On £25k but 'poor'?! Misery thread...

On £25k but 'poor'?! Misery thread...

Author
Discussion

simonej

3,894 posts

181 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
okgo said:
What, you can live in a nice part of Liverpool (oxymorons aside) for under £100k?

What is a good job paying in those cities? £50-60k I guess?
You can buy a perfectly nice house in a perfectly nice West Yorkshire village for £100k. One that's also within easy commuting distance of Leeds. And a job paying 50-60k is a well paid job wherever you are in the country.

crazy about cars

4,454 posts

170 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
simonej said:
And a job paying 50-60k is a well paid job wherever you are in the country.
Not really... in the City 50-60k is mediocre. 100k+ is well paid and anything above 200k is good.

STURBO

322 posts

161 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
simonej said:
You can buy a perfectly nice house in a perfectly nice West Yorkshire village for £100k. One that's also within easy commuting distance of Leeds. And a job paying 50-60k is a well paid job wherever you are in the country.
Really? Care to share where. I've been in W Yorkshire a while and can't quite agree with that.

simonej

3,894 posts

181 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
crazy about cars said:
Not really... in the City 50-60k is mediocre. 100k+ is well paid and anything above 200k is good.
Yes, you're right, London is a special case and 50k seems to go nowhere. Around the rest of the country 50k is still very good, though. I'm not saying it affords you an amazing house and lavish lifestyle, but it's still good going.


STURBO said:
Really? Care to share where. I've been in W Yorkshire a while and can't quite agree with that.
I suppose it depends on your standards and what you're used to, but £100k gets a perfectly nice terraced house somewhere like Denby Dale and lots of the small villages around there. Admittedly it might be a bit small for a family but they're nice enough areas and the houses in question are certainly not under a motorway bridge or next to a railway and definitely not 'unpleasant' - that was the case I was trying to argue.


Edited by simonej on Tuesday 11th February 21:07

STURBO

322 posts

161 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
simonej said:
I suppose it depends on your standards and what you're used to, but £100k gets a perfectly nice terraced house somewhere like Denby Dale and lots of the small villages around there. Admittedly it might be a bit small for a family but they're nice enough areas and the houses in question are certainly not under a motorway bridge or next to a railway and definitely not 'unpleasant' - that was the case I was trying to argue.


Edited by simonej on Tuesday 11th February 21:07
Fair enough I don't know that area. I think North of Leeds it's a bit more like nearer £150-200k. £100k only just gets a small flat in Otley.

okgo

38,062 posts

199 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
So it looks like I was kind of right, those places near the good jobs (for up north) are not £100k at all. And indeed the places that are 100k are not close to any good jobs, or are awful!

simonej

3,894 posts

181 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
okgo said:
So it looks like I was kind of right, those places near the good jobs (for up north) are not £100k at all. And indeed the places that are 100k are not close to any good jobs, or are awful!
Eh? Ive just said that a nice enough house can be bought for £100k near to the good jobs (i.e. Leeds). Certainly within 30 minutes commute. How is that hard to believe?

NerveAgent

3,321 posts

221 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
okgo said:
So it looks like I was kind of right, those places near the good jobs (for up north) are not £100k at all. And indeed the places that are 100k are not close to any good jobs, or are awful!
Yeh but do you know how far you can get in a 45 minute commute "up north"? You could probably even pick which city from some locations...

NerveAgent

3,321 posts

221 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
In fact 100k will just about get you a house in some of the Stockport surrounds which are generally niceish areas and 15 minutes train from Manchester city centre smile


SystemParanoia

14,343 posts

199 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
NerveAgent said:
okgo said:
So it looks like I was kind of right, those places near the good jobs (for up north) are not £100k at all. And indeed the places that are 100k are not close to any good jobs, or are awful!
Yeh but do you know how far you can get in a 45 minute commute "up north"? You could probably even pick which city from some locations...
My commute is 45-50 mins, and i do about 35 miles each way.. this is in the midlands which is full of dawdlers.

i presume you can cover vastly more distance than that up north

bogie

16,387 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
NerveAgent said:
okgo said:
So it looks like I was kind of right, those places near the good jobs (for up north) are not £100k at all. And indeed the places that are 100k are not close to any good jobs, or are awful!
Yeh but do you know how far you can get in a 45 minute commute "up north"? You could probably even pick which city from some locations...
exactly, I live just about in the middle geographically and can commute to any English Northern city in under 2 hours, most under 1 1/2 hours. Even London in 1.40 on train ....if you like driving and someone else is paying the fuel ( you are on expenses) you can be based where you like.....in a nice picturesque village where 2 bed houses are sub £100k .....

Ive always had long commutes, but chosen to live somewhere I can have a nice pad, thats not so crowded....of course if you want to live 10 mins from work and your office is in a city, you dont have a lot of choice......

fido

16,799 posts

256 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
bogie said:
Even London in 1.40 on train ....if you like driving and someone else is paying the fuel ( you are on expenses)
It is possible - that is not in doubt, but then you're spending £500+ a month on fares, fuel and maintenance .. thus the argument is full-circle .. cheap places are cheap for a reason. Of course if you can put with the expense, potential lack of reliability (weather or transport related) and losing 4 hours of every working day then it's for you. I suspect unless you're on a whopping salary then this will not be an attractive proposition.

bogie

16,387 posts

273 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
fido said:
bogie said:
Even London in 1.40 on train ....if you like driving and someone else is paying the fuel ( you are on expenses)
It is possible - that is not in doubt, but then you're spending £500+ a month on fares, fuel and maintenance .. thus the argument is full-circle .. cheap places are cheap for a reason. Of course if you can put with the expense, potential lack of reliability (weather or transport related) and losing 4 hours of every working day then it's for you. I suspect unless you're on a whopping salary then this will not be an attractive proposition.
of course, everyone's circumstances is different. These days I work from home and travel to customers, so all travel is a business expense.. hence no requirement for me to live in an expensive area of the country any more. I left the SE of England many years ago

on the other hand, in the 90s I moved house 6 times (rented places) all within 50 miles of London to be more suitable for my job at the time...sometimes living in rented rooms for years at a time...it was a means to an end

...youve got to be really fortunate to be able to buy your own home, where you CHOOSE to live within years of leaving the education system...thats just not reality for most people....took me until my mid thirties to make that choice

kiethton

13,896 posts

181 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
What people on here seem to be missing is that even close to London it is possible to buy a place of your own on the thread title salary.

Admittedly I earn a couple of £k more but I've just managed to buy my own place in SE London/Kent boarder through shared ownership - £340pm mortgage and just under the same again in rent/service charge for 50% of a 2 bed flat with parking etc, leaving £900pm for bills/living/holidays smile - just me which helps (and I like the reduced section!) - worst case I'll take in an un-official friend lodger....

From where I will be I can cycle to the city in 50 mins, take a train to the west end in 20 mins etc.

Shows that even in London it can be done, it's all about managing your living costs, although thus is harder with a family admittedly.

My first few months (or until I get a new job will be hard) - I've got a budget which I plan to stick to but the plan for anybody in their early 20's like I am has to be to stretch yourself when you first start (in the sense of few luxuries) in the knowledge that as you move on career rise you will do very nicely - new jobs I'm currently interviewing for would alleviate this problem and give me an extra £800pm disposable...it can be done and I fully intend to keep the 540i!

All that jazz

7,632 posts

147 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
kiethton said:
What people on here seem to be missing is that even close to London it is possible to buy a place of your own on the thread title salary.

Admittedly I earn a couple of £k more but I've just managed to buy my own place in SE London/Kent boarder through shared ownership - £340pm mortgage and just under the same again in rent/service charge for 50% of a 2 bed flat with parking etc, leaving £900pm for bills/living/holidays smile - just me which helps (and I like the reduced section!) - worst case I'll take in an un-official friend lodger....

From where I will be I can cycle to the city in 50 mins, take a train to the west end in 20 mins etc.

Shows that even in London it can be done, it's all about managing your living costs, although thus is harder with a family admittedly.

My first few months (or until I get a new job will be hard) - I've got a budget which I plan to stick to but the plan for anybody in their early 20's like I am has to be to stretch yourself when you first start (in the sense of few luxuries) in the knowledge that as you move on career rise you will do very nicely - new jobs I'm currently interviewing for would alleviate this problem and give me an extra £800pm disposable...it can be done and I fully intend to keep the 540i!
So in actual fact, you haven't then. rolleyes

kiethton

13,896 posts

181 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
All that jazz said:
So in actual fact, you haven't then. rolleyes
By the time the student loan repayments have come off it's within a few hundred annually....hardly a huge difference.

okgo

38,062 posts

199 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Oi, he owns 25% of that one bedder in Sidcup fair and square!!

kiethton

13,896 posts

181 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
okgo said:
Oi, he owns 25% of that one bedder in Sidcup fair and square!!
This one's 50% and in Poverest wink

All that jazz

7,632 posts

147 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
kiethton said:
By the time the student loan repayments have come off it's within a few hundred annually....hardly a huge difference.
But it's not yours and never will be so your comparison is pointless. Come back when you've actually bought 100% of a house on your £27k income.

Kozy

3,169 posts

219 months

Friday 14th February 2014
quotequote all
All that jazz said:
But it's not yours and never will be so your comparison is pointless. Come back when you've actually bought 100% of a house on your £27k income.
Agree, not a valid point at all. Congratulations on falling for a stty deal.