RE: £4m classic on the limit...

RE: £4m classic on the limit...

Author
Discussion

Itsallicanafford

2,771 posts

160 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
scholesy said:
It is odd when you think that it is really an entirely reproducible bit of metal, obviously you can't make the history and heritage that goes with it, but I know what you're saying at root. Strange things us human beings, nostalgia and provenance can make something arguably worthless, priceless, just like that, all because of an emotion.
Nicely put... it just got me thinking about this the other day…I was looking at a period photo of a 300SL gullwing, it was a stripped car, with the parts roughly assembled in the correct position. There really was not very much to add upto the current monetary valuation of the car. Metal panels, a few seats, wheels, an engine. It is a question when you look at the sum of its parts, is a car ever actually worth over a certain amount of money and what is that amount.

Motorheads

22 posts

155 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Its true you can't rationalise the value. But thats not the point. If we were rational we'd all be driving Golfs. We're not and we don't. We climb moutains, fall in love and invent iPhones. Being human isn't about being rational, thank God.

scholesy

143 posts

163 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Motorheads said:
Its true you can't rationalise the value. But thats not the point. If we were rational we'd all be driving Golfs. We're not and we don't. We climb moutains, fall in love and invent iPhones. Being human isn't about being rational, thank God.
I think it's pretty evident that everyone knows the prices for things like this aren't rational, we were just being reflective on the value of them because of the emotions surrounding them, rather than their quantifiable value.

Lawrence5

1,253 posts

236 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Nice motor - lives at JD Classics in maldon....


duncanlarke

9 posts

190 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
If that's what Itsallicanafford really thinks I don't understand why he is a member of Pistonheads,seeing as the majority of people on this site would spend their hard earned cash going to Goodwood or Le Man& the Classic to lust/drool over beautiful and expensive cars.

RichB

51,597 posts

285 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Itsallicanafford said:
...the current monetary valuation of the car. Metal panels, a few seats, wheels, an engine. It is a question when you look at the sum of its parts, is a car ever actually worth over a certain amount of money and what is that amount.
An argument which can be applied to any antique or artwork. take any of the works by the grand masters, they are clearly reproducable for a few hundred quid by a good artist so why pay millions? Because the brush strokes were laid down by Rembrandt not Ron Brown. People pay for provenance and history.

Itsallicanafford

2,771 posts

160 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
duncanlarke said:
If that's what Itsallicanafford really thinks I don't understand why he is a member of Pistonheads,seeing as the majority of people on this site would spend their hard earned cash going to Goodwood or Le Man& the Classic to lust/drool over beautiful and expensive cars.
... It doesn't have to be expensive to appreciate it, does it? SOTW tells us that.

DJRC

23,563 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
Itsallicanafford said:
duncanlarke said:
If that's what Itsallicanafford really thinks I don't understand why he is a member of Pistonheads,seeing as the majority of people on this site would spend their hard earned cash going to Goodwood or Le Man& the Classic to lust/drool over beautiful and expensive cars.
... It doesn't have to be expensive to appreciate it, does it? SOTW tells us that.
When something as beautiful as a C type and owned by Fangio appears in SOTW...let us know.

rohrl

8,740 posts

146 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
325bhp sounds very optimistic to me. Who supplied that number?

dinkel

26,957 posts

259 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all









ukmike2000

476 posts

169 months

Wednesday 21st November 2012
quotequote all
If Carlsberg made racing cars ...............

Greg348

37 posts

163 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
I did my ARDS test with Wil, and also some driver tuiton before hand. He was encouraginging me to not only use all the track(obviously), but also the kerbs in the pouring rain - even occaisionally grabbing the wheel and making me run well out onto the kerbs(almost over on a few occasions eek) - Legend smile I learnt a lot from him that day. I think we did OK as we managed to keep up with a 964 in my 110 TDI VW in the pouring rain!

Hasbeen

2,073 posts

222 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
marmite monster said:
no roll over bar eek death on a stick !
What possible use would a roll over bar be, when there are no seat belts anyway? A roll over bar would only be likely to catch & squash you, as you fell out.

I drove in the last ever propper Le Mans start in Oz, Bathurst 1964, with not a seat belt or roll over bar in sight. Also drove in the last attempt, Surfers Paradice 1968, when we were all strapped into our cars with the now mandatory seat belts, & the co-driver ran across the road with the key. Only trouble many of the cars did not have a key, just a switch, so a LITTLE cheating occured.

Was it journalistic licence or is the author that naive. Almost all the cars of that era, [my era] up to late 60s handle that way. They were easy to drive, & so much more fun, because of that.

Steering boxes may not have been very precise, but they gave full feed back. It was nice to have, but you knew the thing was going to be tail happy anyway, particularly on narrow cross ply tyres.

My ideal car was, [& still is], the XK150S. Went like stink, stopped well, & was so slow around corners, you could feel like Fangio at speeds so slow you shouldn't get hurt if you did crash it.

The best cars ever. Most drivers could handle them, with their low limit, unlike today, when most cars have a limit the average driver will never reach, PHers excepted of course.



Amizade

284 posts

226 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Lawrence5 said:
Nice motor - lives at JD Classics in maldon....

Derek has the most incredible office imaginable - how he gets any work done is beyond me !

scubadude

2,618 posts

198 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Marvelous car, epicly driven (I like how he started gently seeing as it was wet :-)

Tragic video but I think others have covered that....

Nothing sadder than a classic rusting over a full oil pan in a museam, much rather see them being ragged, it was what they where built for. Bet it looked "happy" ticking and sizzling in the rain afterwards too! :-)

techmechnw

10 posts

180 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
I reckon Nick's the hero. Being the driver's the less scary bit, but If I was driving I'd maybe have "browned out" at half of Wil's speed, certainly if a passenger.

threespires

4,295 posts

212 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
That's a fun video.
This vid is 30 secs in the famous Ian Appleyard NUB120
http://tinyurl.com/JaguarXKNUB120

sisu

2,584 posts

174 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Nice article guys but FFS what a pointless video.
Does Chris Harris have all the gopro cameras at PH? They are cheap and the more the merrier..
Why not have one looking at his feet and another in the footwell looking at him, another stuck over his shoulder loking forward.
Instead it is a pointless video of a Gopro with a suction cup stuck above the fuel tank with the sound of the car fecked


hairykrishna

13,178 posts

204 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
duncanlarke said:
If that's what Itsallicanafford really thinks I don't understand why he is a member of Pistonheads,seeing as the majority of people on this site would spend their hard earned cash going to Goodwood or Le Man& the Classic to lust/drool over beautiful and expensive cars.
Steady on. I understand what he means - it's odd in a way that such a thing's worth 4 million quid largely because of who owned it. Doesn't necessarily mean he appreciates it any less.

TIGA84

5,210 posts

232 months

Thursday 22nd November 2012
quotequote all
Top driver is Mr Arif, he helped me set my old race car up at Snett a few years ago.