Which kid gets the bigger room?

Which kid gets the bigger room?

Author
Discussion

offshoreeddy

Original Poster:

349 posts

142 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Bit of a dilemma here, be interested to hear your thoughts.

My g/f and I are moving house shortly from a 4-bed to a 3-bed house. However, the sq ft in the 3 bed is a bigger than the 4-bed, and it includes two rooms downstairs, one of which'll be my office, the other a room for the two kids to share, a 'chillout' / play room if you like.

However.

My 7yr old son is only here half the time. Her 12yr old daughter is here all the time. Now, originally when I was wondering about who got the bigger bedroom, I went with the 'older kid gets the bigger room' logic. However, the 12yr old doesn't really play in her room anymore, has friends over etc instead and they use the whole house; plus they have use of the downstairs 'chillout' room as well for the whole 50% of the time when my son isn't here.

My son, on the other hand, is of an age where he does like to play in his room and so might benefit from more floorspace. Plus the bigger room will fit his loft bed in sideways, whereas the smaller room won't, and this creates more floorspace for scalextric, playing cars etc which he loves to do. The small room would probably fit that in too though.

There isn't really a whole lot of size difference between them - they're the exact same length, but one is 70cm wider than the other and has a small alcove.

Have already said to both that they can have choice of decorating/feature wall/whatever in whichever room they end up in.

So, thoughts? Pics below.

Big room:



Small room:


Zoon

6,719 posts

122 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
The small room looks bigger.

ForZiE23

194 posts

96 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
We went with older son (14 now) having the smaller room but had a TV onto the wall and younger son (now 6) having the bigger room as more toys etc. Alot of people didnt get it thinking the older child should have the bigger room but personally we think it worked better that way.
Also in time i think they will want to swap and have more of a "boys room" and the the bigger room into double bed etc when 17 - 18 odd.

offshoreeddy

Original Poster:

349 posts

142 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Zoon said:
The small room looks bigger.
LOL I know, doesn't it. The dimensions are 13.5' x 10'10 for the bigger one, and 13.5' x 8'6 for the smaller.

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
I'd let the daughter have the larger room, or let her decide which room she wants, as she's there full time.

TTmonkey

20,911 posts

248 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
The girl. She's there 100% of the time.
Or at least give her the choice.
She's old enough to listen to your point of view if you explain the reasons, but the decision should remain hers.

Toltec

7,165 posts

224 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Give the girl the choice, you might find she prefers the smaller room because of the view, closeness of the bathroom, not sharing a wall with your bedroom etc.


caelite

4,280 posts

113 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
It's quite clear you favourite child is the one who should get the bigger room.

evil

Sheets Tabuer

19,067 posts

216 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Oldest gets the bigger room, you only have your 7 year old half the time and it would make more sense to encourage him to spend time with the family not go and play in his room.

g7jhp

6,970 posts

239 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
a) The oldest gets the choice of the bigger room
b) The one who's there 100% of the time should get the choice of the bigger room (over one who's their 50%)

As a+b are the 12 year old daughter, give her the choice.


schmunk

4,399 posts

126 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
The 12 year old will soon enough want a desk in her room (if not already) for schoolwork. Will that fit in each room?

hotchy

4,487 posts

127 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
As a child my parents gave me the big room and my older sister the small room. The logic was shes so messy its less space to mess up.

hyphen

26,262 posts

91 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Worst, my 3 bed house doesn't have a tiny box room, post ever.

TTmonkey

20,911 posts

248 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Very soon shes going to have the full kick in of the clothes buying hormones. She'll want several wardrobes and at least one floor to ceiling shoe rack.


I have a daughter. I know.

Zetec-S

5,938 posts

94 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Logically I'd suggest the son has it if there's more room for playing with toys, etc...

However, as he's not there all the time and the daughter is (and is also older), it's probably worth giving her the option. Sit her down and explain, she's probably old enough to understand both sides of the argument. If she wants the bigger room it will save a lot of agro in the long run as you've got to live with her all the time smile

FourWheelDrift

88,638 posts

285 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
offshoreeddy said:
Zoon said:
The small room looks bigger.
LOL I know, doesn't it. The dimensions are 13.5' x 10'10 for the bigger one, and 13.5' x 8'6 for the smaller.
Do they know that? Tell them that they are both the same size. What are they going to do measure it?

R8Steve

4,150 posts

176 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
As there's only a couple of foot in it i can't really imagine either caring tbh.

I'd let the oldest choose.

SteellFJ

793 posts

168 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
The one with the most st should have the biggest room, a fight i'm currently undertaking with a 10 yo who wont give his 4 yo brother a bigger room without tears and tantrums. Been discussing it for 6+ months and he never uses the bigger room or any crap he has in it!!

Mummies boy gets his way though in our house, they both do, just never me.

PositronicRay

27,084 posts

184 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
Rank hath it's privilege.

Older full time girl gets 1st refusal.

JQ

5,760 posts

180 months

Thursday 13th July 2017
quotequote all
We gave our older child the choice - he picked the smaller room and everyone was happy.