soap. Which to be fair, a lot of it is. the generic 'cheese' sold in bulk blocks in Asda through to Waitrose.

However in the last 18 months or so (with th ehelp of certian people on here, including Anna_S), I've rediscovered the joys of decent cheddar.

So, I've set about finding good ones. So far, the best ones I've found include:
1. Black Bomber
2. M&S Cornish Cruncher (seriously)

Any other readily avilable nominations? (FWIW - the stuff from the farm house 2 miles down the road might be great, but isn't readily avialable, unless you fancy posting to all of us)...

Akers

463 posts

236 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all

1. Black Bomber
2. M&S Cornish Cruncher (seriously)
3. Tickler - Nice and strong. Available at Tesco and other supermarkets

bazking69

8,620 posts

191 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Colliers. Readily available and a nice kick.

fastfreddy

8,577 posts

238 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Montgomery is one of my favourites.

If you can't get good cheese locally, I'd recommend this place for mail order:

http://www.thecheeseshed.com/


JRM

2,043 posts

233 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
A mate of mine makes cheese down in Somerset and I have to say that almost anything made from un-pasteurised milk is by far and away the best flavour.

With this new found knowledge I went into a lovely cheese shop in London a couple of years back and asked if he had anything un-pasteurised, to which he replied, they all were. getmecoat There was me thinking it was unusual!

bazking69

8,620 posts

191 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
JRM said:
A mate of mine makes cheese down in Somerset
I buy some Somerset made stuff from the local market now and then. Ruddy good stuff. He also does homemade pickles which are equally as good.

SirClarke

633 posts

177 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Keen's, Quickes or Montgomery's (as mentioned above) are all fantastic traditional cheddars and are available in some supermarkets I think, certainly found at any decent farm shop.

As far as more obvious supermarket cheeses go I tend to quite enjoy Seriously Strong Cheddar as it does genuinely have a bit of kick to it and is more mature than most other farmhouse supermarket types.

If you're in the South West the Cheddar Cheese company now makes all theirs in an authentic cloth-wrapped manner and the vintage/cave stuff is fantastic.

Nolar Dog

8,786 posts

196 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Get up to Westmorland Farm Shop at Tebay Services on the M6.

Some of the best cheeses are for sale there.

smile

JRM

2,043 posts

233 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
A mate of mine makes cheese down in Somerset and I have to say that almost anything made from un-pasteurised milk is by far and away the best flavour.

With this new found knowledge I went into a lovely cheese shop in London a couple of years back and asked if he had anything un-pasteurised, to which he replied, they all were. getmecoat There was me thinking it was unusual!

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,292 posts

214 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
For me, it largely revolves around texture. The ones I like are generally quite crumbly and have an almost crystaline structure to them, similar to really good fresh Parmesan.

Puggit

48,486 posts

249 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
I've been hung, drawn and quartered before for saying this on PH, but:

Canadian Cheddar rocks...

JRM

2,043 posts

233 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Is there an echo in this thread??

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,292 posts

214 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Is there an echo in this thread??

























hehe

ad551

1,502 posts

214 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Booth's own brand mature cheddar is the best I've tried. I think it's made by Dewlay in Lancashire, so it might be available in places that don't have Booths, just under a different name.

Justman

121 posts

183 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Godminster is a big favourite of mine although it is a smoother textured cheddar. Packs a punch mind!

Edited by Justman on Friday 19th February 12:14

Freddie328

685 posts

202 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Another vote for Tickler yum

escargot

17,110 posts

218 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
The best chedder i've ever tasted was a snowdonia chedder. Comes with a black wax surround.

As you mentioned above, crumbly and crystalline. It really does put that mass produced plastic pap to shame.

escargot

17,110 posts

218 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Also (and I know it's not a cheddar) a mate of mine bought me a lancashire black bomb for a cheese & wine night I did over Christmas. It was (to my taste) very cheddar-like and extremely, extremely lovely.

jimothy

5,151 posts

238 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
SirClarke said:
Quickes
Do a sheeps chedder, lovely stuff!

Nobaccymaccy

572 posts

203 months

Friday 19th February 2010
quotequote all
Puggit said:
I've been hung, drawn and quartered before for saying this on PH, but:

Canadian Cheddar rocks...
I agree on taste but not on texture