Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 5
Discussion
pcvdriver said:
eharding said:
eharding - needing to try harder..... you used a clip not from "On the buses", as shown by the actor that played Blakey wearing a "Security" cap, and not an Inspectors' one.... pcvdriver said:
There again, Scotland IS a country in its own right - The Sarf-East isn't...... even though they have more than enough people to fill one.......but perhaps too many to be crammed into such a postage stamp sized piece of real estate.
Scotland isn't a real country either. Its just a modern region that blurs the borders of the true kingdoms.http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heptarchy
alock said:
Scotland isn't a real country either. Its just a modern region that blurs the borders of the true kingdoms.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heptarchy
I think you'll find it is....http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heptarchy
the first King of Scots was Kenneth MacAlpin (Cináed mac Ailpín), who founded the state in 843.
The English lands were unified in the 10th century in a reconquest completed by King Athelstan in 927.
So not only is Scotland a country in it's own right, it became a state before England existed.
pcvdriver said:
I think you'll find it is....
the first King of Scots was Kenneth MacAlpin (Cináed mac Ailpín), who founded the state in 843.
The English lands were unified in the 10th century in a reconquest completed by King Athelstan in 927.
So not only is Scotland a country in it's own right, it became a state before England existed.
So is UK getting back Normandy or Israel the holy land or Poland the land which now resides in Ukraine or heck UK should take back USA we created the state first. the first King of Scots was Kenneth MacAlpin (Cináed mac Ailpín), who founded the state in 843.
The English lands were unified in the 10th century in a reconquest completed by King Athelstan in 927.
So not only is Scotland a country in it's own right, it became a state before England existed.
Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
Welshbeef said:
So is UK getting back Normandy or Israel the holy land or Poland the land which now resides in Ukraine or heck UK should take back USA we created the state first.
Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
If you're going to quote me...at least add the context too...Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
alock said:
Scotland isn't a real country either. Its just a modern region that blurs the borders of the true kingdoms.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heptarchy
So I simply corrected him, it wasn't intended to be a pissing contest....and whilst you are indeed correct that Scotland ceased to exist as a state in 1707, so did England, when both countries merged. Independence is simply a demerging of our Nation States.http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heptarchy
Welshbeef said:
So is UK getting back Normandy or Israel the holy land or Poland the land which now resides in Ukraine or heck UK should take back USA we created the state first.
Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
The trouble is many in Scotland remember all too well the good old days back in 1706 when everything was much better. So its understandable that they want to go back to the 18th century and turn their backs on this modern global economy we live and prosper in.Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
Welshbeef said:
pcvdriver said:
I think you'll find it is....
the first King of Scots was Kenneth MacAlpin (Cináed mac Ailpín), who founded the state in 843.
The English lands were unified in the 10th century in a reconquest completed by King Athelstan in 927.
So not only is Scotland a country in it's own right, it became a state before England existed.
So is UK getting back Normandy or Israel the holy land or Poland the land which now resides in Ukraine or heck UK should take back USA we created the state first. the first King of Scots was Kenneth MacAlpin (Cináed mac Ailpín), who founded the state in 843.
The English lands were unified in the 10th century in a reconquest completed by King Athelstan in 927.
So not only is Scotland a country in it's own right, it became a state before England existed.
Everything is history Scotland cease being a country which it joined the Act of union through free will.
Gecko1978 said:
My point was together we are stronger not perfect but stronger. Seperate there will always
Be a weaker partner (according to evening standard today londons gdp is greater than twice gdp of scotland and wales combined) and in the event of a yes vote negociations will favour the stronger party.
why do some find that hard to understand. Scotland are being sold a lie example "14th richest nation in the world" versus being the sixth (except the posters don't tell you curently we are 6th). Its really ok to be independant (sorry wiggly) all the best to scotland if they choose that, but please understand what you are loosing and make sure the so called
Gains are true.
I'm not against independenceBe a weaker partner (according to evening standard today londons gdp is greater than twice gdp of scotland and wales combined) and in the event of a yes vote negociations will favour the stronger party.
why do some find that hard to understand. Scotland are being sold a lie example "14th richest nation in the world" versus being the sixth (except the posters don't tell you curently we are 6th). Its really ok to be independant (sorry wiggly) all the best to scotland if they choose that, but please understand what you are loosing and make sure the so called
Gains are true.
I'm against their vision of independence
i'm against the constant lies and bullst coming from the yeSNP
Give me a deeply right wing, liberal non bullst version of Scotland and i'd happily vote yes
McWigglebum4th said:
I'm not against independence
I'm against their vision of independence
i'm against the constant lies and bullst coming from the yeSNP
Give me a deeply right wing, liberal non bullst version of Scotland and i'd happily vote yes
.....and by that I take it you mean a UKIP Utopian Scotland?.... But, for that to happen, first UKIP will need to pass the milestone of retaining one single deposit, just one, Then advancing from there. As yet, they have miserably failed to even get one deposit returned to them..... I'm against their vision of independence
i'm against the constant lies and bullst coming from the yeSNP
Give me a deeply right wing, liberal non bullst version of Scotland and i'd happily vote yes
OpulentBob said:
Watched Braveheart last night, and thought of this thread. The English really were sts.
Whats that got to do with present day English people? Also the film has little to do with historical reality , so really, what has it got to do with anything?PS: Couldn't tell if you're being sarcastic
pcvdriver said:
.....and by that I take it you mean a UKIP Utopian Scotland?.... But, for that to happen, first UKIP will need to pass the milestone of retaining one single deposit, just one, Then advancing from there. As yet, they have miserably failed to even get one deposit returned to them.....
If UKIP are so irrelevant, why do you keep posting about them? Gassing Station | News, Politics & Economics | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff