Login | Register
SearchMy Stuff
My ProfileMy PreferencesMy Mates RSS Feed
Reply to Topic
Author Discussion

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

54,241 posts

134 months

[news] 
Saturday 28th July 2012 quote quote all
After having my hand shaken to pieces by a 30-year old Black and Decker mains trimmer, I tried a neighbour's cordless Bosch one and it was a revelation.

So I thought I'd get one: www.amazon.co.uk/Bosch-Cordless-Hedgecutter-Blade-...

And then I see there's a posher 18V one: www.amazon.co.uk/AHS-52-LI-Cordless-Electric/dp/B0...

I guess this has more grunt and better battery life/between charges - worth the extra? And any other candidates to try?




JustDerv

267 posts

77 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
Simpo Two said:
After having my hand shaken to pieces by a 30-year old Black and Decker mains trimmer, I tried a neighbour's cordless Bosch one and it was a revelation.

So I thought I'd get one: www.amazon.co.uk/Bosch-Cordless-Hedgecutter-Blade-...

And then I see there's a posher 18V one: www.amazon.co.uk/AHS-52-LI-Cordless-Electric/dp/B0...

I guess this has more grunt and better battery life/between charges - worth the extra? And any other candidates to try?
It'll be more powerful, probably last longer before running down. I have a mains powered one, specifically this one:

http://www.lawnmowersworld.co.uk/p/Flymo_EasiCut_6...

Gets blooming heavy after a couple of hours, and with the Flymo, you need to hold two buttons down after pressing a third button, so it sometimes just cuts off as your hands/arms get too tired!

On the other hand, with the blade length, I can cut the the whole width of the top in one go, rather than doing half on one side and then moving to the other side to do the other half.



stemll

1,510 posts

69 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
JustDerv said:
It'll be more powerful, probably last longer before running down.
Reading the two links in the OP, the 14.4v says 55 minute runtime (x2 as it comes with two batteries) against 50 minutes for the 18v one. I guess it's down to the 19v one having more power maybe?

The 14.4v one is also the best part of half the price. Is the 18v really going to be that much better? It also shows a boxed weight of 3kg to 6kg for the 18v one so unless the 18v comes in a massive box to account for the weight, will be easier to use for any length of time.

The Leaper

1,715 posts

75 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
I have a Flymo mains electric hedge cutter. It is good for general use and has quite a large blade so reaches across all our hedges. The three drawbacks are

  • it is quite heavy and gets tiresome to use after a while
  • the number of buttons to push or hold with both hands to get it going: good for safety though
  • need to watch out and avoid cutting through the cable...I've done this twice over the years.
Two weeks ago I bought a Ryobi long pole hedge trimmer, mains electrric. Great tool! Excellent to get to the parts that the Flymo dosen't easily reach. Very easy to change the cutting angle and extend the pole. However, it is quite heavy and although it's OK to uses at a 90 degree angle for lengthy periods it is tiring to the arms if used at a different angle, say 45 degrees, and therefore some way from your body. Ideally it needs a shoulder harness, so I tend to lean it against my body when using. Really is quick and saves having to mess with ladders. The other drawback is that it has a shorter blade so it may not cut across all of the top of a hedge.

R.

Pioneer

1,185 posts

68 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
Big difference is the 18v one uses a lithium battery, the 14.4 uses the old style batteries.
Advertisement

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

54,241 posts

134 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
OK... a delve through the specs scattered on the net concludes:

Of the Ni-Cad: 14.4V/1.5Ah NiCd battery, two batteries, total of 110 minutes’ running time (55 minutes each battery). 2.6kg

Of the Li: Lithium-ion - Battery voltage : 18 V - Charge time : 3 h - Battery running time : 50 min - Blade length : 520 mm - Blade spacing : 15 mm - No-load stroke rate : 2.200 spm 2.3kg

Charge time for each is 3 hours.

My garden is quite small and I can probably trim everything that needs trimming in 5-10 minutes, so one issue is how long the battery stays charged for. I don't much like gardening so if I have to wait three hours before acting on impulse, I probably won't act at all!

Cost isn't a massive factor so if the Li version stays charged for momths and the NiCad goes flat in a week, the Li probably wins.

BigBen

6,507 posts

99 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
The Li one will be significantly lighter, this is its main advantage

stemll

1,510 posts

69 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
BigBen said:
The Li one will be significantly lighter, this is its main advantage
300g. Doubt you'll notice the difference when it's still over 2kg

OP, if you can do the lot in 10 minutes would something like this do the job? Only 900g

http://www.amazon.co.uk/Bosch-Cordless-Li-Ion-Hedg...

Buzz84

99 posts

18 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
I have the first one with the Ni-Cad batteries and it is a good peice of kit, I went for that over the Li one due to the cost as I dont have a massive amount of things that need trimming so the battries last long enough for me.
cuts decent sized bits of bush wih relative ease, and very rarely jams up (only when the battery is low) its easy to wield and is a real comfort not to have to worry about a cable.

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

54,241 posts

134 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
Thanks - I was about to go for the Li one but see it has a different handle. I'll see if I can get to B&Q etc tomorrow and get my paws on both.

Jasandjules

45,410 posts

98 months

[news] 
Sunday 29th July 2012 quote quote all
I got a petrol one... Not get petrol for it yet though!!

Simpo Two

Original Poster:

54,241 posts

134 months

[news] 
Wednesday 1st August 2012 quote quote all
B&Q solved it. The Ni-Cd version handled beautifully, light and well-balanced with perfectly placed handles/buttons. By contrast the Li one felt nose-heavy, the handles less well placed and you had to operate three of them to make it work.

It was reduced to £59.98 in B&Q but I couldn't remember how much Amazon were selling it for, so left it and went home to check. Amazon were also £59.98 but now out of stock. Doh!

mondayo

586 posts

132 months

[news] 
Wednesday 1st August 2012 quote quote all
Glad you've seen the offer at B&Q, as I was about to post and say you should get yourself down there. I bought one at the weekend.

Black can man

10,963 posts

37 months

[news] 
Wednesday 1st August 2012 quote quote all
Simpo Two said:
After having my hand shaken to pieces by a 30-year old Black and Decker mains trimmer, I tried a neighbour's cordless Bosch one and it was a revelation.

So I thought I'd get one: www.amazon.co.uk/Bosch-Cordless-Hedgecutter-Blade-...

And then I see there's a posher 18V one: www.amazon.co.uk/AHS-52-LI-Cordless-Electric/dp/B0...

I guess this has more grunt and better battery life/between charges - worth the extra? And any other candidates to try?
I have one of these , ideal if you have an allotment like myself ,
Reply to Topic