Chris Evans to do Top Gear.who will join him

Chris Evans to do Top Gear.who will join him

Author
Discussion

loose cannon

6,030 posts

242 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Greecy Quentin Wilson eww I'd rather have my eyes injected with sulphuric acid
I met him once at my work, the most arrogant arse I have ever, he was promoting the s class and even my boss said he was the most stuck up arse he has ever had to deal with other than himself
He's a dinosaur from the brylcream era no chance IMO

otolith

56,179 posts

205 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
danjama said:
Roger Irrelevant said:
I'd like to see be

Guy Martin
David Mitchell
Steve Coogan.
After all this time, you've picked out the three people I would actually like to watch together. I think this would be a very interesting chemistry.
This David Mitchell?

Mitchell said:
As a non-driver, I spurn this illusion, and welcome the self-driving car. Its rise would retrospectively transform the indolence and nervousness that has prevented me from getting a driving licence into foresight. I must have intuited which way society was going – technologically, at any rate. I may have wasted hours learning grammar and punctuation rules now rendered as irrelevant as heraldry, but at least I didn't bother much with the highway code.
http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/01/google-driverless-cars-ukip-elections-david-mitchell

exitwound

1,090 posts

181 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
hondansx said:
Steve Coogan is a great shout... doubt he'd ever do it but he loves cars and is just a naturally funny guy, so is well suited.

Jason Plato appearing on TFI is surely a massive clue! No need to pay a Stig, either.

Jodie Kidd is awful, VBH would be much better from a banter point of view.
Why do we need "funny" and "banter"? It should be about the cars not the personalities, shouldn't it? Or does that not matter anymore?

Or is the format just about a bunch of losers parked on chairs trying to outtalk each other with their diminishing knowledge of what they drive and how it actually works? I want information, informative discussion from a serious car show. Knowledge that I will find useful, if I just want entertainment, I have lots to choose from.

Mermaid

21,492 posts

172 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Hol said:
Todays sky news story says..

The DJ has also confirmed that he will be joined by a female co-host on the show, sparking speculation former model Jodie Kidd is in the driving seat for the job.
.
3 blokes seemed to work fine, why this sexism?

zeDuffMan

4,056 posts

152 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
exitwound said:
QW = The best motoring correspondent/presenter ever!!


QW.. The Master bar none..
I want some of that crack you're on, must be strong stuff.

DonkeyApple

55,397 posts

170 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Megaflow said:
DonkeyApple said:
keebz91 said:
The BBC will ensure there is a female amongst them
Haven't they ticked the oppressed, minority box by hiring a Ginga?

I happen to like Evans but I guess he'll be dropping Radio2? Which would be a shame.

Plato is a good character. As is Martin and Glenister.

Very few women work in TV with cars. Martin Clunes' drag act is dull. The squealing bush pig from 5th Gear is well, a squealing bush pig.

I rate Perry as being on TV because she's actually good at her job. And her banter with the bike racers shows she has the skills for this kind of tv show.

All in though, it'll work better being just three blokes acting like immature dicks.
Sort of. But, he is still white hetro sexual male.

So the beeb will have to fit in ethnic minority, homosexual, female somewhere. And probably chuck in some disability as well to cover all the bases they are scared of.
Guy Martin has the twin disability of aspergers and chronic northernism. He's perfect.

And then chuck in Dianne Abbot for the other boxes.

Hooli

32,278 posts

201 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Who cares? with the ginger tt onboard I'll never be watching again.

otolith

56,179 posts

205 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
exitwound said:
Why do we need "funny" and "banter"? It should be about the cars not the personalities, shouldn't it? Or does that not matter anymore?
Depends - do you want to watch it on BBC2 on a Sunday evening, or on Discovery Shed late night Wednesday?

exitwound

1,090 posts

181 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
otolith said:
exitwound said:
Why do we need "funny" and "banter"? It should be about the cars not the personalities, shouldn't it? Or does that not matter anymore?
Depends - do you want to watch it on BBC2 on a Sunday evening, or on Discovery Shed late night Wednesday?
If its worth watching, I'll watch anytime, but I don't expect to be "amused" rather than informed..

lord trumpton

7,406 posts

127 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Chris Evans will help the show continue in the vein that viewers have been accustomed to of late - Childish, predictable humour cushioning a show that occasionally features and informative review.

It was st and will continue to be st.



Edited by lord trumpton on Wednesday 17th June 13:26

RG02GEE

20 posts

174 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
How about a motoring journalist? Chris Harris for instance? Would bring a bit of petrol-headed geekery to it and Evans can be the goof. BBC playing it safe it looks like.

SturdyHSV

10,098 posts

168 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Rowan Atkinson. Just to be the absolute antithesis of Chris Evans whilst still being a car man. Did he sell the F1 because it was a bit much to commute to Surrey in? hehe

chris7676

2,685 posts

221 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
It is likely to be rubbish, no better than the US Top Gear.

Why don't they invite And & Deck, the mediocres of the mediocres !

Top Gear was special mainly because of the characters, primarily Jeremy.

exitwound

1,090 posts

181 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Mark Knopfler..

I watched him race his AH3000 at Goodwood and he knows how it works too. Easy guy to chat to in the paddock. Nice relaxed style..

otolith

56,179 posts

205 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
exitwound said:
otolith said:
exitwound said:
Why do we need "funny" and "banter"? It should be about the cars not the personalities, shouldn't it? Or does that not matter anymore?
Depends - do you want to watch it on BBC2 on a Sunday evening, or on Discovery Shed late night Wednesday?
If its worth watching, I'll watch anytime, but I don't expect to be "amused" rather than informed..
Top Gear, and its prime time slot at the BBC, are not the place for what you want. What you want is a minority interest show, and there are lots of them on the minority interest channels. May as well ask for The Vicar of Dibley to give more coverage to serious discussion of theology.

exitwound

1,090 posts

181 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
otolith said:
exitwound said:
otolith said:
exitwound said:
Why do we need "funny" and "banter"? It should be about the cars not the personalities, shouldn't it? Or does that not matter anymore?
Depends - do you want to watch it on BBC2 on a Sunday evening, or on Discovery Shed late night Wednesday?
If its worth watching, I'll watch anytime, but I don't expect to be "amused" rather than informed..
Top Gear, and its prime time slot at the BBC, are not the place for what you want. What you want is a minority interest show, and there are lots of them on the minority interest channels. May as well ask for The Vicar of Dibley to give more coverage to serious discussion of theology.
Can't argue with that... I'm just ever hopeful. smile

LDM

372 posts

128 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
loose cannon said:
Greecy Quentin Wilson eww I'd rather have my eyes injected with sulphuric acid
I met him once at my work, the most arrogant arse I have ever, he was promoting the s class and even my boss said he was the most stuck up arse he has ever had to deal with other than himself
He's a dinosaur from the brylcream era no chance IMO
I doubt he would be in with a shout and to be honest I would rather see him continue on the "classic car Show" which has the makings of a decent prog. Strangely I have met Quentin Wilson and he came across as a decent guy, knew what he was talking about but not arrogant at all.


Andy665 said:
James Martin (the chef) would be a decent addition - he is a real petrolhead and a decent presenter
I hope not!
I always quite liked his progs as he came across as a normal type of person, although I thought he looked a complete plonker when he did the Mille Miglia or was it the Targa Florio? My wife met him once as he was with someone she knew and said he was completely arrogant and the way he spoke to or ignored some people (not her) was embarrassing - not that I guess it would / should affect the prog!

Chr1sch

2,585 posts

194 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Jason Plato is a good shout given that he left 5th Gear...


Craikeybaby

10,416 posts

226 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
As much as I'd like to see Guy Martin presenting it I doubt he would, his own stuff is more suited to his style and in his autobiography he mentions his dream job is being a lorry mechanic and not liking all the attention from being famous etc - Top Gear would only make that worse.

Does anyone know if Richard Porter will still be doing the script, or if he'll be going with Clarkson and the rest to Netflix/wherever they end up?

I think the best bet would have been for the BBC to rest Top Gear for a few years and come back with a new format, not just try to rehash it with a new team.

lord trumpton

7,406 posts

127 months

Wednesday 17th June 2015
quotequote all
Now the beeb have an expensive heavyweight at the helm I reckon the sidekick(s) will be some young upcoming characters prepared to work for a bag of pretzels