Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 8

Scottish Referendum / Independence - Vol 8

TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED
Author
Discussion

csd19

2,189 posts

117 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Silverbullet767 said:
jshell said:
Christ! Now they're putting up Av Speed Cameras on the A90 North of Dundee.

They are the epitome of control freakery, 1984 here we come.

Anyone voting for this pile of shyte needs their heids looked!
That's just asking for more fatal accidents, cruise control set and pay less attention to the roads, or even worse, speed watching without looking where you're going.

The amount of crossings on that stretch beggars belief. Sort that out if safety is a concern!

But I suppose saving lives doesn't take in fines.
I posted about this in the Scotland forum, but the whole road is to get cameras, one every 3-4 miles from Aberdeen to Dundee on both sides. Epic.

They'll need the fines to pay for any road improvements. I wouldn't say speeding is a particularly rife thing on that road though.

The crossings between Dundee and Perth which were dangerous were upgraded with flyovers etc, and that was a fair few years ago now - just need to get on and sort the next stretch. Although £2m for average speed scameras is a lot cheaper than actually fixing the road layout...

s2kjock

1,683 posts

147 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
csd19 said:
I posted about this in the Scotland forum, but the whole road is to get cameras, one every 3-4 miles from Aberdeen to Dundee on both sides. Epic.

They'll need the fines to pay for any road improvements. I wouldn't say speeding is a particularly rife thing on that road though.
Do these cameras actually "make" anywhere near enough money to pay for road improvements? - I'd be very surprised if they do. My experience of the A9 is that people stick to the limits, and I am not even sure penalties would cover the original outlay and ongoing running costs.

Other than a genuine desire to improve road safety (and I don't think we have had enough experience of the A9 yet to confirm if it works) what other incentive is there for the government? Can't see much other political capital in it, unless it is pressure from the Scottish Greens who the SNP are currently having to be pally with.

jshell

11,006 posts

205 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
wc98 said:
jshell said:
Christ! Now they're putting up Av Speed Cameras on the A90 North of Dundee.

They are the epitome of control freakery, 1984 here we come.

Anyone voting for this pile of shyte needs their heids looked!
the old coast road is a better run once past arbroath anyway,and it will be quicker once there are average speed cameras on the a90 wink
i am starting to take an unhealthy dislike to angus robertson .snotty nosed stuck up pretentious tt .where the hell did he get that accent ? the people that voted for him in moray need to take a long hard look at themselves. him and his cronies are managing to do what decades of being taken for granted by the labour party couldn't do to the people that voted for them,turn them toward the tories.

i have spoken to a few people that are seriously considering voting conservative or independent at the next local elections as they have had enough of the snp.will be interesting to see how the local elections pan out.
It's nicer, but for a commute would be a ball-ache. I was doing Edinburgh - Aberdeen every week and back. The only saving grace was the lack of cameras and the Gatsos are easy - through at 79 and no problems.

We NEED to get rid of this Govt that rely on the Watermelons to get their policies through. They are poison!

percymk4

384 posts

186 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
https://youtu.be/0iDczTCFXes?t=909

Mike Russell being asked straight up, "which currency would an independent Scotland have?".

Three guesses what the answer was.


Silverbullet767

10,701 posts

206 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
percymk4 said:
https://youtu.be/0iDczTCFXes?t=909

Mike Russell being asked straight up, "which currency would an independent Scotland have?".

Three guesses what the answer was.
Not watched it, was it .......................................? Ah but, yeah but no but.......

percymk4

384 posts

186 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Silverbullet767 said:
percymk4 said:
https://youtu.be/0iDczTCFXes?t=909

Mike Russell being asked straight up, "which currency would an independent Scotland have?".

Three guesses what the answer was.
Not watched it, was it .......................................? Ah but, yeah but no but.......
Add in a dash of PM bashing and you've got it biggrin

Lucas Ayde

3,557 posts

168 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Regardless of what you think about Scottish independence, it surely makes sense to WAIT until a few years have passed after Brexit and see how things go, rather than have a second referendum pre-Brexit.

Scotland can't 'remain' in the EU if it leaves the UK - the EU made that clear during the first referendum (just a few years ago) and under any circumstance would have to apply (and wait) for membership after they have left the UK. And they are unlikely to be able to manage to properly separate from the UK in the 2 years before the UK leaves the EU, even if there was an independence vote today.


It's just a piece of silly opportunism and is likely to backfire badly.

wobert

5,039 posts

222 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
percymk4 said:
Silverbullet767 said:
percymk4 said:
https://youtu.be/0iDczTCFXes?t=909

Mike Russell being asked straight up, "which currency would an independent Scotland have?".

Three guesses what the answer was.
Not watched it, was it .......................................? Ah but, yeah but no but.......
Add in a dash of PM bashing and you've got it biggrin
One point often repeated is the UK government is unable to provide answers regarding the terms of Brexit.

Do those who raise it, not realise that when entering negotiations you don't "show your hand" or give an indication of what your settlement point will be?

If anyone told Nicky No-Lips what the opening position is, it'd be around Europe faster than a dose of the trots....

Edited by wobert on Thursday 30th March 18:16

NoddyonNitrous

2,116 posts

232 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Lucas Ayde said:
It's just a piece of silly opportunism and is likely to backfire badly satisfactorily.
FTFY

csd19

2,189 posts

117 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
s2kjock said:
csd19 said:
I posted about this in the Scotland forum, but the whole road is to get cameras, one every 3-4 miles from Aberdeen to Dundee on both sides. Epic.

They'll need the fines to pay for any road improvements. I wouldn't say speeding is a particularly rife thing on that road though.
Do these cameras actually "make" anywhere near enough money to pay for road improvements? - I'd be very surprised if they do. My experience of the A9 is that people stick to the limits, and I am not even sure penalties would cover the original outlay and ongoing running costs.

Other than a genuine desire to improve road safety (and I don't think we have had enough experience of the A9 yet to confirm if it works) what other incentive is there for the government? Can't see much other political capital in it, unless it is pressure from the Scottish Greens who the SNP are currently having to be pally with.
The biggest issue I see with trying to get away with "the cameras are being introduced for safety" is that they do nothing to solve the issue of farm traffic having to cross a busy dual carriageway to tend to their fields, nor do they help people who have to join the A90 with about 6 feet of slip road to get up to speed.

Speeding really isn't the issue on the A90, it's the lack of investment given to redesigning junctions. But of course, once the Greens get cosy with the SNP we were always going to get fked over in some way or another under the cloud of bks.

anonymous-user

54 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Lucas Ayde said:
Regardless of what you think about Scottish independence, it surely makes sense to WAIT until a few years have passed after Brexit and see how things go, rather than have a second referendum pre-Brexit.

Scotland can't 'remain' in the EU if it leaves the UK - the EU made that clear during the first referendum (just a few years ago) and under any circumstance would have to apply (and wait) for membership after they have left the UK. And they are unlikely to be able to manage to properly separate from the UK in the 2 years before the UK leaves the EU, even if there was an independence vote today.


It's just a piece of silly opportunism and is likely to backfire badly.
Sense???? This is politics we're talking about!

pingu393

7,784 posts

205 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
csd19 said:
I posted about this in the Scotland forum, but the whole road is to get cameras, one every 3-4 miles from Aberdeen to Dundee on both sides. Epic.
Pull over just after a camera and wait 60 seconds wink.

Average speed = 70 mph - Epic smile

tim0409

4,404 posts

159 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
57 Chevy said:
dro said:
Murph7355 said:
tim0409 said:
dro said:
Has anyone else noticed that most "mouthy" indy supporters..like those gathered outside Holyrood yesterday appear to be like "rough council scheme" types, dressed in hoodies and striped jogging bottoms and very much lacking in eloquent speech?
If you look at the breakdown of the 2014 result and compare it against the Scottish Index of Multiple Deprivation (SIMD) they are remarkable similar.
You need to be careful with this reasoning. The key question is "so what?"

There are hundreds of reasons why Scottish Independence is a dumb idea for Scotland. There is no need to insinuate anything as above and doing so risks a backlash.
I am from the Roy Walker school of observation.... Say what you see.
The reason it becomes important, as discussed on this thread before, is that it is actually in the interest of the SNP to keep unemployment up and education down.
I campaigned (knocked on doors/street stalls etc. for Better Together) and spoke to a lot of people in 2014; I got a real sense that the further down the economic scale somebody was, the more likely they would support independence because they thought they didn't much to lose so the downside was limited (for them). The irony was/is that independence would very much impact on them (benefits/social care/health etc.), perhaps more so than any other socio-economic group.

Vipers

32,876 posts

228 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
Silverbullet767 said:
jshell said:
Christ! Now they're putting up Av Speed Cameras on the A90 North of Dundee.

They are the epitome of control freakery, 1984 here we come.

Anyone voting for this pile of shyte needs their heids looked!
That's just asking for more fatal accidents, cruise control set and pay less attention to the roads, or even worse, speed watching without looking where you're going.

The amount of crossings on that stretch beggars belief. Sort that out if safety is a concern!

But I suppose saving lives doesn't take in fines.
Have to disagree, use cc all the time, use that road loads, no problem, it doesn't stop me paying attention. Yes there are quite a few junctions, personally I would rather see average speed cameras than the middle aged boy racers who keep anchoring up when the see a fixed camera.

Then again some on that road are just bad drivers.

Hayek

8,969 posts

208 months

Thursday 30th March 2017
quotequote all
petition.parliament.co.uk said:
UK wide referendum to get rid of all devolved parliaments.

The entire population of the UK should have a referendum to abolish devolved parliaments (national assemblies). In 2004 according to the daily telegraph it cost £650 million a year to run. It causes division and friction. We should have a choice to go back to one inclusive parliament.

Ridgemont

6,564 posts

131 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
Hayek said:
petition.parliament.co.uk said:
UK wide referendum to get rid of all devolved parliaments.

The entire population of the UK should have a referendum to abolish devolved parliaments (national assemblies). In 2004 according to the daily telegraph it cost £650 million a year to run. It causes division and friction. We should have a choice to go back to one inclusive parliament.
How jolly. How stupid. Pandora's box has been opened. You can't stuff the plagues back in.

The only way the devolved parliaments/assemblies will work with the UK is if the secessionist urge is clipped. Otherwise we'll stumble from one constitutional challenge to another. Sooner or later the U.K. will have to embrace federalism.

MikeT66

2,680 posts

124 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
Sturgeon signs independence vote request:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-39449459


FN2TypeR

7,091 posts

93 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
Ridgemont said:
How jolly. How stupid. Pandora's box has been opened. You can't stuff the plagues back in.

The only way the devolved parliaments/assemblies will work with the UK is if the secessionist urge is clipped. Otherwise we'll stumble from one constitutional challenge to another. Sooner or later the U.K. will have to embrace federalism.
yes

DrDeAtH

3,587 posts

232 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
MikeT66 said:
Sturgeon signs independence vote request:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-39449459
Shame it wasn't her resignation....

Strocky

2,642 posts

113 months

Friday 31st March 2017
quotequote all
percymk4 said:
https://youtu.be/0iDczTCFXes?t=909

Mike Russell being asked straight up, "which currency would an independent Scotland have?".

Three guesses what the answer was.
Has the section 30 order been accepted already?

Splendid, let the campaigning commence, should be a cakewalk this time for Indy, what with all the tired snowflake anti democratic unionists, probably won't get out of bed on ballot day, the poor dears
TOPIC CLOSED
TOPIC CLOSED