RE: PH fleet: Golf GTI Edition 35

RE: PH fleet: Golf GTI Edition 35

Author
Discussion

E38Ross

35,088 posts

212 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
dapearson said:
£31,000!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Surely that's 2nd hand RS4 or M3 money?
it is, but what's your point?

fking stupid people comparing old and new cars. those cars were 2x the price when new when they had a few options on them.

WCZ

10,531 posts

194 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
I'll take an S3 instead, thanks

I'd rather have a Golf R instead of an S3 though.

Garlick

40,601 posts

240 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Hellbound said:
Oh look Riggers, your car is parked next to it

Hellbound

2,500 posts

176 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Garlick said:
Hellbound said:
Oh look Riggers, your car is parked next to it
You could have been drifting sideways in the snow, but NOOOoooo....you had to go for the girly option. Pah!

Riggers

1,859 posts

178 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Hellbound said:
You could have been drifting sideways in the snow, but NOOOoooo....you had to go for the girly option. Pah!
I'll just have to dust off the handbrake on the Puma... biggrin

oO Trouble Oo

170 posts

149 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Scirroco R? A little bit more and a Golf R?

Evo X?

Can't get my head around £30k+ for this.


uncle tez

530 posts

151 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
k15tox said:
uncle tez said:
Those wheels really do kill whole look of it
would you prefer some diamond cut 40inchers?

can bet it rides and handles better on those
Would look good with the golf R wheels

Hellbound

2,500 posts

176 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
oO Trouble Oo said:
Scirroco R? A little bit more and a Golf R?

Evo X?

Can't get my head around £30k+ for this.
In the cold light of day, I personally wouldn't got for the Evo X or Impreza WRX STI.

I've only read good things about the Golf R, it's better than any GTI and in the right colour can be as understated as any other model in the range.

Compare it to a Megane 250 or even the 265, it's not that much more expensive. It's a much better product in terms of build quality and materials used, plus it's got all wheel drive. A GTI with a few options makes less sense imo.

Steff

1,420 posts

263 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Riggers said:
nick30 said:
yeh it is a lot when you can get a new 135i for that. As much as i like this car its not enough of an improvement over the Edition 30 if i was going to blow 30k on a golf it would need to be the top of the range, the R.
No doubt the 135i is a fine car (a favourite of mine in fact), but once you spec one up to the same level as the Golf you come out (according to WC?.com) with a car costing £37,485...
Don't look at what an optioned up Golf R costs then, it makes the 135i look like a bargain

Hellbound

2,500 posts

176 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Steff said:
Don't look at what an optioned up Golf R costs then, it makes the 135i look like a bargain
Totally forgot about the 135i. Is that the coupe? It would need to be the 2012 cab/coupe at this point in time, so that would be the BMW 235i.

I'm 'supposed' to be a BMW man, I should hang my head in shame!

Riggers

1,859 posts

178 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Steff said:
Riggers said:
nick30 said:
yeh it is a lot when you can get a new 135i for that. As much as i like this car its not enough of an improvement over the Edition 30 if i was going to blow 30k on a golf it would need to be the top of the range, the R.
No doubt the 135i is a fine car (a favourite of mine in fact), but once you spec one up to the same level as the Golf you come out (according to WC?.com) with a car costing £37,485...
Don't look at what an optioned up Golf R costs then, it makes the 135i look like a bargain
And hence the reason the GTi Ed 35 makes sense ...

Actually, just looked it up - a Golf R with the same spec as my Ed 35 costs £35,465. what was that about 135is and bargains? wink

Chr1sch

2,585 posts

193 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
My god those wheels look monumentally ste....

BBS-LM

3,972 posts

224 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Chr1sch said:
My god those wheels look monumentally ste....
+1

Numeric

Original Poster:

1,397 posts

151 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Have to confess we've just got a Mini JCW company car at £24k - can't work out if that is good value or ludicrous in comparison to a £31k Golf. Goes like stink though so we've forgiven it!

nickfrog

21,170 posts

217 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
dapearson said:
£31,000!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Surely that's 2nd hand RS4 or M3 money?
it is, but what's your point?

fking stupid people comparing old and new cars. those cars were 2x the price when new when they had a few options on them.
Nah it's OK to compare new to second hand. I do it all the time when buying a car and I am still alive.



dapearson

4,328 posts

224 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
E38Ross said:
it is, but what's your point?

fking stupid people comparing old and new cars. those cars were 2x the price when new when they had a few options on them.
Don't call me fking stupid mate. My point is that from a performance-per-£ point of view that money buys lots if you can avoid buying new.

Then again, fk it. Buy yourself a new one and i'll have it off you in 3 yrs with a 65% discount.

Boonster

37 posts

202 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
nick30 said:
sanctum said:
Yes it looks expensive sliding north of £30k, but the anniversary editiona have always held their value far better than the standard GTi and the improvements often make them drive a whole lot better. I remember the 25th anniversary edition, which was chalk and cheese to the box standard Gti 150.
Add that to the strong residuals of a Golf GTi and you'll find these up for contract hire for very reasonable money, I wouldn't be surprised to see one below £200 per month (+vat etc etc), which is a good target for the huge fleet market out there.
i dont think so. My Edition 30 was 24k new and i sold it at 3 years old for 10.5k.
Purchased Edition 30, 6.5k miles for £23k from dealer (full spec as ex-VW Management car), sold it (on here) 4 years later with 90k on clock for £9k, averaged 34 mpg across all those miles - hard to find better value per £ and was still a great little car even when I sold it!

antspants

2,402 posts

175 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Oohh handbags smile

Interestingly (well to me anyway) it would appear you can business lease the Ed 35 for less than a standard Gti, presumably due to better standard kit and expected residuals.


PIGINAWIG

2,339 posts

165 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Nice capable car - but 30K+? Blimey!

Evo X's can be had BRAND SPANKING NEW FROM £23k now......

Let's see how Riggers gets on with it though - I'm sure he's not gonna take the hit in depreciation.....;)

va1o

16,032 posts

207 months

Wednesday 14th December 2011
quotequote all
Good choice in car but the old winter wheels somewhat spoil the look IMO!