Welfare Card

Author
Discussion

PugwasHDJ80

7,529 posts

221 months

Thursday 20th December 2012
quotequote all
Spent 6 months on JSA between jobs.

Claiming was a piece of piss- couple of visits and a form and bobs your uncle I've got 60quid a week.

I had to set aside 15mins once per week to sign on.

They couldn't have been more helpful with claiming other benefits, they were throwing money m way and seemed very suspicious when I refused them.

Having said all that I hated it and got a job pretty quickly once id put my mind to it. Around 25% looked embarrassed to be there- the rest looked perfectly happy!

dudleybloke

19,837 posts

186 months

Thursday 20th December 2012
quotequote all
i think the thing we have to do it separate the unemployed folk who are actualy between jobs and those who wont work and want to live for free.

maybe a maximum time limit on any benefits.


thinfourth2

32,414 posts

204 months

Thursday 20th December 2012
quotequote all
Sticks. said:
thinfourth2 said:
Its also a fking terrible solution as the potential for abuse is massive. Once it is the norm for one sector of society to have their spending controlled by the government then it can easily be rolled out to others. And i for one really don't want some government tt saying i shouldn't be buying goose fat to stick on my roast potatoes.
Thisn is it for me. There is a sector of the UK which is multi-occupancy addresses, NFAs, unclear and multi-identities, and that's before you start on the trade, loss and theft of the cards, and the consequent resource needed to plug the leakage.

But if you think it's a good idea, why not start with Child Benefit? Govt could ensure that children don't eat non-state-approved foods and drinks, which would benefit their education, behaviour and improve their long term health and economic outcomes. There would therefore be savings all round, from youth crime, the obesity epidemic to a healthier old age. You could also use your vouchers for the single state-approved school uniform, so that children are properly dressed.

It's a bit commie for me, but once you've accepted the principle, what's to stop it?
I hear that some parents use the child benefit to put petrol in their car


This must be stopped

So i agree

The first benefit to get the welfare card MUST be child benefit

Just think of the children

SpeedMattersNot

4,506 posts

196 months

Thursday 20th December 2012
quotequote all
Some parents even use the child support money to buy fashionable clothing for their child. Totally uncalled for and cards should be implemented so that they can only buy them shoes at the local charity shops.

(actually, that's not a bad idea)

smegmore

3,091 posts

176 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
fk 'em.

Let them eat cake.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

204 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
SpeedMattersNot said:
Some parents even use the child support money to buy fashionable clothing for their child. Totally uncalled for and cards should be implemented so that they can only buy them shoes at the local charity shops.

(actually, that's not a bad idea)
And of course under no circumstances should this child benefit card be allowed to be used in upmarket shops like Waitrose.

It should only be used in shop which provide maximum value like Asda and Tescos




If we start off with child benefits i could actually warm to this idea of a benefits card

sugerbear

4,039 posts

158 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
thinfourth2 said:
SpeedMattersNot said:
Some parents even use the child support money to buy fashionable clothing for their child. Totally uncalled for and cards should be implemented so that they can only buy them shoes at the local charity shops.

(actually, that's not a bad idea)
And of course under no circumstances should this child benefit card be allowed to be used in upmarket shops like Waitrose.

It should only be used in shop which provide maximum value like Asda and Tescos

If we start off with child benefits i could actually warm to this idea of a benefits card
In a single post I have seen the light and completed a full 180 Dave Cameron. Yes, benefits card for child allowance is essential, I think we, as taxpayers ,should allow it to used in Iceland, Aldii and Netto only. There should also be a special "benefits" isle, clearly signed and the card itself should have "WELFARE" emblazoned on it so that everyone knows exactly what it is.

I have seen the light....

eccles

13,740 posts

222 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
PugwasHDJ80 said:
Spent 6 months on JSA between jobs.

Claiming was a piece of piss- couple of visits and a form and bobs your uncle I've got 60quid a week.

I had to set aside 15mins once per week to sign on.

They couldn't have been more helpful with claiming other benefits, they were throwing money m way and seemed very suspicious when I refused them.

Having said all that I hated it and got a job pretty quickly once id put my mind to it. Around 25% looked embarrassed to be there- the rest looked perfectly happy!
I spent a few weeks on JSA a few years ago. Like you I found signing on a very easy process, just a phone call an interview and a few forms. I got £57 a week and all I had to do was write down three thing a week to show I'd been looking for a job. This could have been as something as simple as looking at a website, a paper or in the job centre window.No proof was required that I'd actually been doing this though.
Unlike you though, I was not offered any other support or benefits and had to fund my own journeys to job interviews. I only found out about the perks once I was working again.
I was very easy to tell the 'normal' people signing on from the regulars with their taxis waiting outside for them.
The staff came across as uncaring and just wanted to tick the boxes. My 'advisor' seemed genuinely surprised that I'd applied for several jobs and had a couple of interviews lined up within the first couple of weeks. I ended up working again within 3 weeks.
Until you've had to step into one of these job centres and sign on, I don't really think you can understand the feeling involved. I've been in full time work since I was 16 apart from those 3 weeks, and hope I never have to sign on again.

sugerbear

4,039 posts

158 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
eccles said:
PugwasHDJ80 said:
Spent 6 months on JSA between jobs.

Claiming was a piece of piss- couple of visits and a form and bobs your uncle I've got 60quid a week.

I had to set aside 15mins once per week to sign on.

They couldn't have been more helpful with claiming other benefits, they were throwing money m way and seemed very suspicious when I refused them.

Having said all that I hated it and got a job pretty quickly once id put my mind to it. Around 25% looked embarrassed to be there- the rest looked perfectly happy!
I spent a few weeks on JSA a few years ago. Like you I found signing on a very easy process, just a phone call an interview and a few forms. I got £57 a week and all I had to do was write down three thing a week to show I'd been looking for a job. This could have been as something as simple as looking at a website, a paper or in the job centre window.No proof was required that I'd actually been doing this though.
Unlike you though, I was not offered any other support or benefits and had to fund my own journeys to job interviews. I only found out about the perks once I was working again.
I was very easy to tell the 'normal' people signing on from the regulars with their taxis waiting outside for them.
The staff came across as uncaring and just wanted to tick the boxes. My 'advisor' seemed genuinely surprised that I'd applied for several jobs and had a couple of interviews lined up within the first couple of weeks. I ended up working again within 3 weeks.
Until you've had to step into one of these job centres and sign on, I don't really think you can understand the feeling involved. I've been in full time work since I was 16 apart from those 3 weeks, and hope I never have to sign on again.
An excellent write up that accurately reflected my limited experience. I think at 3 months they have (or had) some kind of review to see where you are on your job hunt and they very kindly offered re-training, I opted for Prince 2 certification which always looks good on a CV. I rang them the following week as I hadn't heard anything. They told me that there wasn't any budget available.

So that was an absolute waste of a day and if i really was desperate I think I would have been suitably dejected to wonder why I was even bothering.

Job centres are very depressing places and as far as I could tell not greatly helpful unless you wanted a job washing dishes/cleaning toilets or working in a care home. I think the money would be better spent closing them down and trying something else. All they seem to do is monitor the unemployed.

ShampooEfficient

4,267 posts

211 months

Friday 21st December 2012
quotequote all
sugerbear said:
I think we, as taxpayers ,should allow it to used in Iceland, Aldii and Netto only. There should also be a special "benefits" isle, clearly signed and the card itself should have "WELFARE" emblazoned on it so that everyone knows exactly what it is.
Have you ever been in an Iceland? You don't need the "benefits" sign, the windows are adequate...