Help / advice needed with our rescue dog

Help / advice needed with our rescue dog

Author
Discussion

solidlad84

Original Poster:

176 posts

187 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Hi all. Been a long time lurker of this section so it's about time I made a post.

Last August our family finally found a dog that didn't cause any allergies with the 2 out of 4 family members who seemed to be allergic to every breed. We decided to rescue a dog and not buy a puppy, and ended up with a staffy/ black Labrador cross called Ellie. She is over 30kgs and very muscular so I suspect there may be another breed in the mix too but that doesn't bother us. She has been the perfect dog in almost every aspect - perfectly house trained, trained to sleep downstairs and she never goes upstairs even after we took down the stairgate we had initially bought for her. She is a big wuss despite her appearance and would happily let even a stranger pull a toy or food out of her mouth with no fuss at all. She also seems to enjoy greeting strangers like they are long lost friends.

She is the perfect family dog in many ways except for one. Whenever we do anything that she even remotely associates with going on a walk she goes absolutely mental, almost like she's a different dog. She gets walked between 2-3 times a day so I doubt this is from excess energy. The manic behaviour then continues until she is back in the house. She will pull on the lead so badly that taking her for a 30 minute walk feels like you've completed a marathon. She still listens to commands like sit or stay and she will do this when pulling the lead but as soon as you begin to take a step forward she notices and begins pulling again, and we have tried all sorts to stop her pulling so badly to no avail. It is this problem that has made us wary of ever letting her off the lead - in the year we've had her she has only been off lead either in the garden or a contained area (local tennis courts are a favourite) to try and improve her behaviour off the lead. This puts her in to a catch 22 type situation - she could do with running around on her own accord to help her burn off steam faster but while she is so manic on the lead we worry if we let her off she wouldn't come back until she fancied it - and she looks quite intimidating to a lot of people so that is something we just can't do until we are 100% confident in her.

Sorry for the long post and thanks for making it this far if you did - any advice would be really appreciated.

Oh and when I'm not posting from my phone I will upload some pics of her when we got her and how she is now smile

Thanks in advance.

Jasandjules

69,885 posts

229 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
What breed and how much exercise (in minutes) is she getting each day?

Also, what food is she on? Some of the commercial c**p has additives which make a dog ADHD.


tintopracer

139 posts

167 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
I share your feelings. We adopted a 2 yr old Harrier Hound from Dog's Trust in April. We soon realised that he'd not lived in a house before and although he's been a really quick learner, walking him is still a problem at times even with up to 3hrs exercise a day. We haven't been able to let him off the lead on his own (without other dogs) as he will disappear at great speed.

We're persevering with recall training and walking him on open land on a long (20m) lead. Nothing fancy just some 50kg webbing from B&Q made into a lead. It gives him the freedom to explore without being able to run off.

After a few weeks of having Charlie, his behaviour in the car became a problem. He was getting very excited and barked at other dogs, children etc. when in the car. We spoke with a behaviourist at Dog's Trust, who suggested that we had made a problem in that trips in the car always lead to a long walk, either with our horse or days out. He associated car journeys with fun times. We now take him on all sorts other trips - to the shops, to the tip wherever so that he's learnt that sometimes its walk time and other its just a journey and he doesn't get out of the car.

I think it may be worth you trying similar; variety of activity and some fun training with lots of treats should help. Does your dog get walked at the same time every day? it could be seen as being the best bit of the day, hence the excitement. What other activity/ stimulation does your dog have in its day?

Also, do you know some other dog owners who you can walk with and who you can let your dog off the lead with their dogs so that yours will see how they behave?

I think my reply is longer than your question, sorry, but I see exactly where you're coming from.

megamaniac

1,057 posts

216 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
You could try a harness . I was sceptical, but it has worked for our beagle. We bought an ancol happy at heel .

Autopilot

1,298 posts

184 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
This is obviously a loaded question, but have you tried training her to walk to heel?

You have to use the right tools for the job and in my opinion harnesses are not the answer. A strong and wilful dog will pull through it anyway, probably even have more traction in fact!

Some dogs may respond to stopping each time they pull but this is obviously not working for you so time to change tact! Have you tried having some food (high value reward, not crappy biscuits or something) in your left hand where you want her head to be? When she walks where you want her to, say the heel command at the right time and she'll soon get it. Training like this will transfer to walks too! If she's not food orientated, get her favourite toy and put it under your arm.


Fugazi

564 posts

121 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
We have a 30kg Staffy cross too and had similar problems when walking. Although she would pull during a walk, it was her reaction to cats which we couldn't control. So the Dogs Trust helped us to work on her concentration and reinforcing behaviours etc, but the what really helped was using a head harness. She always wears a body harness on a walk and previously we'd attach a double ended lead to both the harness and collar, but using a head harness means we can steer her head away from things that cause reactions and means we have much more control over her behaviour, including pulling on the lead to dart after a smell or cat. Think of it like a horse harness and it really did work for us, the one Dogs Trust recommended Gentle Leader, it doesn't restrict their movement and Cindy can still drink, pant, eat and lick just as well wearing one so it isn't like a muzzle.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoVgd5AmZeQ

Fugazi

564 posts

121 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Autopilot said:
This is obviously a loaded question, but have you tried training her to walk to heel?

You have to use the right tools for the job and in my opinion harnesses are not the answer. A strong and wilful dog will pull through it anyway, probably even have more traction in fact!

Some dogs may respond to stopping each time they pull but this is obviously not working for you so time to change tact! Have you tried having some food (high value reward, not crappy biscuits or something) in your left hand where you want her head to be? When she walks where you want her to, say the heel command at the right time and she'll soon get it. Training like this will transfer to walks too! If she's not food orientated, get her favourite toy and put it under your arm.
We had hours and hours of behavioural training and if she sees a cat, she still goes nuts. Dangling toys in front of her, food, (even her all time favourite training treat of squeezy cheese)... Nothing worked and the best we can do is remove her focus from whatever has her attention and physically moving her head was the only way through a head halter. Once she looks at us and can see we are telling her off she will behave and we can carry on, being deaf she would have no idea unless she she's that we aren't happy with her behaviour. We've had her for a year and she is the same as when we first re-homed her, I just have a stronger right arm now and can spot cats in the dark at 500 yards.

Jasandjules

69,885 posts

229 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
You could also look into a balance leash. Works for many people, and one of my boys at 55kg or so walks nicely like this.

scdan4

1,299 posts

160 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
She needs to run - On lead only is probably a large part of the problem.

Ours goes a bit nuts if she only has on lead walks and ends up quite unmanageable if she hasn't had a run for a while, displaying many of the same symptoms. (Best way I can describe it is she is wired and really really excited.)

What solved it greatly for us was finding her a best friend (a mates collie as it happens) who she could run around with - expending many multiples of the energy whilst doing it. And she ran and ran and ran. Two 8 mile walks with her friend a week and she was a different dog.

Find her somewhere she can run until she's had enough, ideally with a playmate. She'll be far happier to come back then. Use it to get her recall good as well.

Head/nose harnesses (the lightweight ones) stopped ours pulling on the way to the park, but she really hated them.

Does your local dog walker do "playdates?" That'll wear her out.

HTP99

22,546 posts

140 months

Saturday 19th July 2014
quotequote all
Fugazi said:
Autopilot said:
This is obviously a loaded question, but have you tried training her to walk to heel?

You have to use the right tools for the job and in my opinion harnesses are not the answer. A strong and wilful dog will pull through it anyway, probably even have more traction in fact!

Some dogs may respond to stopping each time they pull but this is obviously not working for you so time to change tact! Have you tried having some food (high value reward, not crappy biscuits or something) in your left hand where you want her head to be? When she walks where you want her to, say the heel command at the right time and she'll soon get it. Training like this will transfer to walks too! If she's not food orientated, get her favourite toy and put it under your arm.
We had hours and hours of behavioural training and if she sees a cat, she still goes nuts. Dangling toys in front of her, food, (even her all time favourite training treat of squeezy cheese)... Nothing worked and the best we can do is remove her focus from whatever has her attention and physically moving her head was the only way through a head halter. Once she looks at us and can see we are telling her off she will behave and we can carry on, being deaf she would have no idea unless she she's that we aren't happy with her behaviour. We've had her for a year and she is the same as when we first re-homed her, I just have a stronger right arm now and can spot cats in the dark at 500 yards.
We rehomed a deaf French bulldog in November last year who is well behaved in the house; a quick swipe of the arm in the direction that you want her to go and she will obey however as soon as she is outside she isn't interested. In the garden isn't a massive issue as it is enclosed however sometimes I have to actually go out restrain her and and carry her in as she just ignores me.

Walking is and always has been a nightmare, she pulls non stop, if I pull her back to heel she will stay, if a walk a step or two and stop she will stop however anymore and that's it she pulls but it's not just pulling ahead, if she sees a cat or a fox, a bird, a car etc etc whether behind, infront, to the left or to the right she just pulls and nothing will stop her.

Since November I've tried so many different ways to stop her pulling:

  • stopping when she pulls and continuing when the lead goes slack
  • doing a 180 degree turn as soon as she starts pulling and carrying on in the opposite direction
  • when she pulls, stopping and walking backwards encouraging her to walk back to my heel and dropping a treat at my heel
  • holding a treat by my leg so she keep and eye on it and heels and rewarding her after a certain distance, the problem though is she is small so it kills my back and if she sees a car or a bird or a cat or a person they are far more interesting than her treat.
I've given up now and have resigned myself to walks being not very enjoyable as she just pulls.

solidlad84

Original Poster:

176 posts

187 months

Sunday 20th July 2014
quotequote all
Wow, didn't expect so many replies so fast!
Jasandjules - she was given to us as a half staffy half black lab. However due to some physical features and the fact she weighs about the same as a pure labrador its quite possible theres some other breed in there along the lines.

Apologies if I forget to reply to anyones questions.

She is fed on 'Butchers' dog food. I admit I have no idea what the 'best' food for them is, although i know the cheapo choices are obviously bad ideas and we wouldn't skimp on anything related to her, shes rather spoiled.

She gets around 90 minutes of brisk walking on a day where she is walked twice, if she is walked 3 times it will be around 2 hours of walking, plus with free access to the garden all day to sprint around with her toys.

Tintopracer - she is walked at almost random times each time - morning walk can vary between 5 and 8 am, evening walks can vary from 3 pm until 10. Even if she is in bed asleep in the middle of the night and I just jangle her lead she will go into full on 'manic' mode, whimpering and yelping and jumping up and down all over the place.

She is absolutely fine in the car - even from the first day we got her it always seemed like she had previous experience of car travel as she loves it. If I am walking her and nip to my car to get something out she will try and barge past me and jump in! just to sit there and look at me as if to say 'where are we going?!'

Finding another dog to walk her with off lead is possibly tricky - she is not aggressive at all to other dogs however unless meeting them in our house (which is something I am unsure of, due to possible territory disputes) as she currently will be far too manic and boisterous when she is outside to meet another dog without completely scaring them, this is the experience we've noticed so far when interacting with other dogs anyway. She will cry and wimper at the sight of a dog in the distance and pull towards them so hard to go and sniff their butt and say hello that the other dog must see this as an aggresive action and tends to react accordingly defensive, and that sets up how the whole encounter will be - one dog petrified of Ellie because of her 'entrance' towards the other dog and Ellie going mental and hyper because she gets to meet a new friend, not knowing that she is coming across as a bit scary. There is only one dog who is happy to see her - a german shepherd who walks locally to us. Problem is he has serious hip and leg problems so they could never play off lead together.

When she is walking on the lead absolutely nothing gets her to pay attention to you. Steak, chicken, her favourite ham, nothing, her favourite toys are even less effecive than food. Often she has actually took a treat off me and put it in her mouth and then something else grabbed her attention back and she literally drops it on the floor and begins to pull again before shes even eaten it.

Tried all the usual tricks like stopping each time she pulls, turning in a random direction, making her heel every time she pulls. Its like she knows what we want her to do but is too stubborn to actually do it. We have even tried putting her lead on in the house so she gets used to just wearing it and not associating it with walks - all this achieved was her charging around the house full pelt for hours at a time, which wasnt so fun once the novelty had worn off lol.7

Scdan4 - I agree that her being on the lead is part of the problem. However until we are 100% sure she will come back to us off lead it is a scary thought letting her off as she would be out of sight in seconds and a long way away. We have however let her run around in the garden playing games until she is that tired she is panting excessively before taking her out for a walk - this didn't do much other than make her even more hyped up about going on walkies.

Thanks for the suggestions so far anyway guys - she currently has a full body harness as her pulling is so bad anything near her neck makes her choke as she walks, we know the body harness allows her to pull more strongly but until now didn't know of any alternatives. Will have a look into the head and nose harness. Until then all I can think of is to get her to play for a while fetch while in a confined area like some tennis courts, then when shes knackered see how she behaves on a walk then.

solidlad84

Original Poster:

176 posts

187 months

Sunday 20th July 2014
quotequote all
Ps - a few pics of her here for your viewing.

This is a pic of her on the first day we picked her up, she was approximately 18 months old at the time and weighed 19-20 kg, she was about 5 KG underweight and her coat and the pads of her paws were in a pretty bad way which improved a lot after a few weeks of proper nutrition and care.

https://imageshack.com/i/pa3746c6j

Working out her new surroundings on the first day

https://imageshack.com/i/paaa7b02j


Already in love with the family even after an hour of being home smile

https://imageshack.com/i/ex3464d0j

Trying out her bed, which she very quickly outgrew!

https://imageshack.com/i/iq8c770aj

Trying out her 'doggy bath' thinking she wouldn't like our human one. Turns out she thinks this is just a nice chair for her and she loves our human bath smile

https://imageshack.com/i/eyacc276j

She put on just over 10 kgs from the age of 18 months to approaching 3 years old now.

This is how she currently looks: (yes we did train her to stay in the shaded corner on hot days - as you can see she has snuk forwards slowly so she can sunbathe!)

https://imageshack.com/i/ez83abeej

Cooling off in her 'window chair' (she actually has two of these chairs - she isn't allowed on the leather human chairs so we got her one where she can sit by the window to watch the world go by and also one nearer to where we sit when we are in the living room, spoiled thing.

https://imageshack.com/i/id8876a8j

https://imageshack.com/i/ipe0808dj

Here she is sulking because she was kicked out of the living room while we moved some furniture around:

https://imageshack.com/i/exb3b4a9j

Trying to attack the fox that escapes from our garden near the shed

https://imageshack.com/i/kp9512ffj

This 'trick' she decided to start doing herself! she acts as if she is a human sometimes

https://imageshack.com/i/ewc3e543j

Finally, a picture of her which probably sums her up best - a (albeit crappy quality) shot of her mid air about to pounce on a tennis ball like its actually alive.

https://imageshack.com/i/idab07b5p

Hope these pics work.




tintopracer

139 posts

167 months

Monday 21st July 2014
quotequote all
She looks adorable but also like she is a bundle of energy and activity.

I'm not sure if diet is relevant, but have you tried her with different foods? Just wondering if she's now up to ideal weight she's getting too much energy from her current diet?




solidlad84

Original Poster:

176 posts

187 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2014
quotequote all
Thanks tintop - she's a real character smile

Can't recall the names off the top of my head but this is the third different brand of food we have tried her with. She seems to like this the most and we only give her 2 meals a day as this seems to be the right amount for her to maintain weight without getting fat, she is apparently meant to be on 3 meals a day as a ballpark figure for her weight.

She obviously has some treats through the day but I really can't see her behavioural problems out of the house being diet related. Even if we put her lead on and let her out into the garden she will go completely mental spinning around and rolling everywhere. Just not sure how to deal with this one issue as other than that she really is the perfect dog! To all the people who initially think SBT crosses are all nasty dogs she has changed a lot of the people that she's encountered perspective on the breed. She also obviously gets people crossing the road with their dog to avoid her and other problems associated with this breed, like certain classes of people saying 'wow mate that's a big staffy' etc.

katec

6 posts

118 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2014
quotequote all
First of all - she's a beautiful dog. Looks really sweet.

Now - it isn't sounding like a problem with her food, I had exactly the same issue with my dog. He was a rescue too, and lived with a family that never walked him, as a result of this he was incredibly over-enthusiastic about walks.

When I first brought him home if I picked up his lead he would charge down the stairs at full pelt and start spinning in circles over and over again in front of me, then would try to run on the lead during the whole walk. He pulled so hard in the first few days that he managed to pull his collar off. After that incident (in which he pelted to the bottom of the street then decided to flop over and play dead like a bloody idiot) I tried a harness, but this just allowed him to put more of his strength into pulling without as much discomfort.

In the end I used a halter-lead type thing. It goes over his head and muzzle, and make it very easy to redirect his fixation and get him to heel. After a few days, walking became a lot easier. I was starting to feel a lot braver, so I got a long line (usually used for lunging a horse, so it's nice and long) and used it to give him more exercise on the fields.

We kept it up for about a week and he calmed right down. He still comes over and sits wagging his tail if you touch his lead, but there's not more ridiculous spinning or charging around and the walks themselves are much better.

Fugazi

564 posts

121 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2014
quotequote all
I forgot to mention that as we have a pretty big back garden I've taken to trying to get rid of her pent up energy before walks, but nope she could go all day in fact if she had her own way I would still be in the garden playing tug.
I think any dog with even a slight hint of staffy is going to be a handful laugh
Charging down the stairs at full pelt at any possible sign of a walk and the perennial 'argghh must lick your face and jump on your head' greeting when you get home, regardless of whether you've left the house for five hours or five seconds.

KFC

3,687 posts

130 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2014
quotequote all
solidlad84 said:
Thanks tintop - she's a real character smile

Can't recall the names off the top of my head but this is the third different brand of food we have tried her with. She seems to like this the most and we only give her 2 meals a day as this seems to be the right amount for her to maintain weight without getting fat, she is apparently meant to be on 3 meals a day as a ballpark figure for her weight.

She obviously has some treats through the day but I really can't see her behavioural problems out of the house being diet related. Even if we put her lead on and let her out into the garden she will go completely mental spinning around and rolling everywhere. Just not sure how to deal with this one issue as other than that she really is the perfect dog! To all the people who initially think SBT crosses are all nasty dogs she has changed a lot of the people that she's encountered perspective on the breed. She also obviously gets people crossing the road with their dog to avoid her and other problems associated with this breed, like certain classes of people saying 'wow mate that's a big staffy' etc.
My dogs seem generally better behaved when they're getting fed properly. I've noticed that when I don't have time to get to the shops or prepare proper food for them and need to get the emergency cans of dog food out... their behaviour gets worse.

If you have the time you could do something like I done here http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=10&... - it ends up working out way cheaper than giving them processed crap, and its got to be a lot better for them. I"m going to start doing this again but doing a months worth in one go.

FredClogs

14,041 posts

161 months

Tuesday 22nd July 2014
quotequote all
A lot of dogs have an indoor and an outdoor setting. I haven't read the other replies so i may be stating the obvious but sounds like she just needs a bit of training on and off the lead, if this is the first dog you've owned more likely you need a bit of training too. A couple of times a week with a local dog trainer and then a weekly class with other dogs for a while will be the best few hundred quid you ever spend, do it now before any behaviours become too ingrained or something unpleasant happens.

tintopracer

139 posts

167 months

Friday 1st August 2014
quotequote all
OP how are you getting on?

After re-reading the thread I took my dog for his usual walk at a local riding club. Met up with some other dog owners who I've known for a long time. Thought it was a good opportunity to let my dog off his lead. 15 mins of great play with the other dogs for him followed by half an hour of searching when in a split second he disappeared into woods and only reappeared later filthy and smelly from a pond he'd found.

I'm back to a long lead or using the horses lunge line.

vinnie01

863 posts

119 months

Friday 1st August 2014
quotequote all
we learnt with our dog that the higher protein foods were making him Hyperactive. Tbh unless the dog is being worked most foods have too much in it for them