El Primero accuracy - what's reasonable?

El Primero accuracy - what's reasonable?

Author
Discussion

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
After a recent service my EP Zenith has settled down to a pretty consistent 7secs a day gain. When new (c8 years ago) it was accurate to within a very few seconds a month.

As it was done by LVMH as part of a repair, I do have the ability to send it back for re-regulating within the one year warranty period.

My question is, is it worth it, i.e. could they improve its accuracy to finer tolerances?

NJH

3,021 posts

209 months

Monday 16th July 2012
quotequote all
If you don't ask you don't get. Easy to regulate a watch to a particular target, its the Isochronism to achieve accuracy in different positions and temperatures that is the problem. My Tutima Nato is a case in point, it was running slow by about 10 s per day, I got Watchworks in Bristol to regulate it. Rocco put it on his timing machine and made it run 10s faster. Recently it has been running to within a few seconds per week so the regulation worked. Its Isochronism is terrible, probably as much as 30s variation across the positions but this is irrelevant to me as it runs mega accurate on my wrist. The best bit is that the whole process took make 10 minutes from handing over the watch to getting it back, adjusted and sealed. In your case though the watch is under warranty so I imagine it needs to go back to the manufacturer. It may well settle down though and +7 is getting on for borderline on spec anyway, could easily run well within spec by next month.

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Tuesday 17th July 2012
quotequote all
Thanks both - on balance I'll probably leave it and see if anything changes over the coming months.

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Friday 4th January 2013
quotequote all
Grrrr - the lower push button has fallen off again (3rd time).

Any mileage with LVMH Service Dept do you think, given they last "fixed it" less than 12 months ago, albeit we're now outside their 1 year post service guarantee period.

GC8

19,910 posts

190 months

Saturday 5th January 2013
quotequote all
Duval dont have an enviable reputation. Id try soemwhere a little better, like Steve Burrage at Ryte Time.

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Saturday 5th January 2013
quotequote all
GC8 said:
Duval dont have an enviable reputation. Id try soemwhere a little better, like Steve Burrage at Ryte Time.
I haven't been impressed TBH, but don't really fancy paying for something they haven't done properly again.

GC8

19,910 posts

190 months

Saturday 5th January 2013
quotequote all
I understand, but Id be looking to draw a line under it. Whilst youll be paying youll be getting a far higher standard or service and repair.

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Wednesday 28th September 2016
quotequote all
Thought I'd drop back onto my old EP thread to ask another question.

The lower pusher pinged off again. No problem really, but this time I couldn't find the tiny return spring that sits underneath. I've just had a quote to replace it: £126... Reason? It only comes as a unit with both the pusher and the spring.

Any idea whether the spring is a generic item that I might be able to pick up elsewhere or do I have to bite the bullet and buy and what might just be, pro rata, the world's most expensive spring?

GC8

19,910 posts

190 months

Thursday 29th September 2016
quotequote all
If this was my watch, Id now be sending it to Joe Horner at Anglesey Clock and Watch. I suspect that all independents might struggle to obtain the parts though.

Bonefish Blues

Original Poster:

26,674 posts

223 months

Thursday 29th September 2016
quotequote all
GC8 said:
If this was my watch, Id now be sending it to Joe Horner at Anglesey Clock and Watch. I suspect that all independents might struggle to obtain the parts though.
I agree - cartels R us makes this an issue, which is why I was wondering if the spring is unique to El Ps or a bought-in item, in which case there's a chance?

glazbagun

14,279 posts

197 months

Saturday 1st October 2016
quotequote all
Bonefish Blues said:
Thought I'd drop back onto my old EP thread to ask another question.

The lower pusher pinged off again. No problem really, but this time I couldn't find the tiny return spring that sits underneath. I've just had a quote to replace it: £126... Reason? It only comes as a unit with both the pusher and the spring.

Any idea whether the spring is a generic item that I might be able to pick up elsewhere or do I have to bite the bullet and buy and what might just be, pro rata, the world's most expensive spring?
It would depend on the pusher. Some can be disassembled and a similar spring (either new or from other dead pushers) some are sealed units which can't be taken apart. Some watches use one type, some the other and once used one and now use another.

If in your case the pusher has unscrewed itself the springs might be available if you have a tame watchmaker who's willing to do part jobs. A bit of threadlock can prevent them coming unscrewed, but then you risk breaking them when it comes time to strip the case for polishing.