Top Gear Style Challenge...but which vehicle!

Top Gear Style Challenge...but which vehicle!

Poll: Top Gear Style Challenge...but which vehicle!

Total Members Polled: 53

Boring Car - steady and safe: 11%
Fun Car - Have a bit of a giggle: 89%
Author
Discussion

CDP

7,460 posts

255 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
If you're going to have a pointless race for the fun of it why would you want to do it in anything less than a car that's pointless but for the fun of it?

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
CDP said:
If you're going to have a pointless race for the fun of it why would you want to do it in anything less than a car that's pointless but for the fun of it?
Man logic I like biggrin

There is a minor point and that is the losers pay for the previous nights dinner - I will make sure I dine like a king! biggrin

durbster

10,284 posts

223 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
tenohfive said:
Sounds like a bit of a naff idea of 'fun.'

You: sit on motorways for 7 hours.
Kids: sit on public transport for 7 hours.
Don't know how old the kids are but regardless, independent travel experience is never a bad thing and always has the potential for an anecdote or two.

They can track each other with GPS on phones now so that'll make it interesting, and whatever way you look at it, it's significantly more fun than all of them being in the same car on motorways for seven hours.

miln0039

2,013 posts

159 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
Brilliant. When's the big day (just give us a month if you don't want to be too specific!!)?

Also - route planning back from the tunnel is very important...can be a nightmare using the coastal route, especially on a Sunday when every Doris is out!!

Definitely the Cerb though smile A fast German exec would do the job just as easily, but it would feel like a bit of a non-event!

tenohfive

6,276 posts

183 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
Mark. said:
She will have been in Amsterdam for the week and I fancy going somewhere different for dinner one evening.
Well if dinners your priority then I'll be contrary and says it's got to be the safe sensible car choice, unless a Maccy D's in the M3 services whilst you wait for the AA to arrive is your idea of a) haute cuisine or b) somewhere different. With most of the miles being on motorways I'd say comfort and reliability wins.

But if your priority is winning family brownie points, letting your daughter take the Cerbera whilst you sit on planes and trains etc is the clear winner. With the daughter anyway - probably less so your wife.


Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
miln0039 said:
Brilliant. When's the big day (just give us a month if you don't want to be too specific!!)?

Also - route planning back from the tunnel is very important...can be a nightmare using the coastal route, especially on a Sunday when every Doris is out!!

Definitely the Cerb though smile A fast German exec would do the job just as easily, but it would feel like a bit of a non-event!
I think they are out there in April, so it'll happen in the next few weeks if I've not had an naff-attack and decided not to bother.

I did the coast route from the tunnel to Hayling once, I'll never do it again. would rather the extended tedium of motorways than negotiate that route again.

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
tenohfive said:
unless a Maccy D's in the M3 services whilst you wait for the AA to arrive ... I'd say comfort and reliability wins.
hehe Long shot here but I guess this refers to my choice of fun vehicle? If it's proper haute cusine I'm after I'd take a KFC any day.

I will confess to not feeling overtly smug last weekend as I passed a Porsche being recovered on a flatbed for fear of the inevitable happening and the Cerbra self destructing in an attempt to get on the back of the same flatbed and giving the 99x one up the twin exhaust.

LuS1fer

41,137 posts

246 months

Tuesday 19th March 2013
quotequote all
Caterham....

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Sunday 14th April 2013
quotequote all
Well for those who care...

The car won, by almost an hour.

However, different set of circumstances it could all have been different. Our train left early, the flight was delayed etc.
If everything ran to time table I think there would genuinely be 5 mins in it - either way.

miln0039

2,013 posts

159 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Mark. said:
Well for those who care...

The car won, by almost an hour.

However, different set of circumstances it could all have been different. Our train left early, the flight was delayed etc.
If everything ran to time table I think there would genuinely be 5 mins in it - either way.
Many congratulations - you used the TVR right?

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Afraid not. Decided to take the tin top as it meant no need to stop for fuel. Also weather was really rough Friday morning and driving the TVR in that would have been plain madness - it was bad enough it the Audi.


extraT

1,764 posts

151 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
LuS1fer said:
Caterham....
^^^^^^^^^This If luggage isn't a problem, or you are happy to buy yourself a new wardrobe....

Also, get your wife and daughter to sign up to PH to post 'live' updates!!! Along with youtube videos etc...!!!!

miln0039

2,013 posts

159 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Mark. said:
Afraid not. Decided to take the tin top as it meant no need to stop for fuel. Also weather was really rough Friday morning and driving the TVR in that would have been plain madness - it was bad enough it the Audi.
Not a true victory then wink

SimonMaidenhead

2,582 posts

204 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Good job your daughter played by the rules, I'd have changed flights and flown into Southampton smile

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
SimonMaidenhead said:
Good job your daughter played by the rules, I'd have changed flights and flown into Southampton smile
hehe

I don't let her go there unaccompanied.

DJRC

23,563 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Mark. said:
SimonMaidenhead said:
Good job your daughter played by the rules, I'd have changed flights and flown into Southampton smile
hehe

I don't let her go there unaccompanied.
From Hayling??????????Every time I crossed Langstone Bridge it felt a bit bridge of Doomy smile Still I do miss a summer's evening at The Ship out by bridge. Good pub.

Mark.

Original Poster:

11,104 posts

277 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
DJRC said:
From Hayling??????????Every time I crossed Langstone Bridge it felt a bit bridge of Doomy smile Still I do miss a summer's evening at The Ship out by bridge. Good pub.
Royal Oak is better still.

Not sure how long since you visited, but Hayling is very quiet, they even closed the police station.

DJRC

23,563 posts

237 months

Monday 15th April 2013
quotequote all
Mark. said:
DJRC said:
From Hayling??????????Every time I crossed Langstone Bridge it felt a bit bridge of Doomy smile Still I do miss a summer's evening at The Ship out by bridge. Good pub.
Royal Oak is better still.

Not sure how long since you visited, but Hayling is very quiet, they even closed the police station.
Cpl of yrs. I have managed to escape the need to visit Pompey these days smile Spent a yr or so checking into the Langstone at least once a week for a cpl of days.