RE: PH fleet: Golf GTI Edition 35

RE: PH fleet: Golf GTI Edition 35

Author
Discussion

thewheelman

2,194 posts

174 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Riggers said:
thewheelman said:
Anyone else notice the "handles like a Golf" while showing a RWD 1 series on that advert?
Thought the 1 series was RWD....?
Yes, it is, the point being that in the advert they claim it handles "like a Golf", when clearly the handling characteristics of fwd & rwd are quite different.

mackie1

8,153 posts

234 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
I bought my Octavia vRS for a little over half that money. Ok so you don't get *quite* as nice an interior but you get the same running gear, more space, more equipment as standard. Depends what you want I guess but I was after something with much better fuel consumption than my old car and something practical I can put the mountain bike in the back of, but still quick. I nearly went for a Spec-B Legacy but the fuel economy was nearly as bad as the Monaro.

P I Staker

3,308 posts

157 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
thewheelman said:
Riggers said:
thewheelman said:
Anyone else notice the "handles like a Golf" while showing a RWD 1 series on that advert?
Thought the 1 series was RWD....?
Yes, it is, the point being that in the advert they claim it handles "like a Golf", when clearly the handling characteristics of fwd & rwd are quite different.
But thats not what they said about it, it shows the BMW then cuts to an interior shot of a Civic and he says "Like a Golf". smile

thewheelman

2,194 posts

174 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
P I Staker said:
thewheelman said:
Riggers said:
thewheelman said:
Anyone else notice the "handles like a Golf" while showing a RWD 1 series on that advert?
Thought the 1 series was RWD....?
Yes, it is, the point being that in the advert they claim it handles "like a Golf", when clearly the handling characteristics of fwd & rwd are quite different.
But thats not what they said about it, it shows the BMW then cuts to an interior shot of a Civic and he says "Like a Golf". smile
No, it does say it handles "like a Golf" while spinning the rear wheels of a 1 series. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omAwEPbHmV0

P I Staker

3,308 posts

157 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
thewheelman said:
No, it does say it handles "like a Golf" while spinning the rear wheels of a 1 series. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omAwEPbHmV0



Hes in a Honda Civic.



ETA: Enough of this, back on topic.

re33

270 posts

165 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Its a golf, definitely whatcar hot hatch of the year. Definitely not for me.

Riggers

1,859 posts

179 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
thewheelman said:
Riggers said:
thewheelman said:
Anyone else notice the "handles like a Golf" while showing a RWD 1 series on that advert?
Thought the 1 series was RWD....?
Yes, it is, the point being that in the advert they claim it handles "like a Golf", when clearly the handling characteristics of fwd & rwd are quite different.
PH joke fail! paperbag

Meant to write 'I thought the 1-series was FWD...?'

Oh dear oh dear ho dear oh dear....

re33

270 posts

165 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Its a golf, definitely whatcar hot hatch of the year. Definitely not for me.

5lab

1,666 posts

197 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
the in car shot is the civic but the external one is a 1 series.

richard300

1,085 posts

210 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
mackie1 said:
I bought my Octavia vRS for a little over half that money. Ok so you don't get *quite* as nice an interior but you get the same running gear, more space, more equipment as standard. Depends what you want I guess but I was after something with much better fuel consumption than my old car and something practical I can put the mountain bike in the back of, but still quick. I nearly went for a Spec-B Legacy but the fuel economy was nearly as bad as the Monaro.
I think most of the alternative options, offered up so far, have been completely irrelevant (old 9th hand Ferrari’s and 6 previous owner V8 BMW M5's). And others have been missing the point slightly (Gimprezza's with cheap fixtures and heavy running costs and so forth).
BUT the VRS I think is a very credible and direct alternative, not sure about being half price (if we are talking 'new' cars, as they are £20K but you pay less, get everything you would love about the VW and then some......

Ok, so you may have a little more badge kudos from the Volkswagen, but that comes from the GTI tag, not the VW badge, and VRS cars are quickly getting a little bit of a cult status of their own.



Edited by richard300 on Wednesday 14th December 18:31

thewheelman

2,194 posts

174 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
P I Staker said:
thewheelman said:
No, it does say it handles "like a Golf" while spinning the rear wheels of a 1 series. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omAwEPbHmV0



Hes in a Honda Civic.



ETA: Enough of this, back on topic.
You fail to see the point, Call yourself a ph'er rolleyes

WCZ

10,548 posts

195 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
richard300 said:
I think most of the alternative options, offered up so far, have been completely irrelevant (old 9th hand Ferrari’s and 6 previous owner V8 BMW M5's). And others have been missing the point slightly (Gimprezza's with cheap fixtures and heavy running costs and so forth).
BUT the VRS I think is a very credible and direct alternative, not sure about being half price (if we are talking 'new' cars, as they are £20K but you pay less, get everything you would love about the VW and then some......

Ok, so you may have a little more badge kudos from the Volkswagen, but that comes from the GTI tag, not the VW badge, and VRS cars are quickly getting a little bit of a cult status of their own.



Edited by richard300 on Wednesday 14th December 18:31
how about a used Golf R as a credible alternative?

P I Staker

3,308 posts

157 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
thewheelman said:
You fail to see the point, Call yourself a ph'er rolleyes
No I don't, you where trying to say that they are completely incorrect saying the BMW is 'Like a Golf' because its RWD. I am saying they didn't say that in there advert, they said a Honda Civic was.

Call yourself a PH'er. rolleyes

va1o

16,032 posts

208 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
This thread is boring and predicable. And cars featured in the 'like a Golf' advert (from 2009?) has been covered before.

Hellbound

2,500 posts

177 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Riggers said:
PH joke fail! paperbag

Meant to write 'I thought the 1-series was FWD...?'

Oh dear oh dear ho dear oh dear....
On behalf of everyone here, we expect your resignation in the morning.

You can see ya'self out.

coffee

Edited by Hellbound on Wednesday 14th December 20:13

WCZ

10,548 posts

195 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
va1o said:
This thread is boring and predicable. And cars featured in the 'like a Golf' advert (from 2009?) has been covered before.
boring and predictable only because it's a common opinon that the VW golf has bordered into the affordable terrority of other (debatebly superior) cars, what's your point?


Morba

621 posts

178 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
thewheelman said:
Yes, it is, the point being that in the advert they claim it handles "like a Golf", when clearly the handling characteristics of fwd & rwd are quite different.
Maybe the point is a kick in the teeth to BMW because a lot of people think the 1 series is FWD (apparently). Most people, unless hammering the car, wouldn't notice the difference between front and rear wheel drive (my wife being one of them!).

hondansx

4,581 posts

226 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Can't believe the pages of moronic suggests here, especially the guy who keeps going on about Evos. I have a vision of him sitting behind his computer screen in full Mitsubishi rally regalia with a Richie Burns shrine formed of prittsticked Autosports in the background.

I fully endorse the Golf purchase. It is handsome (maybe not with the winter wheels...), yet understated. Admired by most, hated by no one. Could anyone seriously say that about an Evo? I personally wouldn't be seen dead in one, and i have no desire to attract the attention of 17 year old kids...

The Golf is also reasonable quick, yet cheap to run (lets remember, for company car drivers C02 is king) and, crucially, dependable. Again, most people like to buy a car and not have to worry about it. They are also fabulous places to sit; i'm getting the impression many haven't sampled a newer Golf; it is a cut above cars way above its price range (even an Evo!!). You also, if you so wish, can spec it up like an S-Class if you so wish.

Anyway, i'm starting to think being objective is rather wasted in this thread, so i'll leave it there. Enjoy the Golf, Riggers. I may as well through myself into the asylum now as i'm selling my 997T and going into VW tomorrow to order a new Golf R at £40k biggrin

Hellbound

2,500 posts

177 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
hondansx said:
Anyway, i'm starting to think being objective is rather wasted in this thread, so i'll leave it there. Enjoy the Golf, Riggers. I may as well through myself into the asylum now as i'm selling my 997T and going into VW tomorrow to order a new Golf R at £40k biggrin
Good man!

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 15th December 2011
quotequote all
Hellbound said:
hondansx said:
Anyway, i'm starting to think being objective is rather wasted in this thread, so i'll leave it there. Enjoy the Golf, Riggers. I may as well through myself into the asylum now as i'm selling my 997T and going into VW tomorrow to order a new Golf R at £40k biggrin
Good man!
But you can buy 4 e46 m3s for that money. Are you crazy!! wink