The boiler dissaster thread

Author
Discussion

silentbrown

8,840 posts

116 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
fastgerman said:
£3.8k for a Worcester Bosch incl. power flush, magnetic filter, fitting, brick work and brick matching, plumbing etc.
Bloody hell. That escalated quickly! From a couple of £10 parts and a 2p screw...

I know it's nigh impossible to value peace of mind, but even so... eek

wombleh

1,790 posts

122 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
I had BG homecare once, that was more of a disaster than the boiler ever could be.

They were talking about £4k for a new boiler, we just had one fitted for £1600 by an indy.

fastgerman

Original Poster:

1,914 posts

195 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
nyt said:
Probably too late but the worcester comes with a 8 or 10 year guarantee if fitted by approved suppliers so you don't need to pay Homecare.
I've just had one fitted for £2,.5k in London.
Not paying the homeware for 8 years means the boiler is 'free'.
BT give a guarantee but in their logic you still need homecare. Weird.
Thanks, I did ask about this. British Gas have a link with Worcester Bosch so all the warranties carry over. The homecare 200 that we're on will be frozen for 1 year and covered under the new boiler warranty. After 1 year, the homecare 200 will start up again at around £10 a month. This includes a yearly service, which are usually around £100 with a specialist (I have this done on a BTL property in the same area) so it kind of pays for itself.

The homecare team can also be called 24/7 and it covers anything plumbing related, not just the boiler. It's good for sleeping a bit easier anyway :-)

Details - https://www.britishgas.co.uk/content/britishgas/pr...

essayer

9,076 posts

194 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
Vaillant do a good warranty too, provided it's installed by an approved installer.

Having a manufacturer backed warranty would give me far more peace of mind than some insurance policy subject to the whims of BG.

KTF

9,805 posts

150 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
fastgerman said:
I could probably save £1k going elsewhere,
You could cover a lot of call outs from a local trade for £1k plus, as has already been mentioned, the boiler is under warranty for the cost of an annual service (<£100).

Are not even going to get a comparative quote or speak to the guy who serviced it before as there may not even be anything wrong with it?

telecat

8,528 posts

241 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
Yes BG do have a link with WB but I wouldn't use them. The Boiler is made so that only BG can service it and the last time I had them in they wanted to fit a 28KW boiler despite the fact I said the old 28KW couldn't cope. It seems they only get a certain range and the larger ones are not included. Ours was a 38KW and replacement and flush was about £2000.

LordHaveMurci

12,044 posts

169 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
nyt said:
Probably too late but the worcester comes with a 8 or 10 year guarantee if fitted by approved suppliers so you don't need to pay Homecare.
I've just had one fitted for £2,.5k in London.
Not paying the homeware for 8 years means the boiler is 'free'.
BT give a guarantee but in their logic you still need homecare. Weird.
BG should give 1yrs Homecare cover as part of the price, can always cancel it next year at renewal.

We have had BG Homecare for nearly 20yrs despite having two mates who are Gas Safe registered, one of which fitted the Worcester boiler. Don't fancy trying to get hold of either in the depths of winter when they are up to their eyes in work, BG have never failed to turn up promptly.

Edited by LordHaveMurci on Friday 6th May 14:36

fastgerman

Original Poster:

1,914 posts

195 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
LordHaveMurci said:
nyt said:
Probably too late but the worcester comes with a 8 or 10 year guarantee if fitted by approved suppliers so you don't need to pay Homecare.
I've just had one fitted for £2,.5k in London.
Not paying the homeware for 8 years means the boiler is 'free'.
BT give a guarantee but in their logic you still need homecare. Weird.
BG should give 1yrs Homecare cover as part of the price, can always cancel it next year at renewal.

We have had BG Homecare for nearly 20yrs despite having two mates who are Gas Safe registered, one of which fitted the Worcester boiler. Don't fancy trying to get hold of either in the depths of winter when they are up to their eyes in work, BG have never failed to turn up promptly.

Edited by LordHaveMurci on Friday 6th May 14:36
THIS > 'Don't fancy trying to get hold of either in the depths of winter when they are up to their eyes in work, BG have never failed to turn up promptly.'

They have 6000 engineers, whereas Worcester have around 400

Sheepshanks

32,788 posts

119 months

Friday 6th May 2016
quotequote all
fastgerman said:
Well I've taken the easy and safe option (although expensive) and gone with BG.

£3.8k for a Worcester Bosch incl. power flush, magnetic filter, fitting, brick work and brick matching, plumbing etc.

Seems to be around £1.6k of labour, which is steep I know.
Well, typical WB boiler is around a grand. Although I presume BG get hefty discounts.

AmitG

3,299 posts

160 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
LordHaveMurci said:
We have had BG Homecare for nearly 20yrs despite having two mates who are Gas Safe registered, one of which fitted the Worcester boiler. Don't fancy trying to get hold of either in the depths of winter when they are up to their eyes in work, BG have never failed to turn up promptly.
Same here. I've had BG cover for the last 15 years. It's pricey, but:
  • It covers all the plumbing as well
  • They always turn up on time, or at least call ahead with an ETA if they are stuck on another job
  • They do whatever it takes to get the thing working again - the inside of my boiler must have been replaced at least twice over by now
  • They do an annual service and generally don't mind doing other small plumbing bits (e.g. weeping pipe) at the same time, in return for tea/biscuits
If I knew a good indy who was available 24x365, was always available for emergency callout and who I knew wouldn't rip me off, I wouldn't bother with BG. But I don't...


eliot

11,434 posts

254 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
fastgerman said:
Well I've taken the easy and safe option (although expensive) and gone with BG.

£3.8k for a Worcester Bosch incl. power flush, magnetic filter, fitting, brick work and brick matching, plumbing etc.

Seems to be around £1.6k of labour, which is steep I know.
£1.6k in labour simply do a straight swap of a boiler?

Having these service contracts is nothing more than a yearly invite for a salesman to find a reason to sell you something.

Of course they want to sell you a WB boiler at your expense , they know it will last and they will never need to touch it for 10 years - whilst you continue to pay them a monthly subscription for the pleasure.

Countdown

39,908 posts

196 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
eliot said:
Having these service contracts is nothing more than a yearly invite for a salesman to find a reason to sell you something.
Not in my experience. I had BG Homecare in my previous house. They kept a 20 year old Worcester Heatslave 9.24 going for ages. In fact I'm sure they said "keep it as long as you can because the new stuff isn't as reliable". Response rates were excellent, there was no worry about being ripped off, everything was covered.

However, when it finally DID toddle off to boiler heaven their quote for a replacement was a joke (in that I burst out laughing). When I asked why they were quoting £4k when an indy was quoting £2k the saleman's response was "well, we're Britsh Gas" rofl

Rickyy

6,618 posts

219 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
Kestons are well documented for cracked heat exchanger. Terrible boilers!

Worcester Bosch by far have the best customer service team I've ever dealt with. On the rare occasion I've had to make a warranty call for a customer, they have always attended the next day and performed a first time fix.

Compare that to Baxi, who took 8 days and two visits to repair a water heater that was faulty out of the box!

British Gas boilers don't come with warranty as such. They buy them cheap from Worcester and strip the warranty off them, then sell you the warranty in the form of homecare.

If you have the space and a suitable cold main, unvented trumps a combi everytime.


Sheepshanks

32,788 posts

119 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
Countdown said:
When I asked why they were quoting £4k when an indy was quoting £2k the saleman's response was "well, we're Britsh Gas" rofl
To be fair, that is the complete answer.

Wacky Racer

38,163 posts

247 months

Saturday 7th May 2016
quotequote all
I had a new large capacity WB boiler fitted eight years ago, (Under 2k) never touched it since, never been serviced, still works as good as new.

BG....Wouldn't touch them with a bargepole...heard too many bad things.

dogz

334 posts

256 months

Sunday 8th May 2016
quotequote all
I've had quite a few boilers fitted recently due to having a few rentals

Cheapest way by far is to find a Worcester trained engineer to fit with either you or him supplying the boiler

Places like plumbnation can give you an idea of costs but typically depending on your requirements a boiler with flue and controllers will start around £1k. Most Worcesters come with minimum 5yrs warranty and up to 10 for some models

The engineer I use charges me £500 - £700 to fit depending on amount of work required

As has been mentioned, you could significantly self-insure between what you are paying and what you could get it done for.

There is usually only 1 winner with insurance based products and that's the insurance companies is BG

Alucidnation

16,810 posts

170 months

Sunday 8th May 2016
quotequote all
No wonder BG are still going.

Harry Flashman

19,363 posts

242 months

Tuesday 10th May 2016
quotequote all
Greshamst said:
You could look into getting a Flow boiler if you've got a 3 room or bigger house http://www.flowenergy.uk.com/

The boiler generates electricity for free whilst it heats water, which you can use to reduce your electricity bill, or sell back to the grid.
I wish I had known about this!

Just fitted a Worcester Bosch 35/Megaflo combination to my house. The flow thing looks excellent.

KTF

9,805 posts

150 months

Tuesday 10th May 2016
quotequote all
Harry Flashman said:
Greshamst said:
You could look into getting a Flow boiler if you've got a 3 room or bigger house http://www.flowenergy.uk.com/

The boiler generates electricity for free whilst it heats water, which you can use to reduce your electricity bill, or sell back to the grid.
I wish I had known about this!

Just fitted a Worcester Bosch 35/Megaflo combination to my house. The flow thing looks excellent.
It is interesting but would your local installer be OK servicing it do would you have to get a Flow person out each time?

I guess it would need a connection from the boiler to the meter as well?

Chris Type R

8,031 posts

249 months

Tuesday 10th May 2016
quotequote all
Tom_C76 said:
For balance I took homecare with a fixed price 99 quid repair at the start of the policy. The guy was there for 5 hours and fitted about £400 in parts. Friendly, helpful, couldn't have been nicer.
Similar experience - boiler wasn't heating and all of the local gas engineers were busy due to a cold spell. Paid for the £99 fixed repair and an annual policy.

BG were there next day. They took a few days to get everything working again due to waiting for parts and it being the weekend. By the end of their visit I'd had:
- pump replaced,
- boiler fascia replaced,
- boiler fan replaced,
- boiler heat exchanger replaced,
- a section of blocked pipe cut out, cleared, and fixed.

So, probably around £1k of parts and about 10-14 hours of labour.