Generator problem

Author
Discussion

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Thursday 23rd February 2017
quotequote all
Yes, but is a new hoover not likely to be a lot cheaper than a genny that can put out the full 2000w on 110v?

Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Friday 24th February 2017
quotequote all
guindilias said:
Yes, but is a new hoover not likely to be a lot cheaper than a genny that can put out the full 2000w on 110v?
Of course a new hoover will be cheaper, but it wont make the output from the 110v socket more than the 1kw that it currently is!

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Saturday 25th February 2017
quotequote all
I meant a new hoover under 1000 watts... unless you really need the extra suction.

Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Saturday 25th February 2017
quotequote all
guindilias said:
I meant a new hoover under 1000 watts... unless you really need the extra suction.
Considering the drywall sander is 700w a 200-300w hoover isn't going to suck much dust wink

Used the sander/hoover Wednesday via transformer plugged to the 240v socket and it worked perfectly, If I don't hear anything back by Monday I will be giving the company another call.

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Saturday 25th February 2017
quotequote all
Ah, apologies - I thought you were sanding and then cleaning up afterwards, didn't realise you would be using them both at once.
The answer is obvious though - get a petrol powered hoover! cool

Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
Have now had a response from the seller, they have said they have found out a little more about the generator (didn't say what) but will accept the return of the generator for a full refund! just waiting for them to confirm they will be paying return postage costs.

Just going to get a Wolf generator for £210 to use until everything is settled, I will however triple check the output is from EITHER socket wink

Jambo85

3,319 posts

88 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
It's an interesting problem... I guess the reason behind this is that the current is the same in either case but the voltage is half therefore the power is half.

Maybe a coil tapped half way along to halve the voltage or some current-limited component somewhere.

Ways around it but not without cost, so I would imagine most generators with 110/220V outputs will have the same 'feature'.

Just talking from theory here, I've never looked inside one.

eliot

11,428 posts

254 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
Saleen836 said:
Just going to get a Wolf generator for £210 to use until everything is settled, I will however triple check the output is from EITHER socket wink
Wolf is just a cheap Chinese generator, significantly poorer quality than the Honda.

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
Wolf are horrendous - cheap trash rebadged as any number of manufacturers. Apart from being an absolute bugger to start after the first few runs, they DRINK oil, and after about 25 hours tend to throw a rod.
I've had 4 of them in for "fixing", straight to the skip. None salvageable at all.

Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
eliot said:
Saleen836 said:
Just going to get a Wolf generator for £210 to use until everything is settled, I will however triple check the output is from EITHER socket wink
Wolf is just a cheap Chinese generator, significantly poorer quality than the Honda.
I know, I just need something temporary until the insurance claim is sorted where I will either be paid out to replace my damaged one or they will replace it. If it lasts 12 months it will be worth the £200 cost.

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
If it lasts a year of regular use I'll buy it from you and stick it in a museum!

eliot

11,428 posts

254 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
I got a bunch of Wolf Grinders - inherited from my dad and about 30 years old - back in the day when Wolf was good quality rather than today's 'new Wolf' which is just a brand name stuck on generic tat

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Wednesday 1st March 2017
quotequote all
A few years ago B&Q were selling the "Wolf" gennys painted grey, under a different name. That soon stopped, I presume because they had so many returns.
I had a "Wolf" genny (bought as the only genny for sale within reasonable driving distance from my hunting shack), around 1200w if I remember correctly.
It was so hard to pull over the recoil starter that my cousin had to have a friend sit on the genny while she tried starting it, otherwise it would just lift off the ground when she pulled the starter.
I could put a boot on it and pull it, and sometimes eventually it would start. She was too short to do that.
I checked the oil during the first "run-in" period - half a tank of petrol gone, the oil was already at the bottom of the dipstick. Understandable on any engine running in, they are going to burn oil.
15 hours or so of running in later and constantly topping up, it still wouldn't do more that half a tank of petrol without needing stopped, topped up with oil (bloody awkward due to the angle of the filler) and started again.
Fixed my old "Yanmar" suitcase genny which had sat for a few years due to lack of available parts, and used it in future before I bought a BIG Onan genny. 3kW, 250kg!
But you can actually short it out completely, live to neutral, and it'll bog down, grunt for a while, then stop - they used to demonstrate this back when they were making them in the 40s (no breakers, mechanical governor).
Then fire them up again, and they were fine. Mine, rated at 13 amps or so, will start my wood splitter motor with a starting current of 72A. It doesn't like it, but it does it every time.

The "Wolf" eventually died due to a broken con-rod, like the rest of them.

Don't waste your money on cheap generators!

Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
The seller has informed me they will arrange for the generator to be collected from the delivery address, I now need to arrange a day off and tie up collection with delivery of a new one, decided to avoid the Wolf models and going for this instead... http://www.sgs-engineering.com/se2700-super-econom...

eliot

11,428 posts

254 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
Saleen836 said:
The seller has informed me they will arrange for the generator to be collected from the delivery address, I now need to arrange a day off and tie up collection with delivery of a new one, decided to avoid the Wolf models and going for this instead... http://www.sgs-engineering.com/se2700-super-econom...
Stephill are a recognised manufacturer.
Dare I ask,as it's not specifically listed - whats the output on the 110v output?
(dont say 16A - that's just the rating of the socket)

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
It runs 2.5mm2 wire to the 115v socket, as opposed to 1.5mm2 to the 240v socket, so looks like it should be grand. And agreed, Stephill are a good gen-end maker, often used on Lister gennys as well - and they aren't cheap!

Jambo85

3,319 posts

88 months

Thursday 2nd March 2017
quotequote all
eliot said:
Saleen836 said:
The seller has informed me they will arrange for the generator to be collected from the delivery address, I now need to arrange a day off and tie up collection with delivery of a new one, decided to avoid the Wolf models and going for this instead... http://www.sgs-engineering.com/se2700-super-econom...
Stephill are a recognised manufacturer.
Dare I ask,as it's not specifically listed - whats the output on the 110v output?
(dont say 16A - that's just the rating of the socket)
Indeed, although it won't (shouldn't) be more than 16A so it isn't the full 2.2 kW.



Saleen836

Original Poster:

11,111 posts

209 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
eliot said:
Saleen836 said:
The seller has informed me they will arrange for the generator to be collected from the delivery address, I now need to arrange a day off and tie up collection with delivery of a new one, decided to avoid the Wolf models and going for this instead... http://www.sgs-engineering.com/se2700-super-econom...
Stephill are a recognised manufacturer.
Dare I ask,as it's not specifically listed - whats the output on the 110v output?
(dont say 16A - that's just the rating of the socket)
Collection of the generator is this Friday, they have however specified it MUST be in a box or the courier will not accept it! (on a small pallet wrapped in bubblewrap isn't acceptable)
have just ordered the Stephill generator and after explaining the problem I had with the Honda generator with the sales guy he phoned Stephill to confirm both sockets provide 2.2kw output, he also said they had the same problem with another make which like Honda they never specified on their website.

Jambo85

3,319 posts

88 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
2.2 kW is 20A at 110V...

guindilias

5,245 posts

120 months

Wednesday 8th March 2017
quotequote all
You can pull 100A from a 16A commando socket if it isn't for long - 20A full time is no problem at all, in fact 30A would work all day long as well. I showed the electrical design engineer at work this thread, (he is a man of few words) and all he said was "Bunch'a shcensoredite - if any a dem fucensoredckers could design a generator they might know what they're on about. But they don't know fucensoredck all, so they won't."

The man spoke....



Edited by guindilias on Wednesday 8th March 20:31