Aftermarket HID headlights - 35W or 55W

Aftermarket HID headlights - 35W or 55W

Author
Discussion

jones325i

755 posts

154 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
I fitted a 35W kit to my previous car (BMW E36) with very good results. I used them for about 6 years and in that time had to replace one ballast at a cost of about £30.

My colleague put a set on his vomitC4 Grande Picasso (2011) and wasn't impressed so maybe there isn't so much room for improvement on modern units, who knows.

Glad to head you're going for 4300k for maximum lumen output.

Previous said:
4300K = Best for illumination
6-8000K = Best for McDonalds car park.
Indeed. The higher temps are achieved through filtering the light through a blue coating, so less light passes through in total. The high temps look awful on an older car in my opinion.

Edited by jones325i on Thursday 30th January 08:32

jkh112

22,070 posts

159 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
4300k refers to the colour of the light, not the lumen output.

jones325i

755 posts

154 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
jkh112 said:
4300k refers to the colour of the light, not the lumen output.
Yes I know, see my post above.

VeeDub Geezer

461 posts

155 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm a convert to Osram Nightbreaker (plus) bulbs.

I've heard the hype for years but only recently took the plunge after seeing them come up on eBay at £12.95 delivered a pair.

Made a massive and noticeable difference to my car's light output.

Depending on the car, you may also benefit from fitting relays to the light loom. The difference with a relayed loom on my Corrado was night and day. Literally.

OriginUnknown

15,246 posts

201 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
jones325i said:
Indeed. The higher temps are achieved through filtering the light through a blue coating, so less light passes through in total. The high temps look awful on an older car in my opinion.
Wrong - the colour temperature is achieved through using different blends of salt in the bulb capsule.

As for HIDs that produce too much glare - this is usually because of two things,

1] For H4 'bi-xenon' bulbs, the bulb is usually missing a small reflector mounted close to the bulb itself. If you look at various kits, you will see some have this little reflector and some don't - the difference is either a sharp cutoff (good quality bulb), or a blurred 'messy' cutoff (cheap rubbish from eBay bulb).

2] For H7 fitments, there are two types of HID bulb on offer. H7 and H7R - again, similar to the H4 bulbs, the H7R bulb is for reflector (traditional) type housings (there is a reflector mounted on the bulb itself to guide the light), and the H7 is for projector type housings (no bulb reflector). Of course, most people don't realise this or bother to do their research, and end up with the wrong bulbs.

If you get a good quality HID kit, there is no reason why it'll be any 'worse' than a modern vehicle with OEM HID's. Some modern cars headlights are quite dazzling, i.e Range Rovers in particular. The trick is, don't look directly at the light!


Edited by OriginUnknown on Thursday 30th January 10:28

Captain Muppet

8,540 posts

266 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
eldar said:
Worst is fecking motorbikes with HIDs. Lunatics.
Again it depends on whether it's a reflector or projector, and whether the headlamp is aligned properly.
I have a set of HID bits that I took off my E36 (I find the standard E36 light adequate) and I've been toying with fitting one to my ZX7R since even with an OEM projector headlight "upgrade" the illumination isn't great. The thing that puts me off is that regardless of how bright the lights are when turning a corner on dipped beam you have zero illumination in the direction you are going (and it's impossible to avoid dazzling on-coming drivers when turning left).

What I really need is some sort of gyro stabalised steerable headlight.

MC Bodge

21,657 posts

176 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Captain Muppet said:
What I really need is some sort of gyro stabalised steerable headlight.
For mountain bike night riding I use a Cree LED mount with a helmet mount. The directional ability makes up for a lot. I've never used similar on a motorbike, but the brightest LED available in a spot lamp on the helmet, powered from the bike might be good on dark roads

julianm

1,542 posts

202 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
This bloke is referring to the situation in the USA but it is nice to have info from someone who knows what he is talking about.
http://www.danielsternlighting.com/tech/bulbs/Hid/...

anonymous-user

55 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
I suspect those who say I have never flashed probably don't realise the person they dazzled is probably concentrating madly on avoiding a head on crash rather than flashing their main beams. The people who fit HID's in reflector head lamps should be slung in the clink and made to eat the bulbs and ballasts they fitted.

StefanVXR8

3,603 posts

199 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
eldar said:
Mr2Mike said:
Badly/incorrectly fitted HIDs (most always in reflector headlamps) are massively dazzling. I don't see how there can be any debate on that.
Worst is fecking motorbikes with HIDs. Lunatics.
No, trucks with HIDs because of the height, seen a few recently and they are particularly dazzling.

I have HID kits in both my main cars, the VXR8 and the Rover 75, both with projector lenses. I wouldn't contemplate fitting them to standard lenses.

My 4300K kit in the Rover used to be in the VXR8 but when I bought a new VXR8 I got a dedicated Holden Commodore kit which has the ballast built in to the cap. These came with 6000K bulbs and there is a very distinct difference in light output reduction over the 4300K ones, I have a pair of 5000K bulbs on the way for the VXR8 to give me a bit more light.

The VXR8 passed the MOT fine with no levelling or washers. The Rover 75 has washers and manual levelling but again I don't anticipate any issues come MOT time.

I've read that there's not much difference between 35W and 55W? Mine are both 35W and no complaints on either, a massive improvement in light, as mentioned above projectors and halogen don't produce a particularly bright output. Philips NightVision/Osram NightBreakers help but are no match for the output of properly adjusted HID.

Stef

Edited by StefanVXR8 on Thursday 30th January 20:02

ahenners

598 posts

127 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
As already said, go with 35w 4300k in projectors. Get the alignment checked after and you'll have no issues.

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

189 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
I've fitted a set of 35 Watt to my daughters boyfriends BMW E39.

Fantastic things, his are of course projector lights, and correctly adjusted.

FatSumo

15,077 posts

170 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Mr2Mike said:
okie592 said:
Don't listen to the people on here that say they burn your retinas, they say the same about DRLS and led breaklights they just like a good grump.
Badly/incorrectly fitted HIDs (most always in reflector headlamps) are massively dazzling. I don't see how there can be any debate on that.
yes

Some chav in a BMW had some purple coloured ones fitted and I could barely see where I was going until I turned on our spotlights.

I think he might still be melted to his steering wheel in the Basingstoke area getmecoat

Captainawesome

1,817 posts

164 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
Some previous owner put HIDs on the main beam of my M3. They are bloody awesome. Leant it my mate the other day and he was raving about them for days. They are the ultimate.

OriginUnknown

15,246 posts

201 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
julianm said:
This bloke is referring to the situation in the USA but it is nice to have info from someone who knows what he is talking about.
http://www.danielsternlighting.com/tech/bulbs/Hid/...
That's just another opinion leaning towards the 'oooooh, don't do it' slant. I guess this pleases you more than someone saying, 'actually they're fine, if done properly and with the right, good quality bulbs' which is fine.
As I said above, for H7 fitments in reflector housings, it's important to get the H7R kit. A lot of people don't know this. Fitting a normal H7 HID in a reflector housing will cause light scatter. Of course, this is simply wasted light that annoys on coming drivers.
Decent H4 bulbs also should have a reflector fitted, but a lot don't.


A900ss

3,253 posts

153 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
OriginUnknown said:
julianm said:
This bloke is referring to the situation in the USA but it is nice to have info from someone who knows what he is talking about.
http://www.danielsternlighting.com/tech/bulbs/Hid/...
That's just another opinion leaning towards the 'oooooh, don't do it' slant. I guess this pleases you more than someone saying, 'actually they're fine, if done properly and with the right, good quality bulbs' which is fine.
As I said above, for H7 fitments in reflector housings, it's important to get the H7R kit. A lot of people don't know this. Fitting a normal H7 HID in a reflector housing will cause light scatter. Of course, this is simply wasted light that annoys on coming drivers.
Decent H4 bulbs also should have a reflector fitted, but a lot don't.
What is you recommended kit for a H4 or H7 in a reflector housing?

PanzerCommander

5,026 posts

219 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Ignore the nay sayers and fit them if you want just be aware they aren't technically legal and depending on your MOT tester they may or may not pass.

You want a 4300k 35W kit, as another poster have said the 4300k provides the best illumination, I certainly wouldn't go over 5000k as they will start to look blue. the 55w kit are great if you want to use the car only off road at night but I wouldn't recommend them for road use as they will be far to bright.

http://www.vvme.com/

Make good kits, they are low cost and they mark the price of the contents down on the invoice so you don't end up paying import duty and VAT smile (or they did when I ordered). These kits also come with everything you need and are plug and play with no cutting of the cars electronics.

If you have a standard headlight you can use HID bulbs, but I wouldn't recommend it if the light units lens is an older glass one with a diffuser pattern in it because that (other than them being badly adjusted) is what dazzles other road users.

Edited by PanzerCommander on Friday 31st January 09:10

julianm

1,542 posts

202 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Yes, I`m sure he only knows as much as the blinding bloke I encountered yesterday in his Y reg Golf.

MC Bodge

21,657 posts

176 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I have some Ring +120% ? bulbs In my dipped beam which are very good. Similar to Nightbreaker.

I have 55 w HIDs in some add-on Hella driving lamps. When I drive other cars on dark roads I miss the HIDs

jones325i

755 posts

154 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
OriginUnknown said:
jones325i said:
Indeed. The higher temps are achieved through filtering the light through a blue coating, so less light passes through in total. The high temps look awful on an older car in my opinion.
Wrong - the colour temperature is achieved through using different blends of salt in the bulb capsule.
Fair enough, I'm not a bulb nerd. It still reduces the output though, doesn't it?