Login | Register
SearchMy Stuff
My ProfileMy PreferencesMy Mates RSS Feed
1
Reply to Topic
Author Discussion

LongLiveTazio

2,521 posts

66 months

[news] 
Sunday 22nd July 2012 quote quote all
stewy68 said:
I know, but they just don't do anything for me just now. The A8 is out my range at moment and A6, although appealling is too much like the A4.
I always find it strange when people say Lexus is anodyne. They're the most idiosyncratic of all the luxo brands and tend to split opinion like nothing else. 600H is a proper bargain btw, would much rather have one than pretty much any luxury car save for a Bentley.

slippery

9,395 posts

108 months

[news] 
Sunday 22nd July 2012 quote quote all
LongLiveTazio said:
I always find it strange when people say Lexus is anodyne. They're the most idiosyncratic of all the luxo brands and tend to split opinion like nothing else. 600H is a proper bargain btw, would much rather have one than pretty much any luxury car save for a Bentley.
Agreed. The ISF might end up getting my vote instead of an XFR when the time comes, if the content of this thread is a guide to what I might find when I start looking. A colleague has just got a 60 reg XF diesel, so I will follow his progress with interest.

Contigo

1,802 posts

78 months

[news] 
Sunday 22nd July 2012 quote quote all
Jaged said:
Sounds like you may have bought an ex company car that was not driven or run in sympathetically?

When I was on the company car list, I was the only one who took it easy and ran it in slowly increasing the load and speeds. My colleagues just said "It's going back in a year, what do I care"!

Makes a huge difference ,even with modern cars.
Totally disagree, all the new cars that I've bought have been run in with a varied driving style and totally disregarding the BS that they put in the manuals. Cars need to be worked even from the first few hundred miles and varied driving is the best. Sticking under 3K rpm is just not what a modern engine needs and alot of that "run in" procedure is done on a 'bench' at the factory especially for performance cars.


bunyarra

162 posts

81 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Hmm .. odd to hear the issues.

Just turned my XF 3.0D in for an XK ; not a single problem with the car in 40k. Serene on the motorways, good turn of speed and very comfortable. And not a BMW/Audi .. major plus point.

MPG was between 35 and 49 depending on my driving style that day.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

6,536 posts

72 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
I understand all of what is being said. I know mine is likely not the same as every other XF, so I am not saying Jaguar or the model is the issue necessarily. I know it isn't a german marque, and I am well aware that there is more to a car than reliability and economy. There are many things that go together to make up experience, and the car does look great and is different from the herd, to a degree. However, I often do long journeys, and the small things really frustrate.

I'm not being a pain in the arse for the dealer, and if I am it is hardly my fault. They sold the car to the first owner, and took it as trade in. The guy went to an XJ I think. If he chopped it in because of issues then they would know and are keeping it from me. I would probably expect that, as much of a personal pain it is for me. It could well be a lemon.

Interestingly, he had it serviced way before scheduled date and miles. I had raised it with the dealer that perhaps he had thrashed the tits off it and consequently it had come up as "aggressive driving" and brought the service forward. That would not have caused these issues though (whilst clearly not great for me as a potential owner). It was immaculately presented at sale, and nothing to indicate it had been raped. It wasn't a company car.

I can't just forget about the niggles unfortunately, not everyone can do this. My personality dictates that stuff like this drives me nuts and I can't stop it bothering me. Victor Meldrew comparisons have been made previously (I'm 34 though).

I've had a few other more basic new XFs as courtesy cars and they are noticeably better (bluetooth contacts max sized a lot larger, economy more acceptable, trim seems better, touchscreen and telemetry more modern).

Thing is, I bought it because they look cheap for what they are compared to ze germans and I always put it down to imagery and brand. Perhaps the reason is more concrete.

I don't want a german car really, audis are boring to me, BMWs are very expensive. That's why I plumped for a Merc previously, but they are all very commonplace, quite clinical and not very beautiful. I just want a car that is the best of all, and it doesn't exist!
Advertisement

Deva Link

26,934 posts

114 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Blown2CV said:
I've had a few other more basic new XFs as courtesy cars and they are noticeably better (bluetooth contacts max sized a lot larger, economy more acceptable, trim seems better, touchscreen and telemetry more modern).
Sounds like you're suffering from buyer's remorse, to be honest.

You probably got yours for (I hope) half the price of a new one. If you want the latest kit then spend the extra money and buy new.

Fittster

14,934 posts

82 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
You want a luxury car that doesn't rattle and isn't german. Why aren't you driving a Lexus?

em177

1,200 posts

33 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Blown2CV said:
I understand all of what is being said. I know mine is likely not the same as every other XF, so I am not saying Jaguar or the model is the issue necessarily. I know it isn't a german marque, and I am well aware that there is more to a car than reliability and economy. There are many things that go together to make up experience, and the car does look great and is different from the herd, to a degree. However, I often do long journeys, and the small things really frustrate.

I'm not being a pain in the arse for the dealer, and if I am it is hardly my fault. They sold the car to the first owner, and took it as trade in. The guy went to an XJ I think. If he chopped it in because of issues then they would know and are keeping it from me. I would probably expect that, as much of a personal pain it is for me. It could well be a lemon.

Interestingly, he had it serviced way before scheduled date and miles. I had raised it with the dealer that perhaps he had thrashed the tits off it and consequently it had come up as "aggressive driving" and brought the service forward. That would not have caused these issues though (whilst clearly not great for me as a potential owner). It was immaculately presented at sale, and nothing to indicate it had been raped. It wasn't a company car.

I can't just forget about the niggles unfortunately, not everyone can do this. My personality dictates that stuff like this drives me nuts and I can't stop it bothering me. Victor Meldrew comparisons have been made previously (I'm 34 though).

I've had a few other more basic new XFs as courtesy cars and they are noticeably better (bluetooth contacts max sized a lot larger, economy more acceptable, trim seems better, touchscreen and telemetry more modern).

Thing is, I bought it because they look cheap for what they are compared to ze germans and I always put it down to imagery and brand. Perhaps the reason is more concrete.

I don't want a german car really, audis are boring to me, BMWs are very expensive. That's why I plumped for a Merc previously, but they are all very commonplace, quite clinical and not very beautiful. I just want a car that is the best of all, and it doesn't exist!


or

635d?


Blown2CV

Original Poster:

6,536 posts

72 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Fittster said:
You want a luxury car that doesn't rattle and isn't german. Why aren't you driving a Lexus?
Fair point. Not lookers though are they? Don't see many of the hybrids about, which I always wondered about. If they are so quick and economical then why aren't other manufacturers and customers all over it?

LongLiveTazio

2,521 posts

66 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Blown2CV said:
Fair point. Not lookers though are they? Don't see many of the hybrids about, which I always wondered about. If they are so quick and economical then why aren't other manufacturers and customers all over it?
Because since when has the general public's buying habits dictated if a product is good or not? I can't believe a petrolhead would cast an aspersion based on what their neighbour thinks looks good on the drive! The fact they come top of customer satisfaction surveys says a lot, especially in the quality of their dealers. FWIW BMW, Land Rover, Audi and Mercedes are now either selling hybrids or developing them.

30k will get you into an approxed LS600h, go and drive one.

Blown2CV

Original Poster:

6,536 posts

72 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
LongLiveTazio said:
Blown2CV said:
Fair point. Not lookers though are they? Don't see many of the hybrids about, which I always wondered about. If they are so quick and economical then why aren't other manufacturers and customers all over it?
Because since when has the general public's buying habits dictated if a product is good or not? I can't believe a petrolhead would cast an aspersion based on what their neighbour thinks looks good on the drive! The fact they come top of customer satisfaction surveys says a lot, especially in the quality of their dealers. FWIW BMW, Land Rover, Audi and Mercedes are now either selling hybrids or developing them.

30k will get you into an approxed LS600h, go and drive one.
When you average it out, the market often has a good point, if not always. Anyway I just checked and a 2009 40-50k miler LS600h is at least £35k, so considerably more expensive for an older car. An equivalent age and mileage would be over £40k! I did look briefly when researching before buying the XF. I am sure they are better than anything around, hence the prices.

Caulkhead

4,938 posts

26 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Blown2CV said:
I understand all of what is being said. I know mine is likely not the same as every other XF, so I am not saying Jaguar or the model is the issue necessarily. I know it isn't a german marque, and I am well aware that there is more to a car than reliability and economy. There are many things that go together to make up experience, and the car does look great and is different from the herd, to a degree. However, I often do long journeys, and the small things really frustrate.

I'm not being a pain in the arse for the dealer, and if I am it is hardly my fault. They sold the car to the first owner, and took it as trade in. The guy went to an XJ I think. If he chopped it in because of issues then they would know and are keeping it from me. I would probably expect that, as much of a personal pain it is for me. It could well be a lemon.

Interestingly, he had it serviced way before scheduled date and miles. I had raised it with the dealer that perhaps he had thrashed the tits off it and consequently it had come up as "aggressive driving" and brought the service forward. That would not have caused these issues though (whilst clearly not great for me as a potential owner). It was immaculately presented at sale, and nothing to indicate it had been raped. It wasn't a company car.

I can't just forget about the niggles unfortunately, not everyone can do this. My personality dictates that stuff like this drives me nuts and I can't stop it bothering me. Victor Meldrew comparisons have been made previously (I'm 34 though).

I've had a few other more basic new XFs as courtesy cars and they are noticeably better (bluetooth contacts max sized a lot larger, economy more acceptable, trim seems better, touchscreen and telemetry more modern).

Thing is, I bought it because they look cheap for what they are compared to ze germans and I always put it down to imagery and brand. Perhaps the reason is more concrete.

I don't want a german car really, audis are boring to me, BMWs are very expensive. That's why I plumped for a Merc previously, but they are all very commonplace, quite clinical and not very beautiful. I just want a car that is the best of all, and it doesn't exist!
To be fair to the car, a third of those problems are very minor and a third you would've been aware of if you pushed a few more buttons on the test drive. As for reliability: http://www.whatcar.com/car-news/jaguar-tops-jd-pow...

LongLiveTazio

2,521 posts

66 months

[news] 
Monday 23rd July 2012 quote quote all
Blown2CV said:
When you average it out, the market often has a good point, if not always. Anyway I just checked and a 2009 40-50k miler LS600h is at least £35k, so considerably more expensive for an older car. An equivalent age and mileage would be over £40k! I did look briefly when researching before buying the XF. I am sure they are better than anything around, hence the prices.
I don't think the market ever has a good point, unless you like white paint and black wheels too wink

The equivalent to the XF would be the GS, I was just pointing out that the LS represents good value for money. Bear in mind it is a 90k luxury vehicle with build quality and features far beyond an XJ, much though I love my Jags. A new pre-reg GS450h is 35k, or 20k for an 09 range-topping L with 25k miles on the clock. Barely run in.
1
Reply to Topic