Which Cheap to Run, Reliable Shed?

Which Cheap to Run, Reliable Shed?

Author
Discussion

GreatGranny

9,128 posts

227 months

Thursday 1st August 2013
quotequote all
Don't think you can be too fussy with specific makes and models at that budget.

Decide what type of car you want, sounds like the Mondeo type is ideal, and then find the best example. Sounds easy :-)

I would stick to petrol, alot less to go wrong and look in local papers and newsagent windows, always a bargain there.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

210 months

Thursday 1st August 2013
quotequote all
as above stick a max price max mileage and any other restrictions in Autotrader then see what comes up at the bottom of the market you can either be buying a shed that's being ditched because there is one too many bills or a much loved vehicle that the owner is now in a position to replace.

eltax91

9,893 posts

207 months

Thursday 1st August 2013
quotequote all
trumptriple said:
Almera or Tino, I've had one of each and the Tino is very practical with good standard equipment. Cam chain engine, easy and cheap to service, tend not to have been abused.
Yeah, this is what I pushed my MiL into several years ago, and the be honest it's been totally faultless until last month. It then started missing under load and threw the engine management light on. It's the 1.5 Nissan engine, with what has transpired to be a Renault-sourced faulty timing chain, which stretches! Apaarently very common in the high 30k's mileage wise.

Such a shame as it's ruined her opinion of Nissan, she steadfastly refuses to have another, as it's essentially scrap at 38k miles due to it's relatively low value and high cost to fix.

curlie467

7,650 posts

202 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Has your Mondeo been good to you? If it has and you know the car well then I would consider doing the repairs it needs.
You don't have to do it all at once, just bit by bit.

RizzoTheRat

25,191 posts

193 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
beko1987 said:
Citroen ZX. 1.9d will give you almost unparralelled fuel economy, and you won't care where you leave it parked!
I used to find my 1.9TD used less fuel than the 1.9D the garage would lend me when mine was in for a service, mainly because on the motorway I had to have my foot flat the floor the whole time to maintain somewhere near 70mph, while the TD would happily cruise along at 70+ with just a light touch on the throttle.

Certainly cheap to run though, I did 100k miles in 3.5 years and it made me 9p/mile profit biggrin As for reliability, until the radius arm bearings failed at 196k miles the only non consumables I'd had to change had been the power steering pump, brake ballancing valves, and horn.

LuS1fer

41,140 posts

246 months

TameRacingDriver

18,094 posts

273 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Reliable = Japanese

So, Primera, Avensis, Accord, etc you get the idea.

Markhoskins

109 posts

130 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
T
TameRacingDriver said:
Reliable = Japanese

So, Primera, Avensis, Accord, etc you get the idea.
Yip.cars from Japan right?

Eth2312

332 posts

162 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Has to be a Honda Civic Aerodeck!!

I did this last year. My current car was going to cost a small fortune to fix so got rid and decided to step into the shed world for once, did exactly this and looked around for some good recommendations, Honda's and Nissan Micra's were coming back on top by miles.

Did as suggested and bought an N reg Honda Civic, drove it for an entire year hassle free, cannot believe how reliable it was, basically a years free motoring and all it cost me (apart from purchase price which was a lot less than fixing my current one) was the tax for the year.

The VTECS are great engines and known for being reliable, estate too! As its an "Old" car its dropped into a slightly higher tax bracket (assuming emissions etc are not as good as new cars these days) and fuel usage is average, just over 400 miles out of a full take driven sensibly.

Well worth a look!




beko1987

1,636 posts

135 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
beko1987 said:
Citroen ZX. 1.9d will give you almost unparralelled fuel economy, and you won't care where you leave it parked!
I used to find my 1.9TD used less fuel than the 1.9D the garage would lend me when mine was in for a service, mainly because on the motorway I had to have my foot flat the floor the whole time to maintain somewhere near 70mph, while the TD would happily cruise along at 70+ with just a light touch on the throttle.

Certainly cheap to run though, I did 100k miles in 3.5 years and it made me 9p/mile profit biggrin As for reliability, until the radius arm bearings failed at 196k miles the only non consumables I'd had to change had been the power steering pump, brake ballancing valves, and horn.
Will bear that in mind! If the XM ever explodes I'll jump back to a ZX straight away!

Darbo

6 posts

240 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
eltax91 said:
Octavia TDi, ALL.... DAY..... LONG
agreed
50+ mpg and sub £1k

edit to say mines a estate 495000 miles done its hammered but keeps plugging away 1.9td vw engine
parts are cheep
and you can leave it anywere not like anyones gonna nick it


Edited by Darbo on Friday 2nd August 14:07

TameRacingDriver

18,094 posts

273 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Designed by Japanese companies in Japan, presumably. I have no problem with buying a British built product.

Project C

Original Poster:

739 posts

206 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
curlie467 said:
Has your Mondeo been good to you? If it has and you know the car well then I would consider doing the repairs it needs.
You don't have to do it all at once, just bit by bit.
If it wasn't for the clutch I wouldn't even think about changing as it's not missed a beat in the 18mths or so I've had it. So I'm not going to rush in to changing before the MOT ends in September - if I can't find something before then I'll fix it.

Project C

Original Poster:

739 posts

206 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Darbo said:
agreed
50+ mpg and sub £1k

edit to say mines a estate 495000 miles done its hammered but keeps plugging away 1.9td vw engine
parts are cheep
and you can leave it anywere not like anyones gonna nick it


Edited by Darbo on Friday 2nd August 14:07
Don't diesels have potential big issues with dual mass flywheels or something?

curlie467

7,650 posts

202 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Project C said:
curlie467 said:
Has your Mondeo been good to you? If it has and you know the car well then I would consider doing the repairs it needs.
You don't have to do it all at once, just bit by bit.
If it wasn't for the clutch I wouldn't even think about changing as it's not missed a beat in the 18mths or so I've had it. So I'm not going to rush in to changing before the MOT ends in September - if I can't find something before then I'll fix it.
Yes, bung it through it's MOT as soon as you can (it will say on the cert what date is the earliest), see how it goes, if it passes then get the clutch done.
That is what I tend to do with my cars.

Because sods law states that if you sell a car because of a knackered clutch you will replace it with one with a knackered clutch.

mrpushrod

68 posts

139 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
I've got a Primera and cannot fault it apart from town MPG which isn't great. The 5 door has loads of room and the estate is even bigger. Just make sure you stick to the ones Renault didn't have a hand in, the P12 is a big no but a P11 or P11-144 would be worth a look.

eltax91

9,893 posts

207 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
Project C said:
Don't diesels have potential big issues with dual mass flywheels or something?
Yes. But the pd engine can be changed for a single mass one for under £300. Did it on the wife's Audi, worked fine

Vince70

1,939 posts

195 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
How about an Audi A4 B5 its basically the same motor as the passat and Octavia mentioned earlier but a bit better screwed together and galvanised so it won't rust.
Also cheap enough for parts and the B5 is now cheap to buy.

caprirob

263 posts

146 months

Friday 2nd August 2013
quotequote all
If you need an estate absolutely go for the Volvo V40

You can buy the petrol ones for buttons

Only significant common mechanical issue is a noisy VVT pulley

Bought my 1.8 a few months ago for £600 and its a brilliantly capable daily driver - not fast by any means but does absolutely everything I need it to do and returns 30mpg plus.