RE: Personalised plates: Tell Me I'm Wrong

RE: Personalised plates: Tell Me I'm Wrong

Friday 17th May 2013

Personalised plates: Tell Me I'm Wrong

Chris Harris has a problem with personalised plates but invites you to set him right on the matter...



This is the story I promised myself I would never write. But until this point I have never enjoyed a format as flexible as this one - one which gives everyone the right to reply because the writer is merely presenting a view of a subject, as opposed to a magazine-style monologue that denies the reader an instant voice.

Yes, we know it's a 911, thank you very much
Yes, we know it's a 911, thank you very much
Here goes. I strongly dislike personalised numberplates. I have never publicly voiced this opinion because I am all too aware that a large majority of my fellow car lovers simply adore the things. I wrote a column for Autocar 10 years ago that explained my true feelings and a day before I was due to submit the copy I was at Silverstone doing a Drift School - 11 of the 18 cars in the car park had personal plates. Realising I was about to commit professional suicide, I never filed it.

I have tried to deconstruct what it is that has led to this trenchant view of cars which exhibit a more personal legal signature and I haven't yet landed upon a single, cogent reason for it. It's a combination of factors.

All about the car
The car is always the star for me. I love cars and I suppose in some small way I love the ubiquity of the normal registration number set against the often special feelings a car can radiate for its owner. The private plate contaminates the simplicity of this man/machine relationship. It could be perceived as quite perverse that someone who makes a living out of publicly talking about cars actually prefers a more internalised appreciation of vehicles, but that's the way I feel. If you are lucky enough to own an M3, I would hope that would be enough and that adding an M3 prefix to the plate wouldn't add much to the driving or ownership experience.

Press offices love novelty plates, Harris less so
Press offices love novelty plates, Harris less so
Presenting one's name, or an approximation of a name/nickname to complete strangers also strikes me as odd. Imagine walking into a restaurant and shouting 'I'm Kev' - that's what I hear when I see a personalised plate.

Natural selectionI worry for the practicalities too. I may be completely paranoid, but I think a fancy plate probably exposes the owner to a greater chance of being stopped by a police officer for a minor offence that might otherwise have been allowed to pass, and to random acts of vandalism. Again, this might be my advanced state of paranoia, but whenever I have a press car with a silly numberplate it makes me wince.

Socially, I deconstruct the application of special plates in a way that many people will find plain odd. This isn't the place to explain my odd views on the world and the universe, but even accepting the inequalities of life as being nothing more than natural selection, I find it odd that someone who is successful enough to buy a Veyron, or any other car that stops passers by from 100 yards, should feel the need to add a zany numberplate. For me it spoils the aesthetic.

Yes, that's Riggers and yes that plate says 'Lust'
Yes, that's Riggers and yes that plate says 'Lust'
The car is the star, the car draws the admiration, the plate just tips the whole effort into self-absorption. It takes things a little too far.

Personal vs private
Of course I am not immune to good numberplates - and this is probably another of my underlying issues. So many of these plates are just not cool or amusing. They are banal, not obviously explainable and when strangely spaced just look odd to my eyes. They often cheapen very desirable cars. 30 years ago there were just enough private plates around to satisfy the potential audience in the UK, and it was an audience that didn't much care about having its name (or an approximation thereof) on their cars. Nowadays, people want the personal touch and commit terrible crimes against spacing and fixings to achieve their goals.

To be clear, private plates I find a little easier to handle. Often inherited or attached to older cars that wore them in period, they can be subtle and dignified. I especially like them on old snotters - I think anyone who owns a genuinely valuable plate should always try and place it on their least valuable car.

'Performance' SUV, personalised plate - nuff said?
'Performance' SUV, personalised plate - nuff said?
I am fully expecting to have my body dismembered and burnt now. But I write this in the hope that there might just be another strange individual out there who likes a plain old numberplate.

Ducks.

 

Author
Discussion

dougisaacs

Original Poster:

24 posts

240 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Totally agree with Chris here, couldn't have said it better myself. Would you put a big sticker on the back of your car saying 'My name's __'? If not then why do the equivalent on your number plate?!

kibbbs

49 posts

199 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
This irritates you? If only my life was so rosy that this was a big enough issue to worry about.

Mr MXT

7,692 posts

284 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
dougisaacs said:
Totally agree with Chris here, couldn't have said it better myself. Would you put a big sticker on the back of your car saying 'My name's __'? If not then why do the equivalent on your number plate?!
If it made me happy then yes I would.

Ex Boy Racer

1,151 posts

193 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
P12 ICK

mrclav

1,320 posts

224 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
I'm just glad we have the right to choose Chris. I strongly disagree and you're wrong on this one IMO.

BRMMA

1,847 posts

173 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
I'm kind of in the middle on this one, I have a private plate which is a single letter, single number then my initials, it's spaced correctly and is in standard font etc, i don't love it but think it looks cleaner than the normal plate that was on the car. I however hate any plate that is badly spaced, in a crap font or has been messed with to try and read as something it clearly doesn't say

Munter

31,319 posts

242 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Is Ducks your new nickname for us?

I have one. But it came with a car. I'd have never actually gone out and got one. And I wonder how many people have been given them for a birthday/Christmas by the better half and been "forced" to fit it. A bit like wearing the Christmas jumper. But all year around, and she'll know if you bin it....

LeighW

4,419 posts

189 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Not a fan of D14ANE type plates, with itallic fonts etc, but I personally think a plate with fewer digits than the standard seven looks neater and less cluttered to me. Each to their own though - I can't see why it would or should bother you tbh?

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

207 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
kibbbs said:
This irritates you? If only my life was so rosy that this was a big enough issue to worry about.
It probably isn't his biggest worry.
But Chris' view of the situation in Syria or anitibiotic resistant bacteria is probably less relevant to a motoring website

geeks

9,210 posts

140 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
I know two people with personal plates for two separate reasons..

Plate one ends with the guys name in short form, EDY it was a gift to him so he decided to have it transferred and fitted just because he had it. He had the spacing done as per a normal plate and it doesnt look overly tacky or particularly noticeable.

Plate two is just to cover up the fact that he gets a new car every few years. Guy works in sales and doesn't want people thinking he is doing overly well when he pulls up at a customer site in what would a 6 month old Merc for example. I dont even think the plate is relevant to him just a cheap £250 jobby he got randomly from a DVLA sale

I have nothing against them but then wouldn't chose to have one either!

Dischordant

603 posts

202 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Quite often they make me smile! Most of the person's initials plates I wouldn't even know they are their initials so I don't notice them.

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

180 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Bloody hell, I agree with Harris. Never thought that would happen, what is the world coming to?

jkhamler

21 posts

163 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Just my 2¢, but I've always thought they are completely embarrassing and ostentatious. I love it when somebody with a high end sports car (who could easily pay for the A1 BAZ or whatever) just rocks the standard DVLA plate.

AC43

11,506 posts

209 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Cheap ones make me cringe.

Good ones can make me laugh.

I quite like the simpler ones on classy motors.

Wouldn't have one as I suspect I'd be more likely to be pulled and/or chased by a road rage moron.

New Scot

208 posts

232 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
They are less irritating, and sometimes more amusing, than clothing with the maker's name and/or logo emblazoned ...

Tuvra

7,921 posts

226 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
mrclav said:
I'm just glad we have the right to choose Chris. I strongly disagree and you're wrong on this one IMO.
yes

I like private plates & I like people who collect private plates. I like associating plates with people, for example one of the area's best car collections belongs to a man named affectionatley in the South Wales section as "Mr GE" because of the "GE" plates featured on his cars.

Article said:
The private plate contaminates the simplicity of this man/machine relationship
I think you have a screw lose if you truly believe this rolleyes

acme

2,972 posts

199 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Chris, you're not the only one who likes plain old number plates.

I was at a show the other week and a guy turned up in an XJ220 with a plain old K plate on it, looked fantastic in my eyes.

I just don't get the fascination with them, especially when most of the time they need to be explained, they just shout 'look at me'.......

Krikkit

26,573 posts

182 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
I think some plates look plain awful, some look great.

The cherished/private plates generally look decent, i.e. Having 52A on something nice doesn't spoil it.

BUT most personalised plates are naff, very naff.

Also, at the mega-car end of the market the plates are done to add another personalised, expensive touch. Anyone with £1m can buy a Veyron, but to put 1V on it or something? No.

BrightonEd

76 posts

162 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
I'm of the opinion that if it relates to the car then it's okay, if it's about you, less so. Dodgy spacing and bolts in the wrong place, also wrong.

I've happened to have bought a few cars with model-related plates already on them (911, M3, M5) and it seemed churlish to remove them, so I've kinda come round to the idea.

My girlfriend (Rebecca) has a plate (on retention currently) that reads W1 BEX. I find this offensive, but on her Polo GTI it did look quite cheeky I suppose. Perhaps girls can pull off 'me' related plates better?

sugerbear

4,070 posts

159 months

Friday 17th May 2013
quotequote all
Private plates = Drug dealer/Money launderer/Bank Robber

It also makes things much easier for the police.