Families need more help with tackling childhood obesity?!

Families need more help with tackling childhood obesity?!

Author
Discussion

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

171 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
People today have no self-control or discipline or sense of personal responsibility for their actions - the very thought that the state can nanny people into good behaviour is only reinforcing that lack of personal acceptance.

It's not my fault my kid is fat, the government didn't ban Mars bars.

Burwood

18,709 posts

247 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
KTF said:
Issi said:
diet.
Diet is another term I hate as it suggests a short term change.

This is why the people who go to weight watchers, etc. lose weight whilst on the plan but put it back on again when they finish as they don't change (or don't realise) that they have to change their eating habits for good for it to be a long term thing.
precisely.

dudleybloke

19,852 posts

187 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
superkartracer said:
dudleybloke said:
You don't see many obese marathon runners.
Well i'm currently 15-20kg overweight and still pull a VO2 max of around 70 +
Fatties call it Snickers running these days anyway!

rxe

6,700 posts

104 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
walm said:
I am no Chris Froom but 80 miles in a day on a bike isn't for the faint-hearted.
People actually do "training" for the London-to-Brighton bike ride and that is only 58 miles.
That's the point. 40 years ago that sort of distance on a bike didn't require training, preparation and a 4 grand bike. Its the sort of thing a bunch of kids did at the weekend because they were all as fit as a butcher's dog. These days people think the London to Brighton is some superhuman achievement that requires sponsorship.

40 miles at 15 mph (which is a really, really easy speed to maintain on the flat) - 3 hours. 3 hours there, 6 hours swimming, 4 hours back - probably burned through 6000 calories. Which of course is why they were skinny.

walm

10,609 posts

203 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
rxe said:
walm said:
I am no Chris Froom but 80 miles in a day on a bike isn't for the faint-hearted.
People actually do "training" for the London-to-Brighton bike ride and that is only 58 miles.
That's the point. 40 years ago that sort of distance on a bike didn't require training, preparation and a 4 grand bike. Its the sort of thing a bunch of kids did at the weekend because they were all as fit as a butcher's dog. These days people think the London to Brighton is some superhuman achievement that requires sponsorship.

40 miles at 15 mph (which is a really, really easy speed to maintain on the flat) - 3 hours. 3 hours there, 6 hours swimming, 4 hours back - probably burned through 6000 calories. Which of course is why they were skinny.
I get that.
But I still think you are massively exaggerating.
I just don't believe ANYONE "thinks nothing" of 7 hours in the saddle.

Although perhaps it is just my fat ass that would really struggle!!

Digga

40,352 posts

284 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
witko999 said:
ATG said:
More will power? What the hell does that even mean? If I rustle round in the kitchen drawers, am I going to stumble across a box of will power tablets? What steps are you supposed to take to boost your will power? The simple effective solution is to just remove the temptation.

Inconvenience, expense and embarrassment are powerful tools when it comes to modifying behaviour. Appealing for stronger will power and better education just don't deliver change.
If I put a packet of biscuits next to you, and offered you a million pounds if you don't eat any of them, I suspect you'd find the willpower to resist.
It is about tapping into the inner 'adult' in you - the same one that knows you simply cannot spend all of your salary on the day it hits your bank account. There is little difference really. Taking any other attitude is an attempt to deflect responsibility rather than take ownership of it.

Sway

26,324 posts

195 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
walm said:
rxe said:
walm said:
I am no Chris Froom but 80 miles in a day on a bike isn't for the faint-hearted.
People actually do "training" for the London-to-Brighton bike ride and that is only 58 miles.
That's the point. 40 years ago that sort of distance on a bike didn't require training, preparation and a 4 grand bike. Its the sort of thing a bunch of kids did at the weekend because they were all as fit as a butcher's dog. These days people think the London to Brighton is some superhuman achievement that requires sponsorship.

40 miles at 15 mph (which is a really, really easy speed to maintain on the flat) - 3 hours. 3 hours there, 6 hours swimming, 4 hours back - probably burned through 6000 calories. Which of course is why they were skinny.
I get that.
But I still think you are massively exaggerating.
I just don't believe ANYONE "thinks nothing" of 7 hours in the saddle.

Although perhaps it is just my fat ass that would really struggle!!
A bit like an African kids walking/running ten miles to school everyday, prior to mass car ownership/peedogeddon/decent rural bus services, it really wasn't such a big deal.

I'm in my 30s,but grew up in a non car owning household (even though my old man was a mechanic) in West London. Secondary school was 12 miles away, and I was a rower = 2.5 hours cycling, full day of school including PE twice a week and 3 hours of rowing training a day. Didn't think anything of it, and would regularly do a hundred mile ride over the Downs a couple of times a week during the holidays...

Thankyou4calling

10,607 posts

174 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
As well as activity levels being a factor, portion sizes are now hugely different to those of 10,20,30 years ago.

A normal dinner nowadays is equivalent to what would have been "Christmas dinner sized"

Offer someone "A biscuit" normally the packet is opened and it's gone.

All you can eat buffets, back in the day if you went for a Chinese meal you'd have one or two duck pancakes(love em) now..........blimey, you put half a duck on your plate, six pancakes and that is just a starter!

I remember the Shredded wheat advert daring people to eat more than two! Put two in a bowl now and see how it looks.

Portion sizes are massive now.

ATG

20,616 posts

273 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
Digga said:
witko999 said:
ATG said:
More will power? What the hell does that even mean? If I rustle round in the kitchen drawers, am I going to stumble across a box of will power tablets? What steps are you supposed to take to boost your will power? The simple effective solution is to just remove the temptation.

Inconvenience, expense and embarrassment are powerful tools when it comes to modifying behaviour. Appealing for stronger will power and better education just don't deliver change.
If I put a packet of biscuits next to you, and offered you a million pounds if you don't eat any of them, I suspect you'd find the willpower to resist.
It is about tapping into the inner 'adult' in you - the same one that knows you simply cannot spend all of your salary on the day it hits your bank account. There is little difference really. Taking any other attitude is an attempt to deflect responsibility rather than take ownership of it.
Bribery doesn't increase will power. By offering a million quid, you're just overriding one desire with another.

I've never felt a visceral urge to blow my salary. That's not part of a human's physiological make up. In contrast, eating fat and sugar triggers some very deep-rooted mammalian responses. If you offer rats a pile of cheese cake, their response is remarkably similar to ours. They start sitting around, nibbling on it from time to time and become lazy and fat. You could give a rat a bank account and a salary, and I'm pretty confident its behaviour wouldn't change. You wouldn't see it getting itchy feet towards the end of the month. The difference between blowing your money and eating too many biscuits is not just a matter of perspective or an arbitrary attitude that people choose to adopt. The two are fundamentally different things.

walm

10,609 posts

203 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
ATG said:
I've never felt a visceral urge to blow my salary.
Well I'm sorry, but you clearly haven't been browsing the classifieds on here nearly enough.
I recommend a strict diet of the £100k Garage archive. wink

ATG

20,616 posts

273 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
walm said:
ATG said:
I've never felt a visceral urge to blow my salary.
Well I'm sorry, but you clearly haven't been browsing the classifieds on here nearly enough.
I recommend a strict diet of the £100k Garage archive. wink
Get thee behind me, Satan!

21TonyK

11,542 posts

210 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
Thankyou4calling said:
Portion sizes are massive now.
Putting aside the lack of activity and the calorific content of foods this is very much a problem in schools.

So much so that my staff have a picture of how every meal should look on the plate. Every day the picture on the servery changes to show them exactly what proportion of the plate should be vegetables, meat etc

Now when they get a comment of "is that all they get" from someone they can at least say "yes" and blame me!

Burwood

18,709 posts

247 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
anyone notice the myth that 2500 kcal is accepted as being ok for the average adult male. With exercise maybe but an office job and relatively sedentary, no way. It's closer to 1900.

Thankyou4calling

10,607 posts

174 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
Putting aside the lack of activity and the calorific content of foods this is very much a problem in schools.

So much so that my staff have a picture of how every meal should look on the plate. Every day the picture on the servery changes to show them exactly what proportion of the plate should be vegetables, meat etc

Now when they get a comment of "is that all they get" from someone they can at least say "yes" and blame me!
That's interesting.

Do you serve cornflake tart with pink custard? Used to love that as a kid.

superkartracer

8,959 posts

223 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
rxe said:
walm said:
I am no Chris Froom but 80 miles in a day on a bike isn't for the faint-hearted.
People actually do "training" for the London-to-Brighton bike ride and that is only 58 miles.
That's the point. 40 years ago that sort of distance on a bike didn't require training, preparation and a 4 grand bike. Its the sort of thing a bunch of kids did at the weekend because they were all as fit as a butcher's dog. These days people think the London to Brighton is some superhuman achievement that requires sponsorship.

40 miles at 15 mph (which is a really, really easy speed to maintain on the flat) - 3 hours. 3 hours there, 6 hours swimming, 4 hours back - probably burned through 6000 calories. Which of course is why they were skinny.
15 mph on the flat for 3 hours is not really really easy ( and where the hell do you find flat roads that run for 40 miles?! , thats total rubbish , thats a good speed for any cyclist on the flat let alone over 40 miles of real roads .

http://www.bike4cancer.org/london-to-brighton-bike...

^^ flat



Edited by superkartracer on Friday 19th August 18:36

JustinF

6,795 posts

204 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
15 mph on the flat is a piece of piss, it's sit up chatting touring pace.

superkartracer

8,959 posts

223 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
JustinF said:
15 mph on the flat is a piece of piss, it's sit up chatting touring pace.
Theres no such thing as lots of variables and where are these flat roads for 15 miles? , 15 mph average is a good speed and i reckon about 170-200 watts ballpark , way over what an untrained person could ever manage .

Edited by superkartracer on Friday 19th August 19:00

21TonyK

11,542 posts

210 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
Thankyou4calling said:
21TonyK said:
Putting aside the lack of activity and the calorific content of foods this is very much a problem in schools.

So much so that my staff have a picture of how every meal should look on the plate. Every day the picture on the servery changes to show them exactly what proportion of the plate should be vegetables, meat etc

Now when they get a comment of "is that all they get" from someone they can at least say "yes" and blame me!
That's interesting.

Do you serve cornflake tart with pink custard? Used to love that as a kid.
God I used o hate school meals! LOL

Not a sign of pink custard.



Tuna steak, gremolata, fresh herb gnocchi, ratatouille (or salad if they prefer).

Burwood

18,709 posts

247 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
are you serious-a school dinner/lunch? Wow, that's nice-10/10


Gandahar

9,600 posts

129 months

Friday 19th August 2016
quotequote all
Having a 14 year old daughter who is, lets put it mildly "hefty", let me be blunt.

It's all down to spending too much time sitting on your arse connected to the Matrix each day through phone, tablet or laptop. She never goes out on dog walks with the dog we bought for her. Always has some excuse at the last minute.

Funny enough since getting the dog and doing 2 hours dog walk per day in the North Kent Downs I have gone from 14 stone 10 to 12 stone 12.

Who would have thought the equation of calories in against calories used would be the solution to not being fat !

whistle

And of course we should be more strict on what she does. She should do the dog walks, but of course then I lose out not enjoying them as she grumbles along. So I fail by feeling happy she is not on there but on the PC.

frown