Playful slaps with OH - Is it on?

Playful slaps with OH - Is it on?

Author
Discussion

StuntmanMike

11,671 posts

151 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
NateWM said:
Thanks all. This has actually happened twice before, with the last time being at my Dads birthday gathering in the summer. In fairness it had much less force to it, however I was still deeply embarrassed so I brought it up with her in the morning. She was very apologetic and seemed to see how much it irked me, and I thought that was that...obviously not!

I'll be heading home soon and having a good think tomorrow. It's just tough as she really is amazing and I love her to pieces, but I've been wondering if I should just finish, as she's really been testing me lately. I'm only 22 so feel like I shouldn't be having the stress that she causes me sometimes! I'm just very conflicted at the moment so will think about it more when I have a clear head!

Anymore comments are welcome. Thanks again btw. smile
Right, so this isn't your wife of 20 years or anything, I would be having a long hard think about my future, you are 22 and in a serious relationship, is this what you want? in what way is she testing you? TBH Nate, you come across like someone who is having second thoughts by the tone of your posts, you have got something right though, your 22 and shouldn't be having this amount of stress, I think you should do as your Quoted post says, I also think you post a picture of her, for the P.H massive, you know.;)

Rick101

6,969 posts

150 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
My mrs did this to me. I returned the favour, not hard, just similar to what she has just done.
Her reaction, ow, that really hurts.
Yes, I know, stop fking doing it to me then stupidarse.

If this were the other way round there would no doubt be calls of what a pig he is, ring police immediately, get him out the house, take the kids away because they could be hurt too. Sad thing is Police would happily go along with it if it was man on woman. Sadly stories I've heard of blokes reporting violence is just being laughed out of the station.

StuntmanMike

11,671 posts

151 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Rick101 said:
My mrs did this to me. I returned the favour, not hard, just similar to what she has just done.
Her reaction, ow, that really hurts.
Yes, I know, stop fking doing it to me then stupidarse.

If this were the other way round there would no doubt be calls of what a pig he is, ring police immediately, get him out the house, take the kids away because they could be hurt too. Sad thing is Police would happily go along with it if it was man on woman. Sadly stories I've heard of blokes reporting violence is just being laughed out of the station.
Imagine this thread the otherway around on mumsnet......eek

NateWM

Original Poster:

1,684 posts

179 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Morning fellas.

Many thanks for all of the replays, it has given me lots to think about. I arrived last night to her being very apologetic, crying etc - the works. I listened to what she had to say, but mainly just went to bed and would rather discuss it when she wakes up. For those of you asking, yes I am having second thoughts. She has been incredibly testing this last 8-12 months, and considering it's not really something I should put up with, I am considering calling it off. Overall though I'm very conflicted, as I really do adore her and she isn't a bad person or anything like that, just has these couple annoying quirks that can really test your patience. And to answer the above, yes I do prefer an actual relationship, and yes we do live together however it's my house and I pay for it, so I wouldn't have any issues slinging her out. Oh and just to add, no I would never hit her or slap her back...pretty sure most of the replays suggesting such were joking anyway. hehe

So that's me, a very conflicted fella wondering what to do about her. I must admit, I'm swaying towards the "sponge punch and fling out the door" option. wink

Jasandjules

69,884 posts

229 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
OP is this you?


However, I don't think a slap across the face is playful myself.

I'd tell her to stop it. If she doesn't, find someone else who doesn't think hitting you is fine.

As others have said, if you did this to her, do you think you'd not be under arrest right now?!

DougMcC

769 posts

163 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
I have had this with a relationship in the past. It is very difficult for a man to admit to other men, or even women, that they have been hit in a relationship.

Put simply it isn't on, if you feel uncomfortable with it it doesn't matter if every other bloke in the world disagrees with you or tells you to man up, they aren't the ones getting a slap round the face.

It is best if it is nipped in the bud now, because it could escalate into more than a slap round the face. Hopefully she will realise that it has upset you and will stop it.


Asterix

24,438 posts

228 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
DougMcC said:
I have had this with a relationship in the past. It is very difficult for a man to admit to other men, or even women, that they have been hit in a relationship.

Put simply it isn't on, if you feel uncomfortable with it it doesn't matter if every other bloke in the world disagrees with you or tells you to man up, they aren't the ones getting a slap round the face.

It is best if it is nipped in the bud now, because it could escalate into more than a slap round the face. Hopefully she will realise that it has upset you and will stop it.
I've heard DV to men, both physical and psychological, is far more widespread than reported for the above reasons - men are far less likely to admit it happens to them.

Disastrous

10,081 posts

217 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
MrBig said:
Slap her round the tits. Preferably when naked. On video. Then post it here.
You are so funny!

How do you come up with such witty material?

OP, she sounds st. Sorry to say it but obviously you can't hit her back (unless she's got a knife) but you can chuck her out.

red_slr

17,227 posts

189 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Had she had a drink?

kiseca

9,339 posts

219 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Why does she do it? If she knows you don't like it then it's either something she really wants to do for some reason... either she just likes being dominant or she's secretly really pissed off with you all the time and is holding back the proper thump she really wants to give you, or she's just winding you up because she knows you don't like it.

If you don't like it it's not on of course but she has to know how much you really don't like it and that it's damaging the mood in the house or whatever. But whatever, it might still help to actually ask her why she's doing it and have a friendly two sided conversation about stopping rather than an argument.

EDIT: Dumb question... if it just started out of the blue at some point... would she benefit in any way from having you done on assault charges? Any exes in her history that have been done?

Edited by kiseca on Sunday 14th December 11:52

Biker's Nemesis

38,645 posts

208 months

Monkeylegend

26,377 posts

231 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
NateWM said:
Morning fellas.

Overall though I'm very conflicted,

Oh and just to add, no I would never hit her or slap her back...

I'm swaying towards the "sponge punch and fling out the door" option. wink
wink

Monkeylegend

26,377 posts

231 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
NateWM said:
Morning fellas.

and yes we do live together however it's my house and I pay for it,
I think we should have this quote as a sticky.

TwigtheWonderkid

43,346 posts

150 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Rick101 said:
Sadly stories I've heard of blokes reporting violence is just being laughed out of the station.
I doubt this would happen now. There are strict protocols the police have to follow in cases of reported DV, regardless of gender.

wolves_wanderer

12,385 posts

237 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
If you still want to be with her then explain with crystal clarity that you view slapping as domestic violence (which it is) and that any repeat will see her out.

Ari

19,347 posts

215 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
NateWM said:
Thanks all. This has actually happened twice before, with the last time being at my Dads birthday gathering in the summer. In fairness it had much less force to it, however I was still deeply embarrassed so I brought it up with her in the morning. She was very apologetic and seemed to see how much it irked me, and I thought that was that...obviously not!

I'll be heading home soon and having a good think tomorrow. It's just tough as she really is amazing and I love her to pieces, but I've been wondering if I should just finish, as she's really been testing me lately. I'm only 22 so feel like I shouldn't be having the stress that she causes me sometimes! I'm just very conflicted at the moment so will think about it more when I have a clear head!

Anymore comments are welcome. Thanks again btw. smile
She knows how much it irks you, she's been 'testing' you lately and now she's slapped you harder.

She wants out of the relationship but she wants you to be the ' bad guy' and finish it.

Jasandjules

69,884 posts

229 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Ari said:
She knows how much it irks you, she's been 'testing' you lately and now she's slapped you harder.

She wants out of the relationship but she wants you to be the ' bad guy' and finish it.
Or if you want to be REALLY cynical, she wants him to hit her back, then plod will be round and he will be out on his ear, whilst she gets the house he's paying for...

Asterix

24,438 posts

228 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Ari said:
She knows how much it irks you, she's been 'testing' you lately and now she's slapped you harder.

She wants out of the relationship but she wants you to be the ' bad guy' and finish it.
Or if you want to be REALLY cynical, she wants him to hit her back, then plod will be round and he will be out on his ear, whilst she gets the house he's paying for...
No - that would never ever cross her mind...

NRS

22,143 posts

201 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
StuntmanMike said:
Rick101 said:
My mrs did this to me. I returned the favour, not hard, just similar to what she has just done.
Her reaction, ow, that really hurts.
Yes, I know, stop fking doing it to me then stupidarse.

If this were the other way round there would no doubt be calls of what a pig he is, ring police immediately, get him out the house, take the kids away because they could be hurt too. Sad thing is Police would happily go along with it if it was man on woman. Sadly stories I've heard of blokes reporting violence is just being laughed out of the station.
Imagine this thread the otherway around on mumsnet......eek
They would have gone crazy at the person doing the hitting, regardless of sex. They see any type of violence as pretty much the worst crime. They tend to turn on their "own" if they admit to hitting their guy. For all the other craziness, they don't seem to care who it is regarding this issue.

wolves_wanderer

12,385 posts

237 months

Sunday 14th December 2014
quotequote all
Jasandjules said:
Or if you want to be REALLY cynical, she wants him to hit her back, then plod will be round and he will be out on his ear, whilst she gets the house he's paying for...
Ah, the PH alternative SWT universe raises its head again.