Caravans: What's the Point?

Author
Discussion

prand

5,916 posts

197 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
skinnyman said:
...Now I know it will give him the freedom to go where he likes...
I've always wondered. Are there many people on here who have ended up wedged in one of those narrow Cornish lanes, or small medieval French town centre street after getting a bit lost en route? That would always be a worry to me.

Caravanning appeals, certainly more than campervanning as you can unhook, leave the caravan at the campsite and go exploring by car. The most extravagant "tender" transport I've seen was a Winnebago towing a Range Rover Sport into Hurley campsite, I always wondered how big the old feller's pension lump sum was to afford that setup!

Rosscow

8,774 posts

164 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
prand said:
skinnyman said:
...Now I know it will give him the freedom to go where he likes...
I've always wondered. Are there many people on here who have ended up wedged in one of those narrow Cornish lanes, or small medieval French town centre street after getting a bit lost en route? That would always be a worry to me.

Caravanning appeals, certainly more than campervanning as you can unhook, leave the caravan at the campsite and go exploring by car. The most extravagant "tender" transport I've seen was a Winnebago towing a Range Rover Sport into Hurley campsite, I always wondered how big the old feller's pension lump sum was to afford that setup!
No, never happened to me. I've been down some tight Cornish roads (you have to to get to the Slapton Sands C & CC site!) but all was well.

Tend to plan the routes in France before I go and know where I'm headed beforehand.

prand

5,916 posts

197 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Rosscow said:
No, never happened to me. I've been down some tight Cornish roads (you have to to get to the Slapton Sands C & CC site!) but all was well.

Tend to plan the routes in France before I go and know where I'm headed beforehand.
Underlines the importance of plotting a good course to avoid hazards before getting underway I imagine!

Rosscow

8,774 posts

164 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
prand said:
Underlines the importance of plotting a good course to avoid hazards before getting underway I imagine!
Yeah. There's no excuse these days - work out where you're going, have a look on Google Maps for any tight looking spots and you can go into Streetview and assess for yourself.

Mind you, the A379 had some very tight spots, but you just had to go for it and hope you didn't meet a bus!!

https://www.google.co.uk/maps/@50.2732707,-3.69073...

Antony Moxey

8,087 posts

220 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Rosscow said:
prand said:
skinnyman said:
...Now I know it will give him the freedom to go where he likes...
I've always wondered. Are there many people on here who have ended up wedged in one of those narrow Cornish lanes, or small medieval French town centre street after getting a bit lost en route? That would always be a worry to me.

Caravanning appeals, certainly more than campervanning as you can unhook, leave the caravan at the campsite and go exploring by car. The most extravagant "tender" transport I've seen was a Winnebago towing a Range Rover Sport into Hurley campsite, I always wondered how big the old feller's pension lump sum was to afford that setup!
No, never happened to me. I've been down some tight Cornish roads (you have to to get to the Slapton Sands C & CC site!) but all was well.

Tend to plan the routes in France before I go and know where I'm headed beforehand.
If you're going to Slapton Sands you don't need to go anywhere near Cornwall. Seems you need to plan your routes in England before you go too...:-D

chrisga

2,090 posts

188 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Unless he lives in Cornwall, then he might need to go down tight Cornish roads wherever he's going...

Trabi601

4,865 posts

96 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
crankedup said:
This time a serious reply to the op, as opposed to my earlier bad taste quip.

I enjoy my vintage caravan and tow it with my vintage car. It's a bit slow so I keep a careful eye on my mirror. Most weekends I am attending steam rallies and country shows. Display my outfit during the day and then turn it into my accomadation for evening.
When the show closes to the public I can cook my evening meal and open a bottle of wine, no driving duties for me at this point. Then off to the marquee to enjoy the entertainment, usually live local band, and enjoy some beers with old friends and meet new.
Hotels? boring and staid imo but sometimes I have to comply !

Edited by crankedup on Wednesday 30th March 19:46
Just catching up on this as I'm looking at basic campervan at the moment and had looked at some micro caravan things, too.

But this caught my eye as it sounds like hell in knitwear.

Edited by Trabi601 on Tuesday 4th October 20:49

mikal83

5,340 posts

253 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Antony Moxey said:
Rosscow said:
prand said:
skinnyman said:
...Now I know it will give him the freedom to go where he likes...
I've always wondered. Are there many people on here who have ended up wedged in one of those narrow Cornish lanes, or small medieval French town centre street after getting a bit lost en route? That would always be a worry to me.

Caravanning appeals, certainly more than campervanning as you can unhook, leave the caravan at the campsite and go exploring by car. The most extravagant "tender" transport I've seen was a Winnebago towing a Range Rover Sport into Hurley campsite, I always wondered how big the old feller's pension lump sum was to afford that setup!
No, never happened to me. I've been down some tight Cornish roads (you have to to get to the Slapton Sands C & CC site!) but all was well.

Tend to plan the routes in France before I go and know where I'm headed beforehand.
If you're going to Slapton Sands you don't need to go anywhere near Cornwall. Seems you need to plan your routes in England before you go too...:-D
Ah Pistonheads, always one!

Rosscow

8,774 posts

164 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Haha, you're right! You don't need to go to Cornwall to get to Slapton Sands!

However, we went to Cornwall after Slapton Sands!!

foxsasha

1,417 posts

136 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
We have a motorhome that we use for work, racing and the occasional break away with the kids. If you don't have to tow a trailer then a caravan is the better option for multiple reasons. It's inane to tow a car behind a motorhome, why would you do that when you can tow a (much cheaper to buy and next to zero cost to maintain) caravan behind a car? I just can't understand that. The only time a motorhome makes sense is if you are going from location to location or if it's small enough to take into town centres and the like.

Antony Moxey

8,087 posts

220 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
foxsasha said:
We have a motorhome that we use for work, racing and the occasional break away with the kids. If you don't have to tow a trailer then a caravan is the better option for multiple reasons. It's inane to tow a car behind a motorhome, why would you do that when you can tow a (much cheaper to buy and next to zero cost to maintain) caravan behind a car? I just can't understand that. The only time a motorhome makes sense is if you are going from location to location or if it's small enough to take into town centres and the like.
Disagree. A motorhome's easier to navigate than a car and caravan, easier to reverse if need be, has better driving visibility and, I might suggest, easier to set up when you get to site. Of course it suffers the obvious disadvantage of once you get to site you're effectively stuck there unless you want to pack everything up before going off for the day,and that a car without a caravan behind it is easier to pilot than a motorhome but I don't think it's quite so simple as your 'the only time a motorhome makes sense' comment.

foxsasha

1,417 posts

136 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
Antony Moxey said:
Disagree. A motorhome's easier to navigate than a car and caravan, easier to reverse if need be, has better driving visibility and, I might suggest, easier to set up when you get to site. Of course it suffers the obvious disadvantage of once you get to site you're effectively stuck there unless you want to pack everything up before going off for the day,and that a car without a caravan behind it is easier to pilot than a motorhome but I don't think it's quite so simple as your 'the only time a motorhome makes sense' comment.
I've never had any particular issue manoeuvring a 7m motorhome with a 6m trailer so don't see why a car and caravan would pose a problem assuming you are going from A to B and then back to A. Setting up a motorhome of that size is similar to a caravan, the only differences being that you need to reverse and unhook the caravan and plumb water and waste but theyre not a major task. You still have to wind the supporting legs down, plug in electric, take covers off fridge vents etc with a larger motorhome. And if you are dragging a car then you've got the agro of unconnecting that, removing the A frame and the like before you can park the motorhome.

Why would you choose a motorhome over a caravan to go from A, spend a week at B then go back to A, assuming a family sized van/mhome and that you'll be out and about through the week and not just stay on site?

I've not towed a caravan but don't you fit those big ear mirrors to provide visability?

Rosscow

8,774 posts

164 months

Tuesday 4th October 2016
quotequote all
I agree with Foxsasha!

No way I'd swap my caravan for a motor home.


surveyor

17,843 posts

185 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
Rosscow said:
I agree with Foxsasha!

No way I'd swap my caravan for a motor home.
+ 1

berlintaxi

8,535 posts

174 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
foxsasha said:
You still have to wind the supporting legs down, plug in electric, take covers off fridge vents etc with a larger motorhome. And if you are dragging a car then you've got the agro of unconnecting that, removing the A frame and the like before you can park the motorhome.
Well that must take all of 2 minutes of your life.

Deerfoot

4,902 posts

185 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
surveyor said:
Rosscow said:
I agree with Foxsasha!

No way I'd swap my caravan for a motor home.
+ 1
Have another...+3

foxsasha

1,417 posts

136 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
berlintaxi said:
Well that must take all of 2 minutes of your life.
Well, yes, precisely. And just two more to park and plumb a caravan.

Spuffington

1,206 posts

169 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
Well just to add some balance - I can't see the point of caravans and more than happy with our motorhome. Can't imagine ever having anything other than a motorhome. But then again we enjoy touring and not staying too long in one place, wild camping and the lack of faff.

chrisga

2,090 posts

188 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
Just curious, but is "wild camping" in a campervan putting the kettle on in a lay-by?

Spuffington

1,206 posts

169 months

Wednesday 5th October 2016
quotequote all
chrisga said:
Just curious, but is "wild camping" in a campervan putting the kettle on in a lay-by?
No - sleeping wherever takes our fancy. Here, for example....