Can I use my cycle helmet as a ski helmet?

Can I use my cycle helmet as a ski helmet?

Author
Discussion

thewhangie

Original Poster:

237 posts

163 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Just about to go skiing. I do a lot of cycling as well. They certainly look different. Are the interchangeable?

philv

3,920 posts

214 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
After what happened to shumacher, why would you use anything other than the very best?

plus5dB

985 posts

147 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
One is designed to protect your head when you fall against hard ground, rocks and trees. The other is designed to protect your head from cold, hard ground, rocks and trees. As long as your helmet provides suitable protection then it's all just fashion and practicalities that determine the shape.

If you do a lot of cycling then I assume you aren't using a cheapy helmet that will disintegrate too easily.

ViperDave

5,529 posts

253 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
I've read that they are made from the same materials and construction, but some things to consider are cycle helmets tend to be designed to keep you cool where as ski helmets to keep you warm with ear pads and less vents. Also I'm no cyclist but cycle helmets look like they sit more on top of your head where as ski helmets cover more around the back offering better protection from falling backwards.

Not sure how well a cycle helmet will work with goggles either.

For the price of a lift ticket get yourself the proper safety gear, the cycle helmet is not going to be any good because its in the car due to it being cold and snowing so you want the warmth from your beanie, plus you can guarantee wearing a cycle helmet will make you stand out on the slope, like the guy in jeans and lumberjack shirt

astroarcadia

1,710 posts

200 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
On the flip side- I've been mountain biking in my ski helmet. Vents open and ears were nice and warm.

Cycle helmet on the slopes is certainly a rascal look!

eggchaser1987

1,608 posts

149 months

Saturday 1st March 2014
quotequote all
Not that I know the answer but would it make a difference to what type of cycling helmet ie, piss pot bmx type, road, full face dh etc?

anonymous-user

54 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
My daughters snow board helmet has removable insulation to allow it to be used as a roller board helmet in summer. Of course they are made of the same thing, Polystyrene with a hard plastic shell. You'll be cold mind.

PhillT

2,488 posts

225 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Echoing comment above.

Depends on the type of cycle helmet you have. If it's the perch-on-the-top-of-your head, open-grilled type, then no, get a ski helmet.


If it's the more BMX-style helmet with the back of your head covered, then that would be better.


Personally, I'd just rent a proper ski helmet to be on the safe side. More comfortable and warm too.

CrutyRammers

13,735 posts

198 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
No, not really OP. I use one of the BMX types for freestyle at the snowdome, but on a mountain you'll need something warmer - you'd need a balaclava as well, and your goggles won't fit. Get a proper one, or skip it and just wear a hat.

dtmpower

3,972 posts

245 months

Monday 15th September 2014
quotequote all
There is more than one standard of winter sports helmet:

http://snowheads.com/ski-forum/viewtopic.php?t=960...

Amateurish

7,734 posts

222 months

Monday 15th September 2014
quotequote all
brucerussell said:
No, helmets are designed according to their use. So if you see cycle helmets are designed in a different way than the skiing helmets. So I would suggest you to go for the helmets accordingly. I always make sure that when I am going for skiing I have perfect ski clothing of good quality which is comfortable and fit for doing skiing. You can check some amazing skiing clothing and accessories at http://www.twinner-alpedhuez-berger.fr/ .
Spam?

LDM

372 posts

127 months

Monday 15th September 2014
quotequote all
If you are hiring equipment in the resort (ski's boots) then often a helmet can be added at little or no extra cost.

In all honesty most people skied without a helmet for many years and I suspect a cycle helmet would cover most aspects but I would rather have a proper ski / snowboard helmet for such winter sports.

Maybe I would be just worried about people pointing at me for wearing a cycle helmet?

//j17

4,477 posts

223 months

Monday 15th September 2014
quotequote all
philv said:
After what happened to shumacher, why would you use anything other than the very best?
What, the Mr Schumacher who was wearing a ski helmet when he had his accident...? Didn't seem to help him much.

sneijder

5,221 posts

234 months

Saturday 20th September 2014
quotequote all
I think cycle helmets are designed to channel air flow IN ? That's the last thing you want, if you fall they'll get full of snow too.

Folk wear padded shorts and back protectors as they often fall flat on their arse / flat on their back. I've slammed the back of my head, does the cycle helmet protect that area ?

Concussion is really horrible, you have to live with your brain not working 100% and being fully aware and waiting for it all to come back 'on line'.

As mentioned, for the rental price it's really a 'no brainer' (joke slightly intended)

ViperDave

5,529 posts

253 months

Saturday 20th September 2014
quotequote all
sneijder said:
I think cycle helmets are designed to channel air flow IN ? That's the last thing you want, if you fall they'll get full of snow too.

Folk wear padded shorts and back protectors as they often fall flat on their arse / flat on their back. I've slammed the back of my head, does the cycle helmet protect that area ?

Concussion is really horrible, you have to live with your brain not working 100% and being fully aware and waiting for it all to come back 'on line'.

As mentioned, for the rental price it's really a 'no brainer' (joke slightly intended)
Totally agree that a ski helmet will protect the back of your head better and that is exacty the reason i had to buy a new one last year.

Not sure how comfortable i would be using a rental when most of them are single impact and discard construction, maybe the rentals are more durable but IDK and given you can pick up a basic one for less than a one day lift ticket and nobody said skiing was cheap, i'd have thought you'd be better off buying your own and knowing its history.

Ps as this is a really old thread i wonder how the OP got on skiing in his cycle helmet, maybe he is still in hospital as he never came back to the thread

Nezquick

1,461 posts

126 months

Sunday 21st September 2014
quotequote all
//j17 said:
What, the Mr Schumacher who was wearing a ski helmet when he had his accident...? Didn't seem to help him much.
Err, he isn't dead so I guess it helped a bit.

Gareth79

7,661 posts

246 months

Sunday 21st September 2014
quotequote all
An old thread of course, but I would say definitely no - ski helmets seem to be made much stronger than cycle helmets and I think in a ski fall a cycle helmet would be broken apart quite quickly.

Also I think *buying* a ski helmet off Amazon or similar would probably work out the same cost as renting (£30ish), and really I wouldn't want to wear a rental helmet :/


castex

4,936 posts

273 months

Sunday 21st September 2014
quotequote all
Yes you can, although I've never worried about any of that.