Plane craziness on Radio 4 this morning.

Plane craziness on Radio 4 this morning.

Author
Discussion

joe_90

Original Poster:

4,206 posts

232 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
They were discussing airport security this morning, after the head of BA was commenting that the current checks were over the top, and not needed, but basically we were just bowing down the the Americans again. LINK

Honestly I could not believe that someone (a Lord) used the Simpsons tiger/rock defence. Mind blown..

I might email the guy saying I have a rock, and I have not been attacked by Terrorists, do they want to buy it?

All the Terrorists need to do to inflict maximum terror, is just even attempt about 20 silly ways of getting bombs etc onto planes.. in pants, inside babies clothes, in a hat rim, woven into clothes etc.. Then all babies, pants and hats and clothes would be banned or subject to more searches.

I think they have won..


nelly1

5,630 posts

232 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
joe_90 said:
They were discussing airport security this morning, after the head of BA was commenting that the current checks were over the top, and not needed, but basically we were just bowing down the the Americans again. LINK

Honestly I could not believe that someone (a Lord) used the Simpsons tiger/rock defence. Mind blown..

I might email the guy saying I have a rock, and I have not been attacked by Terrorists, do they want to buy it?

All the Terrorists need to do to inflict maximum terror, is just even attempt about 20 silly ways of getting bombs etc onto planes.. in pants, inside babies clothes, in a hat rim, woven into clothes etc.. Then all babies, pants and hats and clothes would be banned or subject to more searches.

I think they have won..
A lot of people said:
"I want to buy your rock..."

thegman

1,928 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Could I carry the rock through in my hand luggage?

joe_90

Original Poster:

4,206 posts

232 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
thegman said:
Could I carry the rock through in my hand luggage?
it would need to be scanned.

joe_90

Original Poster:

4,206 posts

232 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all

A lot of people said:
"I want to buy your rock..."
I will just speak to Halliburton on how best to sell it, they are experts at selling 'tiger repelant rocks'

thegman

1,928 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
joe_90 said:
thegman said:
Could I carry the rock through in my hand luggage?
it would need to be scanned.
Do I need to put it a little plastic bag?

5potTurbo

12,551 posts

169 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
thegman said:
joe_90 said:
thegman said:
Could I carry the rock through in my hand luggage?
it would need to be scanned.
Do I need to put it a little plastic bag?
No, only liquids in the bags, max. 100ml per container.
Since liquid rock is essentially lava, that'd be tricky. nerd


I think some security checks needs to be relaxed. London City airport's a fking nightmare in the evenings now.

thinfourth2

32,414 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
I'd far rather have ten times the risk of getting blown up then have to go through all the security crap



Zod

35,295 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
They are not even consistent in their implementation of these checks between different terminals at the same airport. I've even sen at T5 some lines being made to remove shoes and others not.

T5 drives me mad. It should be so quick to get through with no check-in, bur they delight in slowing you down at security, particularly in the "Fast Track" lanes it seems (where they love to get a queue of businessmen waiting to have their bags manually searched), with the result that, even when you arrive well over an hour before your flight, you have no time to go to the Lounge. It must be eating into the revenues of the retailers.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

206 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
As an eloquent lady pointed out on 5L this morning - thank goodness there wasn't a bra-bomber. Think of the chaos.

Pothole

34,367 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
bra bombers = chaos at the security recruitment companies more than the airport...

'they' have won, helped by our sensationalist media and stupid politicians

You can take rocks in hand luggage...and paper...but not scissors.

bob1179

14,107 posts

210 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
As Pothole has said, the 'terrorists' have won. You can't drive up to the airport, you have to be held up for hours at screening it is a bloody nightmare. As someone who flies on a regular basis, it is nothing short of a massive inconvinience and makes a pain in the arse journey even more miserable.

If we must have this sort of security, we could do well to take a leaf out of the Israeli book. They aim to get you through check in, security, immigration and into the departure lounge bar within thirty minutes.
A great example is Heathrow T5 or Manchester T2. When it is busy, the throngs queuing to get through screening is huge, hundreds of people packed into a small space getting frustrated, hot and annoyed. It is also a perfect place to set off a nice little bomb that would cause chaos and panic throughout the airline industry. These sorts of bottle necks are not permitted at Ben Gurion Airport or anywhere else. A simple and efficient security system would eliminate this.

We need to profile and pick people that fit that profile. Not letting a seventy year old OAP take his bottle of brandy through security because 'it is a security risk', or having to carry all your liquids in a plastic bag, which if you don't have you must be a threat to airline security is ridiculous.

Obviously all of this would require a modicum of common sense, which neither the UK and especially the US lack.


Zod

35,295 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
bob1179 said:
As Pothole has said, the 'terrorists' have won. You can't drive up to the airport, you have to be held up for hours at screening it is a bloody nightmare. As someone who flies on a regular basis, it is nothing short of a massive inconvinience and makes a pain in the arse journey even more miserable.

If we must have this sort of security, we could do well to take a leaf out of the Israeli book. They aim to get you through check in, security, immigration and into the departure lounge bar within thirty minutes.
A great example is Heathrow T5 or Manchester T2. When it is busy, the throngs queuing to get through screening is huge, hundreds of people packed into a small space getting frustrated, hot and annoyed. It is also a perfect place to set off a nice little bomb that would cause chaos and panic throughout the airline industry. These sorts of bottle necks are not permitted at Ben Gurion Airport or anywhere else. A simple and efficient security system would eliminate this.

We need to profile and pick people that fit that profile. Not letting a seventy year old OAP take his bottle of brandy through security because 'it is a security risk', or having to carry all your liquids in a plastic bag, which if you don't have you must be a threat to airline security is ridiculous.

Obviously all of this would require a modicum of common sense, which neither the UK and especially the US lack.
prticularly when you can stock up on glass bottles, nail scissors, razor blades and all manner of other potential weapons in Duty Free (assuming you arrive hours early in order to have time to shop).

Pothole

34,367 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Thing is, it's not EU wide at all. In Malta I could turn up 30 minutes before my flight time (having checked in online and only carrying hand luggage) go through security in minutes (they do ask you to remove laptops from bags but not much else, never been asked to remove shoes e.g.) and have a quick nose in the shops before catching the flight...best thing about it was that I could leave my flat about 20 minutes before that and be in the pub less than half an hour after landing on the return leg.


F i F

44,144 posts

252 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Pothole said:
You can take rocks in hand luggage...and paper...but not scissors.
what are the rules on lizards and Spock?

mrmr96

13,736 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Zod said:
bob1179 said:
As Pothole has said, the 'terrorists' have won. You can't drive up to the airport, you have to be held up for hours at screening it is a bloody nightmare. As someone who flies on a regular basis, it is nothing short of a massive inconvinience and makes a pain in the arse journey even more miserable.

If we must have this sort of security, we could do well to take a leaf out of the Israeli book. They aim to get you through check in, security, immigration and into the departure lounge bar within thirty minutes.
A great example is Heathrow T5 or Manchester T2. When it is busy, the throngs queuing to get through screening is huge, hundreds of people packed into a small space getting frustrated, hot and annoyed. It is also a perfect place to set off a nice little bomb that would cause chaos and panic throughout the airline industry. These sorts of bottle necks are not permitted at Ben Gurion Airport or anywhere else. A simple and efficient security system would eliminate this.

We need to profile and pick people that fit that profile. Not letting a seventy year old OAP take his bottle of brandy through security because 'it is a security risk', or having to carry all your liquids in a plastic bag, which if you don't have you must be a threat to airline security is ridiculous.

Obviously all of this would require a modicum of common sense, which neither the UK and especially the US lack.
prticularly when you can stock up on glass bottles, nail scissors, razor blades and all manner of other potential weapons in Duty Free (assuming you arrive hours early in order to have time to shop).
They don't sell razor blades in duty free. You can get metal cutlery in some airside restaurants but it's all carefully designed to be hard to use as a weapon. (i.e. knives have a rounded blade and rounded tip) You can obviously get glass bottle though, but they are unlikely to bring down a plane.

Zod

35,295 posts

259 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
Zod said:
bob1179 said:
As Pothole has said, the 'terrorists' have won. You can't drive up to the airport, you have to be held up for hours at screening it is a bloody nightmare. As someone who flies on a regular basis, it is nothing short of a massive inconvinience and makes a pain in the arse journey even more miserable.

If we must have this sort of security, we could do well to take a leaf out of the Israeli book. They aim to get you through check in, security, immigration and into the departure lounge bar within thirty minutes.
A great example is Heathrow T5 or Manchester T2. When it is busy, the throngs queuing to get through screening is huge, hundreds of people packed into a small space getting frustrated, hot and annoyed. It is also a perfect place to set off a nice little bomb that would cause chaos and panic throughout the airline industry. These sorts of bottle necks are not permitted at Ben Gurion Airport or anywhere else. A simple and efficient security system would eliminate this.

We need to profile and pick people that fit that profile. Not letting a seventy year old OAP take his bottle of brandy through security because 'it is a security risk', or having to carry all your liquids in a plastic bag, which if you don't have you must be a threat to airline security is ridiculous.

Obviously all of this would require a modicum of common sense, which neither the UK and especially the US lack.
prticularly when you can stock up on glass bottles, nail scissors, razor blades and all manner of other potential weapons in Duty Free (assuming you arrive hours early in order to have time to shop).
They don't sell razor blades in duty free. You can get metal cutlery in some airside restaurants but it's all carefully designed to be hard to use as a weapon. (i.e. knives have a rounded blade and rounded tip) You can obviously get glass bottle though, but they are unlikely to bring down a plane.
You can get Fusion/Mach II type blade cartridges. Glass bottles can be smashed and used as weapons. Box cutters were the only weapons used on 9/11. They can't get into the cabin now becasue it is locked, but what if they threaten to kill crew/passengers? These days, with knowledge of 9/11, they would probably be mobbed by the passengers, but deaths could still result.

Pothole

34,367 posts

283 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
F i F said:
Pothole said:
You can take rocks in hand luggage...and paper...but not scissors.
what are the rules on lizards and Spock?
no lizards...taking Spock would be illogical, surely...? Captain.

mrmr96

13,736 posts

205 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Zod said:
mrmr96 said:
Zod said:
bob1179 said:
As Pothole has said, the 'terrorists' have won. You can't drive up to the airport, you have to be held up for hours at screening it is a bloody nightmare. As someone who flies on a regular basis, it is nothing short of a massive inconvinience and makes a pain in the arse journey even more miserable.

If we must have this sort of security, we could do well to take a leaf out of the Israeli book. They aim to get you through check in, security, immigration and into the departure lounge bar within thirty minutes.
A great example is Heathrow T5 or Manchester T2. When it is busy, the throngs queuing to get through screening is huge, hundreds of people packed into a small space getting frustrated, hot and annoyed. It is also a perfect place to set off a nice little bomb that would cause chaos and panic throughout the airline industry. These sorts of bottle necks are not permitted at Ben Gurion Airport or anywhere else. A simple and efficient security system would eliminate this.

We need to profile and pick people that fit that profile. Not letting a seventy year old OAP take his bottle of brandy through security because 'it is a security risk', or having to carry all your liquids in a plastic bag, which if you don't have you must be a threat to airline security is ridiculous.

Obviously all of this would require a modicum of common sense, which neither the UK and especially the US lack.
prticularly when you can stock up on glass bottles, nail scissors, razor blades and all manner of other potential weapons in Duty Free (assuming you arrive hours early in order to have time to shop).
They don't sell razor blades in duty free. You can get metal cutlery in some airside restaurants but it's all carefully designed to be hard to use as a weapon. (i.e. knives have a rounded blade and rounded tip) You can obviously get glass bottle though, but they are unlikely to bring down a plane.
You can get Fusion/Mach II type blade cartridges. Glass bottles can be smashed and used as weapons. Box cutters were the only weapons used on 9/11. They can't get into the cabin now becasue it is locked, but what if they threaten to kill crew/passengers? These days, with knowledge of 9/11, they would probably be mobbed by the passengers, but deaths could still result.
I know they have a Boots in Gatwick and Heathrow on the airside, and I saw plenty of fluids/bottles for sale including glass. But I don't recall seeing Razors. Are you 100% sure they sell them?

s1962a

5,351 posts

163 months

Wednesday 27th October 2010
quotequote all
Recall hearing on the radio this morning that the US don't have these kind of checks for their domestic flights (i.e. removing shoes). If they don't deem it necessary for them, why do we have to go through it?