Under The Dome

Author
Discussion

rumple

11,671 posts

151 months

Wednesday 26th June 2013
quotequote all
Am I the only one who didn't like the book?

MissChief

7,101 posts

168 months

Thursday 27th June 2013
quotequote all
Not read the book.

Series has potential but everyone seems to be behaving in a very irrational and strangely calm way. There seems to be no rational thought about their situation.

Would hate to be the Actor playing the Sheriff.


Agent/TV Exec 'We want you to play a Sheriff in a town based on a Stephen king book, long running series we hope, if it gets enough viewers we're hoping for 3 seasons+'

Actor 'That sounds great, where do I sign?'

TV Exec 'Here and here. Oh, BTW you die at the end of Episode 1'

Actor, '...........st!'



goldblum

10,272 posts

167 months

Thursday 27th June 2013
quotequote all
rednotdead said:
Thinking back it was a bit wet, but then so was the ending of The Stand. One of my all time fav King novellas is The Langoliers but the film was a 'straight to video' piece of ste.
Conversely The Mist has a much better ending on film than in the book. The Long Walk and Mrs Todd's Shortcut would make interesting movies. I haven't really enjoyed any of Kings study-of-weird-things-happening-in-small-town-America. You can recognise characters introduced by King in the early eighties in his present stories.



rumple

11,671 posts

151 months

Thursday 27th June 2013
quotequote all
goldblum said:
rednotdead said:
Thinking back it was a bit wet, but then so was the ending of The Stand. One of my all time fav King novellas is The Langoliers but the film was a 'straight to video' piece of ste.
Conversely The Mist has a much better ending on film than in the book. The Long Walk and Mrs Todd's Shortcut would make interesting movies. I haven't really enjoyed any of Kings study-of-weird-things-happening-in-small-town-America. You can recognise characters introduced by King in the early eighties in his present stories.
Which books in particular don't you like? For me Under the Dome seemed to be a total King cliche from start to finish, he seemed to have put his typical King characters into a ridiculous story, in most of his books I don't mind but I just could not like anything about this one, I also didn't enjoy The Stand which s another popular King book, I just found both books really hard going, I have just ordered Joyland off Amazon though, high hopes for that one.

clonmult

10,529 posts

209 months

Thursday 27th June 2013
quotequote all
MissChief said:
Not read the book.

Series has potential but everyone seems to be behaving in a very irrational and strangely calm way. There seems to be no rational thought about their situation.

Would hate to be the Actor playing the Sheriff.


Agent/TV Exec 'We want you to play a Sheriff in a town based on a Stephen king book, long running series we hope, if it gets enough viewers we're hoping for 3 seasons+'

Actor 'That sounds great, where do I sign?'

TV Exec 'Here and here. Oh, BTW you die at the end of Episode 1'

Actor, '...........st!'

Despite that, the first episode looked pretty good. Wonder how close it'll keep to the book, just read the synopsis.

Pugster

428 posts

181 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
I'm currently reading the book at the moment and this turned up in my inbox today:

http://www.stephenking.com/promo/utd_on_tv/letter....

It's a short letter from SK going into the reasons for some of the changes so it's obviously causing controversy. He's been involved a lot in the series and it's interesting what he's got to say.

Nightmare

5,185 posts

284 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
Am a huge King fan and thought the Dome was good - but totally agree that the ending is weak. But then I thought the ending of IT was truly dreadful!
The problem with the Langoliers movie was that it was SO similar to the story - practically shot for, er, paragraph in some cases...somehow this meant it added nowt to the experience


goldblum

10,272 posts

167 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
rumple said:
Which books in particular don't you like?
Pretty much all the novels I tried, although two I quite enjoyed that were supposed to mirror each other were 'Desperation' and 'The Regulators'. I found you could pick up almost any book of his released since the 1980s and recognise similar plotlines and story devices..the good sheriff, the fat lady, the kindly old man etc etc... a bit tedious. I've liked all his short stories though and in particular those he wrote as Richard Bachmann.

ali_kat

31,988 posts

221 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
clonmult said:
Despite that, the first episode looked pretty good. Wonder how close it'll keep to the book, just read the synopsis.
Some of the names are the same, if that helps!

Take every key part of the plot (aside from The Dome) and remove it, because it might offend middle America and what you have left is the series.

Without spoilers..
The radio station is supposed to be religious, because this is a Bible Belt town.
The newspaper is meant to be The Democrat, run by a 40summat spinster that's lived there all her life
Barbie is a drifter that's been in town for a few month working as a cook in the diner
Oh, and the really big screw up - they can communicate through the Dome, not just hear though it, but still have cable TV, Internet & cell phone coverage

I've had a peruse of the IMDB boards - OMG Americans!!
"The sex scene made him look gay & her a slut cause she was on top"
"The pilot was too gruesome" FFS it's a Stephen King novel!!!

ali_kat

31,988 posts

221 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Exactly the same. I loved the book and it was one of my favourite of his until the ending.
However, for a while I had been wondering how on earth he could have ended it satisfactorily and even afterwards I have not been able to think of any kind of ending which would have been acceptable. Curious as to how they might do it.
yes finished it again today & felt the same level of frustration I felt originally, it's like he had it planned out, but then got bored so speed wrote it frown

Even with the major plot deviations already, I'm interested to see how they would finish it so will be watching with my brain turned off, might turnout to be a better plot although laugh

rasto

Original Poster:

2,188 posts

237 months

Friday 28th June 2013
quotequote all
Those reasons as to why the show is different give me hope that we will get a better ending than the book smile

DavesFlaps

679 posts

191 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
So, I got my Sky nevermiss email earlier this week and this starts on Monday.

Stephen King novels don't generally translate well to the screen, I hated the ending of this and previous comments allude to the fact the plot is missing some key threads, but I'll give it a few episodes regardless.

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

232 months

Friday 16th August 2013
quotequote all
DavesFlaps said:
So, I got my Sky nevermiss email earlier this week and this starts on Monday.

Stephen King novels don't generally translate well to the screen, I hated the ending of this and previous comments allude to the fact the plot is missing some key threads, but I'll give it a few episodes regardless.
His novels don't generally translate well?
I think some of our best ever films are Stephen King novels personally.
Shawshank, Green Mile, Stand by Me, The Shining, Misery- just to name a few off the top of my head

rasto

Original Poster:

2,188 posts

237 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
His novels don't generally translate well?
I think some of our best ever films are Stephen King novels personally.
Shawshank, Green Mile, Stand by Me, The Shining, Misery- just to name a few off the top of my head
Stand By Me is one of my all time favourite films, the last scene never fails to bring a lump to me throat. Apparently they are attempting to re-make IT (one of my favourite King books which I am currently re-reading), I enjoyed the original version and thought Tim Curry was excellent as Pennywise, hopefully they will throw enough money at the re-make to give us a worthwhile version.

MartG

20,666 posts

204 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
rasto said:
GTIR said:
I've already seen this years ago.
Didn't a bloke do a death wall type ride on a motorbike and throw a bomb through a hole at the top of the dome?

It then shattered.
This dome has no holes in it, they are completely cut off from the outside world.
Definite whoosh parrot visit there !

MissChief

7,101 posts

168 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
MartG said:
rasto said:
GTIR said:
I've already seen this years ago.
Didn't a bloke do a death wall type ride on a motorbike and throw a bomb through a hole at the top of the dome?

It then shattered.
This dome has no holes in it, they are completely cut off from the outside world.
Definite whoosh parrot visit there !
rofl

The Highway Man

6,004 posts

178 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
How many episodes are in the series, I've just "ahem" obtained the first 8 episodes, something for this evening as the telly is crap tonight. wink

IroningMan

10,154 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Just started listening to The Stand - the recent, extended re-release; something like 47 hours of audio, so I hope the ending isn't a complete flop...

Will move on to Under The Dome thereafter; there was an interesting piece on it in SFX magazine a couple of issues back, I think.

Bigends

5,414 posts

128 months

Saturday 17th August 2013
quotequote all
Terrific book - be interesting to see what theyve done with it on the telly

ESOG

1,705 posts

158 months

Sunday 18th August 2013
quotequote all
I've ben enjoying this series so far up to episode 6 I believe. Its good! I haven't read the book though I've been wanting to, I went into the series not knowing anything other than the obvious and I want to keep it this way, its exciting to watch something with fresh eyes.