When crypto crashes, will the 'normal' markets suffer?

When crypto crashes, will the 'normal' markets suffer?

Author
Discussion

Badda

Original Poster:

2,673 posts

83 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
As the title really. I feel fairly sure the crypto bubble can't last much longer - what's the knock on effect to the markets as and when it goes pop?

NickCQ

5,392 posts

97 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
The danger could come if futures contracts blow up a clearing house that also clears non-BTC derivatives.

JB!

5,254 posts

181 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
Economic slump as people who have been chucking money into it lose the lot?

bloomen

6,918 posts

160 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
Dunno about futures. Beyond that I'll go for nothing. It's mainly nobodies throwing money in. The volumes really aren't big. It's retail level stuff with virtually no professional investment at all.

The prices look enormous because there are hardly any coins available. Trading is unregulated so there's masses of wash trading. Market cap is a junk metric when it comes to crypto. It means nothing.

There might be 16 or so million bitcoins in existence. Only a few tens of thousands traded set the price.

James_B

12,642 posts

258 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
I’d imagine it’ll cause not even a ripple. The market capitalisation is too small to matter.

FarmyardPants

4,112 posts

219 months

Wednesday 13th December 2017
quotequote all
Poundland might dip

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
"When" - the only uncertainty it the market is uncertainty.

Personally I hope we see a move down that makes the USD/CHF move a while back look nothing biggrin




dbs2000

2,690 posts

193 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
I ask myself this and also, what will happen to crypto if the stock market crashes....
I slowly go insane thinking about such things smile

cashmax

1,106 posts

241 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
bloomen said:
Dunno about futures. Beyond that I'll go for nothing. It's mainly nobodies throwing money in. The volumes really aren't big. It's retail level stuff with virtually no professional investment at all.

The prices look enormous because there are hardly any coins available. Trading is unregulated so there's masses of wash trading. Market cap is a junk metric when it comes to crypto. It means nothing.

There might be 16 or so million bitcoins in existence. Only a few tens of thousands traded set the price.
The trade volumes have been outstripping many traditional exchanges for a while now. If nearly $30 Billion daily is not much volume, perhaps you could confirm what is?

klivedrgar

85 posts

175 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
I don't actually think an impending BTC crash is a systemic threat to the markets right now. I think the bigger threat though is how big the BTC or next iterations of cryptocurrency can become. The concept has the power to really disrupt traditional markets, and in particular how governments interact with them. In 10 years time.. when it's all a lot more established.. that's probably where we start to realise the risks!

bloomen

6,918 posts

160 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
cashmax said:
The trade volumes have been outstripping many traditional exchanges for a while now. If nearly $30 Billion daily is not much volume, perhaps you could confirm what is?
https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/bitcoin/#mark...

Highest volume is Bitfinex which isn't even trading real dollars. Second highest is Korean which is low to zero fee which means the same coin can be batted back and forth millions of times an hour at virtually no cost. So that several hundred million in volume might not consist of any new money at all.

Many other top ten options are BTC vs an alt which means inflated and non existent market cap vs another one exchanging money that rarely leaves those exchanges.

None of these exchanges have any overlap with other markets. Most of their volume will be under the control of Bitcoin whales who paid peanuts for their coins a few years ago.

It's primarily one giant mirage and feedback loop.

If someone tried to extract 1 billion actual dollars from the crypto market in one day certain coins would go to zero and the biggies would probably go down by 90% or more.

That's why there'll be no effect on normal markets. Also the crypto market is truly global and 24/7. A catastrophic collapse would be felt across the world and also spread across the world.

Edited by bloomen on Thursday 14th December 14:26

R11ysf

1,936 posts

183 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
NickCQ said:
The danger could come if futures contracts blow up a clearing house that also clears non-BTC derivatives.
Literally Zero chance of that happening. They are setting a 35% overnight margin and they also have and have had products with considerably higher volatility and risk profiles than Bitcoin on their books for a long time without risking their core business. Writing huge out of the money options has a higher blow up risk than BTC.

otherman

2,191 posts

166 months

Thursday 14th December 2017
quotequote all
JB! said:
Economic slump as people who have been chucking money into it lose the lot?
For every loser there's a winner.

bongtom

2,018 posts

84 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
otherman said:
JB! said:
Economic slump as people who have been chucking money into it lose the lot?
For every 1000 losers there's a winner.
FTFY.

I like this quote from Sir Isaac Newton
“I could calculate the motions of the heavenly bodies,” he said, “but not the madness of the people.”

He personally lost $4 million (in today's money) on the South China Sea share collapse.




Edited by bongtom on Friday 15th December 04:48

Behemoth

2,105 posts

132 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
bongtom said:
I like this quote from Sir Isaac Newton
“I could calculate the motions of the heavenly bodies,” he said, “but not the madness of the people.”

He personally lost $4 million (in today's money) on the South China Sea share collapse.
Newton also led the move to sound assayed money when he took charge of the Royal Mint. Doctored, clipped & fake coins reached crisis point & he took over when a recoinage exercise was about to collapse because of fraud. He did it properly through chemical & mathematical analysis. He saved the Royal Mint & secured the long term viability of the UK's coinage supply. If he were alive today, Newton would embrace the concept of a mathematically backed currency immediately.

anonymous-user

55 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
I dabbled a little over 2 weeks ago, BIT-XBTE
60% up in that time.
Have now sold my original stake so ‘free’ gamble now
Doesn’t matter if it crashes but equally could carry on up.
Bearing in mind the financial experts said to sell at $3000 back in July & now $18000 ..

James_B

12,642 posts

258 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
Jimboka said:
I dabbled a little over 2 weeks ago, BIT-XBTE
60% up in that time.
Have now sold my original stake so ‘free’ gamble now
Doesn’t matter if it crashes but equally could carry on up.
Bearing in mind the financial experts said to sell at $3000 back in July & now $18000 ..
Which financial experts said that, and what was their argument?

ReaperCushions

6,037 posts

185 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
James_B said:
Which financial experts said that, and what was their argument?
Probably some of the same people who called this a bubble at $3k $5k $10k $15k etc..

bloomen

6,918 posts

160 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
James_B said:
Which financial experts said that, and what was their argument?
Goldman Sachs. Their predictions gradually crept up and then petered out into silence when it went bonkers.

James_B

12,642 posts

258 months

Friday 15th December 2017
quotequote all
bloomen said:
Goldman Sachs. Their predictions gradually crept up and then petered out into silence when it went bonkers.
That’s a bank. Do you have a quote of them telling people to sell?