Complimentary/Alternative Medicine and Integrated Medicine

Complimentary/Alternative Medicine and Integrated Medicine

Author
Discussion

Bisonhead

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

190 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Evening All,

Just wondering what the PH hoardes thought of the above? CAM and IM are becoming huge in Australia, USA, Canada and are already very considerable in many eastern and European countries.

Mrs Bisonhead has left the NHS and gained a diploma in Integrated Medicine (combining the best of western and 'eastern' medicine and other methods or wisdom traditions) and is setting up a private practice.

One thing we have found is that any deviation from the NHS or conventional medicine is met with either hostility or harsh judgement. We have also found that a lot of people we know are interested in an alternative to what is on offer at the moment in the UK.

I am not going to defend myself or my wifes choices, we feel that the we have made a good (not right) choice.

What are your thoughts or experience on CAM or IM practices and what potential do you see in them?

davepoth

29,395 posts

200 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Bisonhead said:
Evening All,

What are your thoughts or experience on CAM or IM practices and what potential do you see in them?
The Placebo Effect is real.

Bisonhead

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

190 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
davepoth said:
Bisonhead said:
Evening All,

What are your thoughts or experience on CAM or IM practices and what potential do you see in them?
The Placebo Effect is real.
As I said, best of Western and the rest!

grumbledoak

31,545 posts

234 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Q. What do you call Alternative Medicine that is proven to work (better than placebo in double-blind trials)?
A. Medicine.

The_Doc

4,894 posts

221 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
Anything that she finds that works robustly in Level 1 trials, please let us know. The NHS could do with some new treatments

She can skip homeopathy

Disclaimer: 1)lots of treatments make people get better, lots of things get better on their own, the placebo effect means even the act of treating makes some people better
2) It's getting huge, or it's worth $2billion, or it's the fastest growing X in Y do not amount to Level 1 evidence

krunchkin

2,209 posts

142 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
There's plenty of mugs who can be parted from large wedges of cash for any number of combinations of quackery, placebo, and a friendly ear to their problems. Go for it - I'm sure there's loads of money to be made

krunchkin

2,209 posts

142 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I presume you will be offering "alternative" ways of treating broken limbs and serious life threatening diseases as well as the usual stock in trade lines of allergies, "intolerances", stress etc etc that this kind of bks tends to confine itself to? If you did that then there really would be serious cash to be made

mu0n

2,348 posts

134 months

Tuesday 23rd April 2013
quotequote all
I take a scientific approach. If it can be thoroughly tested and theory proved correct then I'd be behind it. If it is simply theory with nothing substantial to back it up then it's just snake oil to me.

Flibble

6,475 posts

182 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
krunchkin said:
I presume you will be offering "alternative" ways of treating broken limbs and serious life threatening diseases as well as the usual stock in trade lines of allergies, "intolerances", stress etc etc that this kind of bks tends to confine itself to? If you did that then there really would be serious cash to be made
That's because the sort of problems this kind of bks can "treat" are self-limiting issues that clear up on their own anyway. Anything that requires actual medicine and you're out of luck.

Obiwonkeyblokey

5,399 posts

241 months

Wednesday 24th April 2013
quotequote all
I mentioned on another thread that Ive seen suffering with arthritis for a number of years which at times is debilitating. Having taken various drugs and remedies I tried aAcupuncture in Feb this year and for me it seems to have worked very well.