Bass drum going boing.

Bass drum going boing.

Author
Discussion

13m

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all

My youngest son has a drum kit and is complaining the bass drum doesn't sound right suddenly. It sounds more boingy, like a marching band sort of sound, than it did previously.

I know nothing whatsoever about drums, but does the above description mean anything to anyone sufficient to advise please?

If not, we need to buy some cymbals, I might chat up our local store and get them to deliver / fettle the bass at the same time.

HOGEPH

5,249 posts

186 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Stick a blanket or a pillow in it, if still going boing, get a new head.

GCH

3,991 posts

202 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Needs dampening.

Many different methods, but the traditional and by far the easiest method is simply to put a pillow/blanket inside - where you put it will affect the sound. Of course, if you have a hole in the front head it is easier than having to remove the front head in order to put it in wink

If it already has a blanket or pillow in, then perhaps it has moved. Tip it a few times to readjust it and it should hopefully get better.

13m

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
HOGEPH said:
Stick a blanket or a pillow in it, if still going boing, get a new head.
The head being the part the pedal hits presumably.


HOGEPH

5,249 posts

186 months

Saturday 18th March 2017
quotequote all
Correct, and depending on how serious a player your son is, it might be worth splashing out on a decent one, something like the Evans EMAD head which with a t-shirt inside the drum will give a lovely thump.

Dizeee

18,302 posts

206 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
Any updates to this?

What kit is it and what heads are on it either side?


13m

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
Dizeee said:
Any updates to this?

What kit is it and what heads are on it either side?
I am being a remiss father and it's not yet been looked at. He also has cymbals that go rattle.

Easter hols coming though.

Dizeee

18,302 posts

206 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
So what is the make and setup - cymbal names, head brands etc?

Muffling the bass drum should work - do you have a tuning key to remove the reso head?

Whay cymbals are they and have you made sure there is no metal to metal contact - the cymbal should sit on a plastic/rubber bit or felt washer, and then it should be supported beneath the washer by something similar.

These sound like easy fixes to make, but some more info or pics would go a long way!

GCH

3,991 posts

202 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
13m said:
He also has cymbals that go rattle.
Sizzle?

Dizeee said:
These sound like easy fixes to make, but some more info or pics would go a long way!
This

So

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all

Your help is appreciated chaps. I intend to fix the drum kit at some point in the next week. I will post up snaps if needs be.

I think we will be buying him new cymbals. His drum teacher said they were ropey when he first got them and he got a distinction in his first drumming exam, so we said we'd buy new ones as a reward.


Elysium

13,815 posts

187 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
So said:
Your help is appreciated chaps. I intend to fix the drum kit at some point in the next week. I will post up snaps if needs be.

I think we will be buying him new cymbals. His drum teacher said they were ropey when he first got them and he got a distinction in his first drumming exam, so we said we'd buy new ones as a reward.
My youngest took up the drums aged 10 and has actually got pretty good. As result I have had to learn some basics to help him out.

If you are replacing beginner cymbals look for bronze (b20 alloy) rather than brass(b8 alloy) otherwise he will be pestering you to change them again in a couple of years. Cymbals can be very (very) expensive so be warned!

The drum heads need to be tuned. It is a faff but not difficult and I taught myself and my son using an iphone app.

The loose sound you describe could be a worn head, lack of damping or he might have fiddled with the head and detuned it. The evans heads are pretty decent value and make a basic kit sound great.

As others have said, there are some simple fixes that can improve the sound for not much money:

1. Evans plastic rings to remove unwanted reverb or overtones

2. Felt and foam washers for cymbals

3. Moongel pads that you can position to achieve a similar effect to the rings on the bass drum.



Edited by Elysium on Tuesday 28th March 19:58

So

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
Elysium said:
So said:
Your help is appreciated chaps. I intend to fix the drum kit at some point in the next week. I will post up snaps if needs be.

I think we will be buying him new cymbals. His drum teacher said they were ropey when he first got them and he got a distinction in his first drumming exam, so we said we'd buy new ones as a reward.
My youngest took up the drums aged 10 and has actually got pretty good. As result I have had to learn some basics to help him out.

If you are replacing beginner cymbals look for bronze (b20 alloy) rather than brass(b8 alloy) otherwise he will be pestering you to change them again in a couple of years. Cymbals can be very (very) expensive so be warned!

The drum heads need to be tuned. It is a faff but not difficult and I taught myself and my son using an iphone app.

The loose sound you describe could be a worn head, lack of damping or he might have fiddled with the head and detuned it. The evans heads are pretty decent value and make a basic kit sound great.
His drum teacher has suggested these:

https://www.andertons.co.uk/p/P101BS314/cymbal-set...
[1]

https://www.andertons.co.uk/p/SABSBR5003G/cymbal-s...
[2]

https://www.andertons.co.uk/p/MCS/cymbal-sets/mien...
[3]

He will need an additional stand I suspect:

https://www.andertons.co.uk/p/4509/cymbal-stands/c...

Elysium

13,815 posts

187 months

Tuesday 28th March 2017
quotequote all
So said:
I got my son the Sabian SBR's which sound great. But at some point in the future is going to want to upgrade to b20's.

That would double the price compared the ones you linked to though.

The set you linked to has a free splash would would go down well I am sure.

So

Original Poster:

26,273 posts

222 months

Monday 3rd April 2017
quotequote all
Okay, so I took a good look at this over the weekend.The problem was in three parts;

1. The pedal had become detached.

2. There was nothing in the drum to stop it being boingy.

3. My son had, I think, been "tuning" it.

I have resolved points 1 & 2 and have loosened the tension both sides. I am not sure it sounds right, but it doesn't go boing anymore.

An aside - I was about to replace the entire kit at the weekend, but thought I would quiz the little chap about his plans drum-wise. His response was that he prefers piano and wants to focus on that. So we won't be getting new drums just yet.

Thanks for your advice chaps.

Dizeee

18,302 posts

206 months

Saturday 8th April 2017
quotequote all
Always buy second hand cymbals. There are loads available online and you will make good savings.